How does the assignment of receivables affect the operation of a transport company?

Freepik / Transcash

Companies in the TSL industry subject to a ban on the assignment of receivables may have difficulty effectively recovering their money, which can prove disastrous for their financial liquidity. Its guarantor is a constant inflow of funds to the account, which can be a challenge in the reality of 60-day payment terms. Additionally, many carriers operate on the verge of profitability, often agreeing to low rates just to make ends meet. In this situation, the ability to transfer the rights to receivables to another entity can be a salvation from the debt spiral associated with a lack of money in the account.

What is the assignment of receivables?

The assignment of receivables involves transferring the right to a receivable due to us to another entity. The seller and the buyer must enter into an appropriate agreement that confirms the transfer. If the debtor has not prohibited the assignment of receivables, there is no need to ask for their consent, only to inform them of the change of creditor.

In practice, the assignment of receivables is often a way to get rid of an unwanted debt or to accelerate repayment. Selling a debt to a collection agency takes place on the basis of an assignment agreement, similar to invoice financing. In the latter case, the assignment of receivables enables the disbursement of funds from an invoice before its due date.

– The assignment of receivables can be a way to improve financial liquidity, whether through selling a debt and recovering at least part of its value, or through invoice financing. Assignment also means lower business risk in the event of debtor insolvency in the case of non-recourse factoring. It allows for the transfer of full responsibility for the receivable to the factor, even in a situation where the invoice has not been paid – says Jakub Gwiazdowski, Head of Partnership and Relations at Transcash.eu.

Assignment ban in a contract – why is it used?

A ban on assignment or the lack thereof does not affect the relationship between business partners as long as their settlements are timely and cooperation is going well. The problem arises when a debt is created, and that is when the assignment ban becomes crucial. Applying it means that the creditor cannot get rid of the debt problem by transferring the rights to it to another entity. Such a situation is often associated with losses, because the sale of debt usually occurs when the creditor has exhausted all ways to recover the money. The assignment of such a receivable is usually associated with buying it back at a price significantly lower than the nominal value. For the debtor, an assignment ban can prove to be a way to further drag out the repayment period and delay debt collection. Many companies agree to such an arrangement for fear of losing a client and future orders.

– An assignment ban closes the path not only to selling receivables but, above all, to invoice financing. Consent to it is necessary to be able to use factoring, because its mechanism is based on transferring the right to the receivable from the existing creditor to the factor, i.e., the service provider, even before its payment deadline. A ban on the assignment of receivables can also close a company’s path to obtaining a loan. The institution granting it may require the transfer of rights to receivables as collateral for repayment, for which an assignment is necessary. An assignment ban is therefore a real obstacle for a company that wants to maintain financial liquidity and protect itself against late payment or its absence – Jakub Gwiazdowski.

The debtor cannot oppose the assignment of receivables that is in accordance with the law, but they are able to prevent its application. This will happen if a ban on assignment is included in the service contract and the contractor agrees to this provision.

Is the law on the side of the creditor or the debtor?

The ban on assignment in contracts has recently become a subject of interest for legislators. In 2023, an amendment to the Act on Counteracting Excessive Delays in Commercial Transactions came into force, which was supposed to change the situation of creditors. However, only a select few can benefit from its provisions. The amendment allows for the lifting of the assignment ban only when the debtor of a small or medium-sized company is a large entity. According to the new regulations, the ban can only be lifted when the creditor becomes a debtor and fails to pay the liability on time. This therefore only applies to the transfer of the right to an overdue receivable, e.g., through a sale via a debt exchange.

This does not improve the situation of companies wanting to use invoice financing before the deadline in order to obtain cash faster. Factoring only applies to invoices with an unexpired payment deadline, so the change in law does not affect the position of companies providing such services. The assignment ban can still be included in the contract and only loses its validity when a debt is created.

The debt spiral is sinking Polish companies

The ban on the assignment of receivables is particularly severe for companies in sectors where payment terms reaching several dozen days are the norm. This includes the TSL industry, which has been struggling with a crisis for two years, in Poland additionally deepened by unfair competition from Ukrainian carriers. According to data from the Central Economic Information Center, 27 transport companies declared bankruptcy or restructuring in 2023, and in the first quarter of 2024 alone, another 183 entities took such a step.

Carriers are openly calling for state support that will allow the sector responsible for 7% of Poland’s GDP and 6.5% of employment to survive. Among the demands were, among others, subsidies for new tachographs or support for fleet electrification, required by the European Union.

– One of the latest government proposals is a temporary ban on the registration of new companies from the transport sector to prevent further bankruptcies. The chances of its implementation are slim, but the appearance of such a proposal shows how difficult a position the Polish TSL industry has found itself in. Lifting the assignment ban would give its representatives a chance to stabilize budgets and support in surviving the crisis – points out Transcash.eu expert, Jakub Gwiazdowski.

Source: Transcash