e-TOLL has launched!

On June 24, the Ministry of Finance and the National Revenue Administration (KAS) announced the launch of a new toll collection system called e-TOLL. How do industry experts evaluate this system in the initial period of its operation?

Jarosław KamińskiJarosław Kamiński, Toll Analyst, Eurowag: It has happened – e-TOLL has launched. First steps are always the hardest! This proverb is usually associated with something positive, emphasizing that things will get better after the initial attempt. However, we primarily dealt with the negative connotation of this saying, which suggests that the first attempt is unsuccessful. The e-TOLL system is closer to the latter meaning.
Exactly on June 24 of this year, the Ministry of Finance and the National Revenue Administration (KAS) announced the launch of the new toll collection system called e-TOLL. The retiring viaTOLL will, however, continue to operate until September 30. Fortunately, otherwise, we would be dealing with chaos.
The flaws of the system are not surprising to industry specialists. It was emphasized earlier that the time required to create and test such a complex system as e-TOLL requires a longer period. After postponing the implementation date several times, the start of e-TOLL coincided with the beginning of the holiday season, i.e., a period of increased traffic on many roads. The designation of special lanes at toll booths on the A2 and A4 motorways has caused increased traffic jams in these areas – this is mainly reported by passenger car drivers.
However, e-TOLL is primarily a change for heavy goods vehicles, which are required to use it. Connection to the system is possible via ZSL (External Localization System), OBU, or a mobile application. It is a kind of paradox that in current times, a mobile application, which is also free, is not the preferred option. Drivers are aware of the flaws of this solution – often the need to buy an additional smartphone, the need to remember to turn the application on/off at the right moment, monitoring battery levels, or even the need to purchase data packages (for border zones – with roaming). Some of the concerns have already been confirmed in practice, as evidenced by the devastating reviews of the application. In the Play Store (Android devices), as of July 9, “e-TOLL PL” had been downloaded over 10,000 times, and the average from over 500 reviews is 1.2 (as a reminder: on a five-point scale!). Users mainly complain about the non-intuitive interface and the complicated account setup procedure.
The most optimal solution from the perspective of carriers is the aforementioned OBU. Here, however, we come to another problem, which is insufficient supply. Due to the lack of semiconductor deliveries from Asia, manufacturers cannot meet market needs. Experts predict that ultimately, as many as 1.3-1.5 million devices will be needed (registered in viaTOLL). Companies that have passed certification are entities capable of producing a maximum of several thousand devices per month. This calls into question the efficient functioning of the system from October, when e-TOLL will be the only way to pay tolls on 3,700 km of toll roads in Poland.
Added to this is the cooperation between fleet card operators/issuers (FCI) and the Polcam Systems and Hilltech consortium, which acts as an intermediary between KAS and FCI, including in the scope of data exchange for company and truck registration, card management, transaction exchange, and FCI card payments (prepay/postpay), which leaves much to be desired. All this means that there are still many doubts and reservations regarding the introduced changes.