Is it profitable for small businesses to buy electric cars?

Is it profitable for small businesses to buy electric cars?

Electric vehicles can save companies 27,000 PLN per year, according to the completed “EV365” project prepared in cooperation with the Polish Alternative Fuels Association (PSPA), the EV Klub Polska Foundation, Webfleet, and the Mihiderka restaurant chain. The first annual study in Poland on the commercial use of electric-powered cars in a small business involved 4 vehicles that covered a total of 97,200 km and consumed 12,651 kWh of energy.

Soon, entrepreneurs will face the decision of electrifying their vehicle fleets. From the perspective of large companies, electrifying a car fleet is one of the points in their sustainable development strategy. Therefore, their purchase prices (which are still higher today than those of internal combustion vehicles – the weighted average for an internal combustion variant is 176,000 PLN, while for an electric one it is 270,000 PLN) or operational aspects are not the key factor in their selection. The situation is different for companies in the small and medium-sized enterprise (SME) sector, for whom costs are a priority issue.

– To prove that electric vehicles can be successfully used in small businesses and that their purchase and operation are profitable, the EV Klub Polska Foundation, together with Webfleet and in cooperation with PSPA and the Mihiderka restaurant chain, initiated the “EV365” research project. Its goal was to analyze the benefits resulting from fleet electrification from the perspective of an entrepreneur who is an electric car user. Over the year of the study, we collected a range of data, and the conclusions from their analysis confirm our conviction that the key to successful electrification is preparing the company well for this process – says Albert Kania, Senior New Mobility Manager, PSPA.

The research project on the commercial use of four electric vehicles in a small business started on May 1, 2022. Over the course of a year, the studied cars covered a total distance of over 97,000 km, and their main source of power was energy from a 50 kWp photovoltaic installation (unit: kilowatt-peak – defines the power of a photovoltaic installation). Implementing such a long-term project required the use of tools enabling constant monitoring of key operational parameters such as range, energy consumption, or battery charge level. As part of the project, a total of over 17,000 data points were analyzed, which were obtained thanks to Webfleet’s telematics systems.

– Webfleet, as one of the first telematics providers, prepared solutions aimed at electric vehicles and is systematically developing its portfolio of services for this segment. Research projects, especially those like EV365, are very valuable to us because they allow us not only to verify the utility of our solutions in real market conditions but also to identify new needs that are specific to EV fleets. Business clients are still quite reserved about electrifying their fleets, but we are convinced that by providing them with reliable and credible data and real examples, as was the case in this project, it will contribute, at least partially, to dispelling their concerns and accelerating the transformation process – says Dariusz Terlecki, Regional Director Poland & EE at Webfleet.

The role of a photovoltaic installation in an electromobile fleet

A 50 kWp photovoltaic installation produced 46,766 kWh of energy over the year. This is nearly four times more than the vehicles consumed, thereby providing the energy needed to power 82% of the charging sessions recorded during the project. Given that the installation is settled under the “Net metering” system, the costs of driving 75,500 km on an annual basis were zero PLN, which indicates how important it is to combine an electric vehicle fleet with renewable energy sources.

Energy consumption and air temperature

As part of the research work, the impact of temperature on energy consumption in electric cars was also examined as an important aspect from the perspective of planning the daily duties of employees using the vehicles. It was confirmed that the optimal temperature conditions, under which energy consumption fluctuations remain at a low level (below 0.05%), are in the 20-22°C range. A drop in temperature by every 1°C in the 20-10°C range meant an increase in the average energy consumption value by 1.4%, by 2.6% in the 11-0°C range, and by 3.1% when the temperature drops below 0°C.

Operational readiness of electric vehicles

The EV365 project aimed to answer the question of whether the time required for charging has a negative impact on the vehicle’s operational efficiency. The collected data shows that on average, for 24% of the day (5.8 hours), the vehicles were used in the company for tasks involving food delivery. For 47% of the time (11.2 hours), they were connected to a charger, but in practice, the average charging time was 2 hours and 37 minutes – points out Łukasz Lewandowski, President of the EV Klub Polska Foundation.

Consequently, the need to charge the vehicle did not affect the fleet’s efficiency in any way, and what is more, for an average of 8 hours and 35 minutes, the vehicles were connected to charging even though their battery levels indicated 100%.

– As one of the pioneers using electric cars in daily business operations, we are very satisfied with the results of the EV365 Project. It confirms our assumptions, based on which we made the decision a few years ago to strongly commit to electromobility. It is worth emphasizing that, in total, we regret a little that the program lasted only 365 days. It allowed us to meticulously analyze our actions based on an amount of data that we would not have been able to aggregate and analyze on our own. In this regard, the contribution of PSPA and Webfleet is a huge support for us, for which we thank both organizations very much. At the same time, we declare our readiness for further cooperation in similar initiatives, especially since in the meantime the fleet of electric cars in our organization (Mihiderka, NoSmog.Rent) has increased to about 30 electric cars of various brands and models – says Marcin Krysiński, co-owner of the Mihiderka chain.

Further fleet electrification

Based on the fleet of vehicles used at Mihiderka, the benefits of transforming it to electric were also determined. An internal combustion Citroën Jumper, which achieved an average daily mileage of 59.5 km, with the longest recorded daily distance being about 200 km (22% of routes on expressways or highways at a speed equal to or greater than 90 km/h), served as an example. The second example is the Citroën C4. This vehicle mainly operated on urban and suburban routes. Its average daily mileage was 31.6 km, and the longest distance was about 100 km (98% of routes on urban roads with a cruising speed of up to 90 km/h).

– The analysis showed that full fleet electrification will allow for further financial benefits for the company. Replacing the aforementioned Citroën Jumper and Citroën C4 with an electric car, thanks to large surpluses of energy from the photovoltaic installation, will allow for reducing annual fuel costs by over 15,000 PLN per year – emphasizes Albert Kania.

Source: Webfleet