
Road transport plays a key role in the European supply chain and accounts for three-quarters of the European Union’s (EU) inland freight transport. The last decade has shown that transport companies from Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries lead the way in international transport. Now, EU regulations will be a significant barrier to the development of this market for many European countries.
According to the latest Eurostat data, in 2019, road transport accounted for 76.3% of total inland freight transport, followed by rail (17.6%) and inland waterways (6.1%). Since 2012, its share in total freight transport in the EU has been slowly increasing. Road transport in absolute terms in the EU amounts to 13.42 billion tonnes, or 1.765 trillion tonne-kilometres. Furthermore, it is an important sector of the economy, generating about 2% of the EU’s GDP and employing 5 million people.
These few figures alone show how large and important road transport is. In the coming years, this industry will face many challenges. For example, many carriers are still struggling with the negative effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and are trying to adapt to a completely new situation. However, the biggest challenge they will soon have to face is the new European Union law regulating many issues related to road transport. These new regulations are combined in the Mobility Package. It is a set of rules governing commercial road transport in the European Union, collected in three initiatives. Mobility Packages 1, 2, and 3 were issued in May 2017, November 2017, and May 2018, respectively. The package covers a wide range of issues, including the posting of workers, access to the road transport market, road tolls, driving and rest time rules, vehicle taxation, and CO2 standards.
As stated on the European Commission’s website: “The new rules will improve working conditions for drivers, introduce special rules for the posting of drivers in international transport, and update the rules on access to the transport market.” The new law aims to harmonize and simplify regulations, resulting in better, more consistent enforcement across all countries, promoting social justice, fair competition, improving environmental performance, and encouraging innovation. However, not everyone agrees with this point of view. Politicians and companies from Central and Eastern Europe strongly oppose the new law prepared by the European Commission. In January 2019, Central and Eastern European countries organized a protest in Brussels with banners reading: “Where is the EU? Only in the West?” or “Abuse package for Eastern transport.” Subsequently, in March 2020, Poland, Romania, Hungary, Bulgaria, Lithuania, Latvia, and Malta (Belgium joined later) appealed to the European Commission and the European Parliament to stop work on the new regulations. These acts of opposition did not change anything, but attempts to influence lawmakers continued. A few months later, on July 1, the aforementioned countries, excluding Belgium and this time with Cyprus, signed a petition to the European Parliament against the new regulations. One of the signatories was the Polish Minister of Infrastructure, Andrzej Adamczyk, who said that the Mobility Package is bad for the EU and its unity. So why do some countries not accept the new regulations?
Some of the changes have been in effect since August 20, 2020. One of the most important and most criticized changes is the mandatory organization of the driver’s return to the operational center (base) or the driver’s place of residence every 4 weeks. In addition, from 2022, transport operations will have to be organized in such a way that the obligation to return the vehicle to one of the operational bases in the carrier’s country of residence can be met at least once within 8 weeks from the date the vehicle leaves the country. This issue raises many controversies. It stands in clear contradiction to the EU’s climate protection policy and the associated reduction of greenhouse gas emissions. In 2015, about 23% of all vehicle-kilometres travelled by heavy goods vehicles in the EU were empty runs. Many stakeholders emphasize that the proposed regulations will increase empty runs and, consequently, increase CO2 emissions. It is also worth mentioning that even the European Commission recently published a study that confirms the reported concerns. As we can read there, “the obligation to return the truck will lead to inefficiencies in the transport system and an increase in unnecessary emissions, pollution, and congestion.” The study found that these two provisions could cause up to 3.3 million additional tonnes of CO2 emissions per year, while up to 704 additional tonnes of nitrogen oxides (NOx) and 251 tonnes of particulate matter (PM2.5) will be released into the atmosphere solely as a result of these two provisions of the Mobility Package. Following this document, associations of Bulgarian, Hungarian, Lithuanian, Polish, and Romanian carriers asked the EU Commissioner for Transport to “urgently cancel the mandatory return of trucks home every 8 weeks.”
Currently, the transport industry is responsible for 25% of total greenhouse gas emissions in the EU. There is a broad consensus that we should reduce CO2 and other gases emitted into the environment. As we can state in the EU Green Deal, the goal is to achieve “a 90% reduction in transport-related greenhouse gas emissions by 2050.” With this in mind, it must be stated that the proposed regulations are inconsistent with the goals promoted by the EU.
Another change is the tightening of rules regarding reduced weekly rest periods. The rules on mandatory regular weekly rest will mainly affect carriers working on longer distances, who will have to drive longer, spend more on fuel, and use more accommodation during work. Also important in this matter, as pointed out by PwC (in the “Transport of the Future” report), is that “there is a lack of sufficient accommodation infrastructure connected to the road network across Europe, especially along major transport routes.”
Another important issue relates to the tightening of remuneration rules for part of international transport. Previously, the minimum wage was paid, but according to the directive, an “equal pay” system is to be introduced. To correctly calculate employee remuneration, it will be necessary to apply:
– the law of the host country,
– general implementing rules – the Posting of Workers Directive,
– local administrative regulations,
– industry regulations and trade union collective agreements,
– arbitration awards.
Typically, drivers receive a daily allowance and a lump sum for accommodation. However, given local regulations and the rules of the Mobility Package, many countries will not be able to include these allowances in the “standard remuneration.” Therefore, it is estimated that after the Mobility Package enters into force regarding the posting of workers, labor costs for entrepreneurs from CEE countries may increase by as much as 30-40 percent. This is not good news for countries that compete effectively with entities from the West mainly due to lower labor costs.
Other changes, whose effective date is the same as for the posting of workers regulations, include changes in reporting obligations. When posting a worker, the carrier will have to send a notification containing specific information, such as carrier details, contact person details, driver details and their driving license number, employment contract information, start and end date of the posting, registration numbers, and type of transport performed. These changes will certainly be a challenge for many transport companies, as they will require knowledge of foreign law and industry regulations, which will make it difficult to calculate the driver’s remuneration. This will involve more bureaucracy, the need to hire new reporting staff, as well as tax specialists and lawyers.
Another argument of the opponents of the Mobility Package is that it would disrupt the EU single market. The former Chairman of the Committee on Budgets in the European Parliament, Janusz Lewandowski, described the new law as contrary to the idea of fair competition in a free market. Even more firm is the position of the European Centre for International Political Economy (ECIPE). This non-profit policy think tank wrote: “The latest proposals of Mobility Package 1 show that ‘free movement of labor’ and ‘free movement of services’ – two terms often used in defense of the European single market – have been relegated to empty phrases.”
The above change in remuneration applies to cross-trade transport (international road transport between two different countries performed by a road vehicle registered in a third country) and cabotage (road transport by a vehicle registered in a country performed on the territory of another country). To better understand why the new law most affects Central and Eastern European countries, we can look at Eurostat statistics, which include the 5 countries with the highest number of foreign truck registrations active in each EU territory. It is difficult to find any Western country there. Also, in 2018, the three largest countries responsible for cross-trade transport in the EU were Poland, Lithuania, and Romania, with shares of 33%, 14%, and 12% of the total number, respectively, followed by Slovakia, Bulgaria, Slovenia, and Hungary. Poland dominated in cabotage transport – 39%, followed by Lithuania and Romania – 9% each.
It should also be emphasized that for some countries, road transport is much more important than for others. For example, in Bulgaria, the transport sector accounts for 15% of GDP, and in Lithuania 13%. The negative effects of the Mobility Package are analyzed by many experts and researchers. In 2019, one of the largest consulting firms, KPMG, presented a report on the effects on the Bulgarian economy. International road transport in Bulgaria generates about 6% of GDP. In 2018, the industry achieved a turnover of almost 3 billion euros. As we read in the report, “36% of currently operated trucks will cease operations in the country if the full scope of regulatory changes is implemented.” This could threaten 14,000 employees (drivers, administrative staff). Estimates of this kind have been and are being made in many countries. Last year, the National Union of Road Hauliers of Romania (UNTRR) predicted that “Within the next two years, Romania will lose more than 5% of its GDP due to the migration of international road transport.” Furthermore, Dr. Błażej Suproń from the West Pomeranian Voivodeship (West Pomeranian University of Technology in Szczecin) pointed to low margins in the transport industry; in his scientific article, he states that “even a small increase in operating costs can lead to the insolvency of many enterprises that have been operating at a break-even point in recent years, characterized by a high level of debt due to investments.”
The regulations contained in the Mobility Package will be a development obstacle for many companies, especially from Central and Eastern Europe. Some of them, most often smaller entities, may even go bankrupt. The larger ones may consider moving their operations to other EU countries, in particular to Germany. In general, transport companies from Central and Eastern Europe are smaller than their counterparts in the West. The effect of the EU changes may be the concentration of the industry. German logistics authority Prof. Peter Klaus shows in the report “Mobility Package I: Impact on the European Road Transport System” that this will significantly increase the overall costs of the European international road transport system and reduce efficiency.
The Mobility Package involves many changes awaiting carriers. The above describes the most controversial and widely discussed ones in the transport industry. It is worth emphasizing that this short article was not intended to question the initial desire to increase road safety and improve working conditions for drivers. However, it is impossible to shake the impression that some of the changes are political in nature as an attempt to curb the expansion of companies from Central and Eastern Europe. The exact effects of the regulation can only be estimated a few years after its introduction. Let us hope that some of the proposals can still be adjusted to jointly develop transport, increase the competitiveness of the EU, and take care of the natural environment.







