Industrial design protection under industrial property law and copyright law

Industrial design protection under industrial property law and copyright law

The Polish legal system sometimes allows for the parallel application of several legal regulations to a single institution. A perfect example of this is the protection of an industrial design. This concept incorporates features of many intangible assets, including utility models, trademarks, and works of authorship. This is precisely why various protective measures provided by legal acts governing these issues can be applied to it. This form of protection is referred to as parallel or cumulative.

The foundations for this method of protection can be found in the Industrial Property Law Act (P.W.P.) and the Act on Copyright and Related Rights (in short: the Copyright Act). If we want to take advantage of parallel protection, our industrial design should therefore meet the requirements of both the P.W.P. and the Copyright Act.

Definition of an industrial design

An industrial design is a new form of a product that possesses an individual character, imparted to it by the features of lines, contours, shapes, colors, material, ornamentation, or texture. It can be an industrial or artisanal product, whether uniform or composed of components. However, a computer program will not be an industrial design.

Legal doctrine defines it, among other things, as a creative intellectual effort or the “skin” covering technology. As can be seen, it is simply the appearance – the design of a given product/creation, which is combined with technological elements.

Therefore, a candy, a dress model, a board game, or even a coat hanger can be an industrial design. As a result of technological development, such protection can also cover the compositional layout of a mobile application.

The reason for registering industrial designs is the fact that it is the attractive appearance and design that attract customers. This is the first “layer” that consumers encounter. There is no doubt that a design can have a significant impact on their purchasing decisions.

Industrial design protection under industrial property law and copyright law
Conditions for industrial design protection

According to the P.W.P. Act, there are two prerequisites for the protection of an industrial design: novelty and individuality. The conjunction “and” is significant here, as it clearly indicates that each of these prerequisites must be present in order to apply for protection.
It is worth mentioning that under the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (“TRIPS”), the World Trade Organization uses the conjunction “or” in this case. Its requirements will therefore be slightly more flexible than in Polish law.

Nevertheless, under national law, it is necessary to meet both prerequisites, namely:

  • Novelty – according to the opinion of A. Tisher, a “new” design is one that is currently unknown, but also one that is different from others. Novelty is always assessed objectively, not subjectively. As a result, it is impossible to protect two identical designs at the same time. According to administrative courts, the most important factors are the differences between designs that can be perceived by the sense of sight. Nevertheless, scientific literature also emphasizes the role of touch. There is no doubt that novelty should always be assessed in the context of the impression that the design makes on an informed user.

Importantly, the Patent Office itself does not check the novelty prerequisite ex officio. However, it must be remembered that its infringement can be raised in an opposition to registration or in proceedings for a declaration of invalidity.

  • Individuality – the prerequisite of individuality has not been explicitly described by the legislator. However, it has been accepted that this refers to a certain uniqueness or distinctiveness, which is assessed as the overall impression made on an informed user. As a result, questions arise: how large can the scope of an artist’s creative freedom be? And who will this “informed user” be?

In the case of the first question, it should be noted that the specific line of case law counts. The lower the threshold of individuality a court accepts as permissible, the fewer differences between designs must exist to meet the prerequisite. What matters is that the market is not flooded with overly similar designs, while at the same time not stifling creative thought among creators. Everything must therefore be balanced in a certain way.

An informed user is neither a layman or an unaware consumer, nor an expert/specialist in a given field. It must be someone intermediate between a consumer and an expert. For example, when a dispute concerned toy cars, a Polish court considered children to be the informed users.

Copyright protection

Copyright protection for industrial designs had its beginnings in the legal solutions of the interwar period. At that time, industrial designs were considered a category oscillating between construction and an aesthetic work.

Later, in the 1970s, the concept of a decorative design was consolidated. Emphasis was placed on a specific and original appearance while maintaining copyright protection.

Industrial design protection under industrial property law and copyright law
Conditions for copyright protection

Currently, it is recognized that an industrial design can be subject to protection under copyright law. However, it must meet three prerequisites: creativity, individuality, and fixation.

  • Creativity
    According to the opinion of intellectual property expert M. Późniak-Niedzielska: “(…) The condition of creativity is met when the author makes an effort to create an intellectual work that enriches the existing state of affairs (…)”. However, does this refer to subjective or objective novelty? Case law has provided the answer to this question. According to the Supreme Court and appellate courts, the work must be new from the creator’s point of view. However, subjective novelty does not allow the prerequisite to be considered met when it comes to performing routine tasks. It is therefore not only about using one’s knowledge, but also about “making a projection with the imagination” (J. Barta and R. Markiewicz).
  • Individuality
    A creation meets the individuality prerequisite if it is unique and has no prior equivalent. For years, concepts of statistical uniqueness, objective and subjective, have clashed. At present, it is recognized that there must be a certain scope of creative freedom and a reflection of the creator’s personality traits in a given work. Nevertheless, just as in the case of individuality in industrial property law, the final decision on this issue is always made by the judiciary.
  • Fixation
    This means incorporating the work so that there is an objective possibility of it being perceived by at least one recipient. The method of fixing the work is irrelevant. It can even be unfinished or impermanent (e.g., destroyed after presentation). The most important thing is the possibility of perceiving its aesthetic or intellectual features. It must therefore produce a certain artistic effect.