Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 3

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise - a case study - part 3

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 1

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 2

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 4

In turn, percentage evaluation allows for classifying a supplier into the category of qualified or reserve suppliers, or completely excluding a candidate from consideration. An example of a division into supplier evaluation categories can be found, among others, in [42].

The results obtained using the point method can be clearly presented in a graphical form [7]. On the other hand, the categorical method is the simplest method of supplier evaluation and selection. It consists of assigning one of the ratings [good (+); neutral (0), unsatisfactory (-)] to individual supplier evaluation criteria and summarizing the achieved results [17, 26].
Another method allowing for multi-criteria evaluation and selection of a supplier is the out-ranking matrix model. In this method, in the first step, the values of selected criteria for individual suppliers are determined. Next, a matrix of dependencies between pairs of suppliers and selected evaluation criteria is determined. Based on this, a result matrix is developed, indicating which of the suppliers best meets the individual criteria among all of them [36].
Models based on the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) evaluation constitute another group of methods. In this method, the total sum of financial outlays related to acquiring, using, or maintaining supply materials or services over a given period of time (for example, costs of poor quality, transport costs, costs of delayed deliveries, ordering costs) is taken into account when choosing the right supplier [11]. The application of this model requires the enterprise to implement the Activity Based Costing (ABC) method of business process cost management [26]. Examples of the application of ABC and TCO methods can be found, among others, in works [26, 32]. In work [12], the authors proposed a model for supplier evaluation and selection based on the use of the ABC method and linear programming.

Over time, the issue of supplier selection began to be treated more comprehensively. The necessity to take into account a larger number of evaluation criteria and to consider many alternative suppliers forced the development of more extensive/detailed methods, such as mathematical programming [28] or statistical models, which are rarely used in practice [28].
The penultimate group of supplier evaluation and selection methods are models based on the use of artificial intelligence. In this area, artificial neural networks are applied (for example, work [1], in which this method was used to evaluate and select contractors in a construction company).
Furthermore, the indicator method of supplier evaluation and selection is worth noting. This method allows for the evaluation of suppliers based on quantitative and qualitative indicators characterizing the spheres of cooperation between the supplier and the recipient. Selected logistics metrics and indicators allow for drawing attention to a problem, but they do not explain the causes of the situations that have occurred. Implementing supplier evaluation using the indicator method requires an analysis of the occurrence of individual deviations.

The article comes from the “Logistyka” magazine 5/2012.

L2012-5s21.pdf