Determination of root causes of delays in small-batch and multi-assortment production

Determination of root causes of delays in small-batch and multi-assortment production

Small-batch and multi-assortment production is characterized by a high level of variability in the produced assortment, a high level of generality in standards and procedures, and requires a high degree of flexibility. This type of business activity requires production and logistics engineers to analyze production systems while taking into account the dominant position of the human factor. This stems from the high importance of individual decisions made by people responsible for production activities, which is usually significantly greater than in mass production. In this respect, small-batch and multi-assortment production is similar to unit production – high variability necessitates a high degree of flexibility, which cannot be achieved without utilizing the human’s natural ability to adapt to new conditions and their creativity. Due to this variability, as well as the significant position of the human factor, it is not easy to determine the actual causes of delays in small-batch and multi-assortment production. The purpose of this article is to present the difficulties in identifying the actual causes of delays, to propose a method for determining root causes, and to compile these causes for a selected period of time in an enterprise with small-batch and multi-assortment production.

Chapter 2 presents the issue of timeliness with particular emphasis on its specificity regarding the causes of delays in small-batch and multi-assortment production. Chapter 3 presents a proposed algorithm for finding root causes and causal analysis tools that can be successfully applied to determine the root causes of delays, along with examples of their application. Actual root causes for a selected period of time in an enterprise with small-batch and multi-assortment production are also compiled.

Due to the high variability in small-batch and multi-assortment production, it is difficult to apply standard production lead times to determine delivery deadlines for the customer. Products manufactured as part of orders can differ significantly from one another, which consequently means different resource involvement in their production. In such a situation, it is better to confirm the deadline for each order individually, after prior analysis of procurement, internal company load, and subcontractor load. Timeliness is a measure of reliability understood as the ability to meet promised delivery deadlines, also in terms of quantity. Timeliness can also be defined as the ratio of the number of deliveries delivered to the customer on the promised time to the number of all deliveries completed in a given period of time.

Enterprises usually do not publish data on their timeliness, which makes researching this issue definitely difficult, but customers are able to observe and measure it – in relation to their own orders. For most modern enterprises, both manufacturing and service, timeliness has a strategic dimension. Studies conducted in Sweden, the USA, India, and New Zealand have shown that delivery reliability is among the top three most important factors related to competitiveness. Since every enterprise wants to be competitive, and their effectiveness depends on the effectiveness of their suppliers, the natural goal of every manufacturing company should be continuous improvement in terms of timeliness.

In the literature, one can find various publications related to improving the level of timeliness, even if it happens indirectly – e.g., by shortening order lead times, with which timeliness is closely correlated. The scope of issues is broad and includes Just-In-Time, Theory of Constraints (TOC), Single-Minute Exchange of Die (SMED), Total Productive Maintenance (TPM), Value Stream Mapping (VSM), and others. However, to be able to effectively apply any of the available approaches or tools regarding timeliness, one must first correctly identify the root cause of the delays.

Root causes of untimeliness can be divided into three groups:
1) causes related to planning – these occur during the planning analysis,
2) causes related to production control – these concern discrepancies between the production plan derived from the schedule and reality, and occur during the production phase,
3) causes related to unplanned and unpredictable events – such as technological problems, delivery delays. These causes can occur at any moment from the moment an order is received until the product is handed over to the warehouse.


The article contains 20,000 characters.

Source: Logistyka Magazine

037_Karkula_Gacek_Determinacja_przyczyn_zrodlowych_opoznien_w_produkcji.pdf