Electromobility as a replacement for fossil fuel-powered engines is sparking a heated debate. Is electricity the only clean energy option that can be used to power cars and trucks?
Roy van Son, Alternative Fuel Manager at Eurowag: The advantages of e-cars still outweigh the shortcomings, which include range and battery charging speed. If we look at freight transport, we don’t need to worry about the e-truck offering, but instead, we should worry about time, i.e., mandatory breaks for drivers. This is linked to another time-related issue, which is charging speed. No matter how fast (powerful) the charging stations we build at motorway rest areas are, the problem will persist.
According to basic math – if driving on a motorway takes at least 4.5 hours, a truck would need to be equipped with a battery with a capacity of no less than 675 kWh. To be able to charge before driving after a mandatory 45-minute break, a charging station with a power of about 1000 kW would be needed. However, long-haul transport also requires road tractors that can drive for up to 10 hours, covering about 800 km at a time. This would mean the need for batteries with a capacity of about 1500 kWh and a charging power of at least 1350 kW. We have to multiply this by several hundred trucks that can park at a motorway rest area, and it is worth noting that up to 400 trucks park at the largest motorway parking lots every night. Regardless of the charging speed, every such rest area would need to have a small power plant to meet the energy demand. Therefore, electromobility is better suited for short-haul freight transport.
In light of such calculations, it should come as no surprise that long-haul trucking companies are exploring options other than electromobility – a key one being hydrogen. It is worth noting how closely hydrogen and electric drives are linked. Hydrogen does not burn in the engine but reacts with air, producing electricity (and clean water as a byproduct). Hydrogen vehicles are therefore also powered by electric motors. However, even they cannot do without batteries, which serve as a reserve in situations where the fuel cell cannot provide enough power, especially when fully loaded sets are driving up steep hills.
All major truck manufacturers are involved in the development of hydrogen-powered trucks because their operation is practically identical to that of diesel-powered vehicles. Depending on the hydrogen pressure in the tanks, a hydrogen-powered truck can travel between 400 and 800 km, and refueling with hydrogen takes no longer than refueling with diesel. Long-haul trucks with liquid hydrogen tanks have a theoretical range of up to 1000 km.
Insufficient refueling infrastructure is the biggest obstacle to the development of hydrogen propulsion in freight transport. High storage pressures and the natural properties of hydrogen make it more difficult to handle. Of all chemical substances, hydrogen has the lowest density, and its molecules are so small that they penetrate seals in pipelines that could otherwise be safely used (for example, for natural gas).
The most developed hydrogen refueling infrastructure is currently located in Southeast Asia, and about two hundred filling stations are also scattered across Europe, mainly in Germany and France. However, there are plans to build more hydrogen refueling stations throughout the European Union, which is why it may become the fuel of the future.







