Loading problems in the light of transport law: what does a carrier need to know?

Loading problems in the light of transport law: what does a carrier need to know?

Loading issues are among the key matters that must be defined before transport begins. Their details should be included in the written transport order so that, in the event of a dispute, one can refer to the arrangements. These, in turn, must comply with legal regulations – otherwise, they will not be binding. Beata Gądek, a legal advisor at TC Kancelaria Prawna, advises on what rights and obligations apply to carriers regarding the loading of goods.

A transport order, or contract of carriage, is the basis for providing services for the transport of persons or goods for remuneration. Although it does not have to be in writing, such contracts are standard, and the provisions contained therein may also concern the carrier’s obligations related to the loading of goods. Examples of such provisions state that the contractor is responsible for properly securing the cargo in the vehicle or is obliged to check the conformity of the goods with the documentation – their packaging, quantity, and visible damage to the goods during loading, or must also inform the principal of any irregularities during loading before leaving the loading site. Another example is a provision according to which the contractor is responsible for checking the condition of the cargo, the method of its loading, as well as the quantity and quality of the loaded goods.

Who is liable for damage in connection with improper loading of goods?

A written transport order is the basis for a carrier to assert their rights when loading problems arise. As a rule, it is the sender’s duty to package the shipment so that the carrier can transport it properly and deliver it without loss or damage.

– The general liability of the sender for the proper packaging of the shipment arises from both the provisions of the Transport Law and the CMR Convention. However, the parties concluding a contract of carriage may define this liability differently and burden the carrier with the obligation of properly packaging the shipment – explains Beata Gądek – Failure to perform or improper performance by the sender of the obligation to properly package the shipment may result in their liability, which is permitted by Art. 72 point 2 of the Transport Law and Art. 10 of the CMR Convention.

The sender will not be held liable only if the defectiveness of the packaging was visible or known to the carrier at the time of accepting the goods and the carrier did not include reservations regarding the packaging in the consignment note. Both circumstances must, however, occur simultaneously. According to Art. 8 paragraph 1 letter b of the CMR Convention, upon accepting the goods, the carrier is obliged to check the visible condition of the goods and their packaging, so the assessment of the correctness of preparing the shipment for transport is on their side. It is worth emphasizing, however, that the carrier does not have to possess specialized knowledge as to how the transported goods should be packaged. Their duties include assessing whether the packaging is not destroyed or damaged.

The sender is also responsible for damage if it resulted from improper loading and placement of the shipment on the means of transport, unless the parties to the contract have decided otherwise. Regardless of this, the carrier should independently – according to their own knowledge and experience – assess the method of performing these activities and consult any doubts with the sender. If, despite obvious and visible irregularities, the carrier did not include their reservations in the consignment note, they will be liable for the damage caused by them.

We will deal with yet another situation when the damage resulted from improper securing of the shipment on the means of transport. In such a situation – in the absence of different arrangements between the parties – as a rule, the carrier bears the liability. If the carrier wishes to be released from this liability, they should prove the fact of improper securing of the shipment by the sender, the existence of a causal link between the damage and the improper securing of the shipment, and also prove that the securing measures were in the proper condition.

Disputes regarding loading

In practice, cases related to the loading of goods and the consequences of their improper execution are a frequent subject of court disputes because they can be difficult to classify unambiguously. We are talking about situations such as loading and placement of the shipment performed by the carrier and the sender simultaneously, cargo securing performed by the carrier according to the sender’s instructions, or maneuvering the vehicle after partial unloading. All cases of this type require detailed analysis to determine both the person responsible for the damage and to establish which of the activities was the cause of that damage.

As an example, the expert cited a case reported to the law firm, in which damage occurred to both the goods and the vehicle – during the analysis of the case, it was determined that the transported goods consisted of several parts and were wrapped in foil as a whole. At the same time, it was properly secured with straps. However, the shipment did not tip over in its entirety – only its upper part detached, which meant that the probable cause of the damage was defective packaging. In this case, the sender was liable for both the damage to the goods and the damage to the vehicle belonging to the carrier.

Delay in loading

Transport orders sometimes very specifically define the time by which loading is to take place. The carrier’s failure to appear for loading on time may result in the imposition of a contractual penalty, provided that it has been effectively stipulated in the contract of carriage. If the contract of carriage does not specify a contractual penalty for delay in loading, the principal may demand compensation for damages from the carrier. In such a case, however, it will be necessary to prove the link between the delay and the damage incurred.

A delay in loading may also result from the improper performance of the obligation by the principal. In such a situation, the carrier will be able to charge them with the costs. The above rules apply to both domestic and international transport, to which the provisions of the CMR Convention apply.

Depositphotos 61340849 XL 750x500

Free time from charges

Transport orders often contain provisions regarding free time from charges, which affect the possibility of seeking compensation related to problems in the scope of loading. Here are examples:

  • Unless the parties agree otherwise, 24 hours (48 hours in the case of transport of non-EU goods) are free from demurrage charges during loading and unloading.
  • The time necessary for loading and unloading, as well as customs clearance in European countries, up to 24 hours, is free from additional charges. For other countries, this time is up to 48 hours. In both cases, this does not apply to non-working days.
  • The free time from demurrage charges at the Sender and Recipient is the first 48 hours on working days, Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, as well as any stop for customs clearance.
  • The principal reserves the first 24 hours of parking, as well as parking on Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays during loading and unloading as free from demurrage charges.

Such provisions in a transport order deprive the carrier of remuneration for the indicated period. For this parking time, the carrier cannot claim compensation.

– Although these provisions are not favorable to the carrier, it is difficult to challenge their effectiveness in court. It is worth remembering, however, that the content of the transport order terms was created solely by the principal and as such are subject to negotiation. Any changes to the provisions of the transport order should be clearly marked to prove a clause other than the standard parking clause – advises the expert.

Withdrawal from the contract of carriage

If the provisions in the contract of carriage are extremely unfavorable to the carrier, and the principal is not willing to negotiate, it can be terminated. The right to withdraw from it is provided for by both the Transport Law Act and the Civil Code.

According to Art. 395 of the Civil Code, the parties may stipulate that one or both parties to the contract will have the right to withdraw from the contract within a specified period. This right is exercised by submitting a statement to the other party. In the event of withdrawal, the contract is considered not concluded, the carrier is no longer obliged to transport the shipment, while the sender is not obliged to pay the freight. It depends on the parties to the contract whether the right to withdraw from the contract of carriage will be available to both the principal and the carrier, or only to one of the parties. In practice, we encounter such provisions as:

  • the parties may withdraw from the contract without any financial consequences no later than 12 hours before the planned loading
  • the contractor has the right to withdraw from the contract (cancel the order) within 3 hours of its acceptance by informing the Principal about the withdrawal via email
  • within 30 days from the date of acceptance of the order by the Contractor, until the commencement of its execution, the Principal has the right to withdraw from the Order

The most important element of a contractual provision regarding the possibility of withdrawing from the contract is indicating the deadline by which such a statement may be submitted by the authorized party.

The legal basis for issuing a statement on withdrawal from the contract at any stage of its execution may be Art. 491§1 of the Civil Code. A carrier who, for example, during loading operations discovers the lack of necessary documentation and – despite reporting it – does not receive it within the appropriate time, is entitled under Art. 491§1 of the Civil Code to refuse to perform the transport and withdraw from the contract.

However, withdrawal from the contract of carriage based on Art. 783 of the Civil Code is possible only if the commencement or performance of the transport is unfeasible due to circumstances concerning the carrier. Such a statement may be submitted by the sender, and they are obliged to settle the appropriate remuneration for the part of the transport already performed. We will deal with such a situation, for example, when during the execution of the contract of carriage the driver is stopped by the police and cannot continue the transport due to the lack of a periodic technical inspection of the vehicle.

The right to withdraw from an already concluded contract of carriage is provided for by Art. 53 paragraph 1 of the Transport Law. According to it, the sender may withdraw from the contract of carriage or introduce changes to it, demanding that the carrier return the shipment to the place of dispatch, deliver the shipment to a place other than the place indicated in the consignment note, or deliver the shipment to a person other than the recipient indicated in the consignment note.

Submitting a statement on withdrawal from the contract of carriage is the sender’s right, and the carrier cannot oppose it. At the same time, the carrier is not entitled to compensation in such a case.

– Loading issues in a contract of carriage can be a minefield for a carrier – emphasizes Beata Gądek from TC Kancelaria Prawna – That is why it is so important to pay special attention to the arrangements related to it before accepting any order. In case of doubt, it is worth seeking the advice of a lawyer who will dispel doubts regarding the compliance of specific provisions with the applicable law.

Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna