Debit notes for debt collection costs for late payments

Debit notes for debt collection costs for late payments

How to calculate payment deadlines and when do we deal with a delay in invoice payment, when does interest become statute-barred, and is it necessary to issue a demand for payment for the 40 euro debt collection costs?

Expert answer: 40 euros is the debt collection cost in case of a delay in settling an invoice (the equivalent of 40 euros is imposed based on Article 10 of the Act on Payment Terms in Commercial Transactions).
Answering the first question, the payment deadline is usually specified in the order, where it should be clarified from when the deadline is counted. E.g., 30 days from the date of delivery of the complete transport documents with a correctly issued invoice. In that case, we count from the date of invoice delivery. If this was not specified in the contract, order, via email, or during a conversation on the exchange, the deadline should be counted from the date of invoice issuance.

Answering the second question, the provision of Article 10(1) of the Act on Payment Terms in Commercial Transactions states:
The creditor, from the date of acquiring the right to interest referred to in Article 7(1) or Article 8(1), is entitled from the debtor, without a demand, to the equivalent of 40 euros converted into zlotys at the average euro exchange rate announced by the National Bank of Poland on the last business day of the month preceding the month in which the monetary obligation became due, constituting compensation for debt collection costs.

According to judicial practice, this provision does not, however, relieve you of the obligation to call upon the debtor to perform the obligation (judgment of the Court of Appeal in Krakow of May 12, 2016, I ACa 110/16). This means that the other party must be informed of your demand. The phrase “without a demand” used in the provision refers to the lack of requirement for the creditor to prove the amount of debt collection costs incurred. The debtor is not obliged, even when settling an obligation with a delay, to pay the equivalent of 40 euros. The possibility of demanding this amount constitutes a right, not an obligation, of the creditor. Therefore, until the demand is made, the debtor does not know whether the creditor, i.e., you in this situation, decides to pursue this amount at all (as ruled by the court in a case we won, District Court for the Capital City of Warsaw, dated 26-01-2018, case file XVII GC 1824/17). Therefore, they must be informed about it. Information about the charge can be in the form of a note or a simple demand for payment of debt collection costs. The form of notification does not matter.

Answering the last question, yes, a note can be issued even after the invoice has been paid. If the principal claim has not become statute-barred, because it was, for example, paid, then we apply the deadline from Article 118 in connection with Article 120 of the Civil Code, three years from the date when the debt collection costs became due.
However, if the claim has become statute-barred, then the claim for debt collection costs has also become statute-barred. In my opinion, we can refer here to the resolution of the Supreme Court of January 26, 2005, III CZP 42/2004, which, although it referred to interest, in my opinion, the same principles will apply here.

Legal basis:

  • Act of March 8, 2013, on Payment Terms in Commercial Transactions
  • Act of April 23, 1964 – Civil Code

Legal status of the publication (date): 2018-06-11