Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 1

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise - a case study - part 1

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 2

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 3

Methods of supplier evaluation and selection in an enterprise – a case study – part 4

Supply chain efficiency cannot be considered without taking into account one of its key elements – the purchasing function. This is due to the fact that purchasing decisions affect material costs, achieved profits, and the possibility of applying logistical management concepts, such as JiT or outsourcing.

The process of selecting and evaluating suppliers is one of the most important aspects of an enterprise’s operation. In the past, many companies used standard rules when selecting suppliers, and the lack of accurate evaluation led to many decision-making errors. Over time, the significant impact of choosing the right suppliers on the entire enterprise’s operations was recognized. Expanding the analysis to detailed criteria with assigned weight values for the company allows for a clear picture of cooperation with individual firms. In commercial activities, methods based on habits or quick decisions are the most detrimental. Analyzing suppliers based on past data illustrates the fundamental errors made in acquiring products and points to new purchasing opportunities. It happens that suppliers from whom purchases were made sporadically turn out to be leaders among the entire group in light of significant criteria and the evaluation of previous cooperation. Conversely, current leading suppliers may perform poorly due to negative ratings in the most important areas of cooperation. The task of a comprehensive supplier evaluation is to draw attention to such errors and attempt to select the best suppliers according to defined selection criteria.

Currently, relationships between a supplier and a recipient based solely on price offers cannot be accepted by purchasing managers. Establishing a cooperation process involves the necessity of considering many qualitative and quantitative factors. Besides price, important factors in choosing a strategic partner include: quality, reliability, or delivery flexibility. At the same time, the complexity of the issue involves the necessity of treating the problem of supplier evaluation and selection as a multi-criteria task. To confirm this fact, one can cite a study in which 47 articles (out of 76 included in the review) concerned multi-criteria modeling. The basic elements influencing the supplier evaluation and selection process are presented in Figure 1.

In literature from the field of supply logistics, many works are devoted to the issue of supplier evaluation and selection. At the same time, fundamental problems concern, among other things, defining the relationship between the supplier and the recipient, defining supplier evaluation criteria, or choosing the appropriate supplier selection method.
One of the first works that addressed the problem of defining appropriate criteria for supplier evaluation and selection was work [13]. In this work, the author selects 23 supplier selection criteria and evaluates them according to their degree of importance for those making the selection. In a subsequent work [15], the author, in addition to presenting a literature review from the studied scientific area, analyzes the basic criteria for supplier evaluation in the case of building partnership relationships between a potential supplier and a recipient. Based on survey research among sample enterprises, a total of 15 supplier evaluation criteria were analyzed, which were classified into one of four main groups: economic criteria, organizational culture and adopted strategy criteria, technological criteria, and others.

The article comes from the journal “Logistyka” 3/2012.

L2012-3s26.pdf