Consumer bankruptcy for entrepreneurs. Everything you need to know

Consumer bankruptcy for entrepreneurs. Everything you need to know

Market problems that emerged in connection with the coronavirus pandemic have led many entrepreneurs to an extremely poor financial situation – especially in the case of small business owners. As a result, many of them had to file for bankruptcy. Does an entrepreneur have the right to file for consumer bankruptcy? On what terms does this take place?

What is bankruptcy? Explanation of the concept

According to bankruptcy law, bankruptcy proceedings consist of the liquidation of the bankrupt’s assets. Although the concept itself seems quite daunting, it is essentially an institution that often proves to be very beneficial for the debtor (commonly referred to as a bankrupt).

Bankruptcy proceedings are initiated when a debtor becomes insolvent, meaning they have lost the ability to settle their due monetary obligations. As a rule, the purpose of such proceedings is to repay as much of the debt as possible. When conducted against an entrepreneur, a secondary goal is usually to preserve the bankrupt’s enterprise. However, if the proceedings are conducted against natural persons who are not entrepreneurs, they should be conducted in a way that enables the discharge of the bankrupt’s obligations that were not performed during the bankruptcy proceedings.

Although bankruptcy is associated with entrepreneurs, it is worth remembering that for several years it has also been an institution available to consumers. Consumer bankruptcy is available to a natural person who does not conduct business activity.

Unlike enforcement proceedings, bankruptcy proceedings are conducted simultaneously against all creditors, not just one. No bailiff participates in the proceedings, and there is no enforcement. The effect of bankruptcy is the debt relief of the debtor in part or (less frequently) in full. In some cases, there is also a chance for the discharge of their obligations.

Changes in consumer bankruptcy. How is it now?

With the entry into force of the amendment to the Bankruptcy Law Act on March 24, 2020, the situation of natural persons conducting business activity was equalized with that of natural persons who do not conduct such activity. It turns out, therefore, that according to the legislator, treating entrepreneurs entered in the Central Register and Information on Economic Activity (CEIDG) more restrictively than ordinary consumers is unjustified. For this reason, there is no reason to block their access to filing for bankruptcy on the same terms as in the case of consumers.

In summary, for some time now, an entrepreneur has been able to file for consumer bankruptcy. However, this applies only to an entrepreneur who conducts business in the form of a sole proprietorship or as a partner in a civil partnership. Companies still only have access to entrepreneur bankruptcy, which is a highly formalized procedure. Furthermore, it must be noted that in order to file for bankruptcy, an entrepreneur must first lose their status by deregistering from the CEIDG.

Bankruptcy in the case of an entrepreneur – in the past

Bankruptcy law separately regulates bankruptcy proceedings concerning consumers. It differs from proceedings concerning an entrepreneur. Therefore, when conducting business activity, one usually first files for bankruptcy as an entrepreneur.

To file for bankruptcy as an entrepreneur, several conditions must be met. First, an entrepreneur is legally obliged to file for bankruptcy within 30 days from the date of establishing their insolvency. Furthermore, the Bankruptcy Law contains a requirement that an entrepreneur must possess assets sufficient to cover the costs of the bankruptcy proceedings. They must also have more than one creditor.

Without meeting the above conditions, the court will dismiss the application. What to do in such a situation? Can an entrepreneur file for consumer bankruptcy in such a case?

Until 2020, the Bankruptcy Law included much more restrictive conditions regarding filing for bankruptcy by former entrepreneurs. First, a period of ten years had to pass from the day of ceasing business activity. Besides that, the court checked whether the insolvency was not the result of intentional action or gross negligence, and whether the entrepreneur was not obliged to file for bankruptcy due to the occurrence of appropriate premises. If the entrepreneur did not fulfill this obligation, they had no right to file for bankruptcy for ten years(!).

An even more problematic issue was the court’s finding of gross negligence or intentionality. In that case, even the passage of time eliminated the possibility of a former entrepreneur filing for consumer bankruptcy. Currently, this premise does not exist – however, if the court finds that the bankruptcy is the result of intentional action or gross negligence, it may order a ban on conducting business activity by the debtor. More importantly, the court also refuses to discharge the obligations of the bankrupt consumer.

Consumer bankruptcy

Bankruptcy in the case of an entrepreneur – today

Currently, the situation is much simpler. A natural person who was an entrepreneur can file for bankruptcy on the same terms as a consumer. At the same time, this applies only to entrepreneurs conducting business in one of the forms subject to entry in the CEIDG: sole proprietorship or civil partnership.

The second condition is that the business must be deregistered from the CEIDG. The day on which this happens is irrelevant – the deadline applicable in 2020 has been abolished. As a result, an application for consumer bankruptcy can be filed literally the day after deregistration from the CEIDG.

This means that an active entrepreneur cannot file for consumer bankruptcy. It is available only to former entrepreneurs. The court only examines whether a specific natural person is no longer conducting business activity and checks their insolvency. Furthermore, when filing for consumer bankruptcy, a former entrepreneur does not have to possess assets enabling the coverage of the costs of the bankruptcy proceedings. They can also have only one creditor.

Here is a summary of the changes implemented in March 2020:

  • Previously, the primary goal of bankruptcy proceedings against a natural person conducting business activity was the maximum possible satisfaction of their creditors. Usually, this had the effect that bankrupt entrepreneurs finished the bankruptcy proceedings – despite the liquidation of their assets – with debts. And this created the necessity of conducting additional bankruptcy, this time consumer, because unsatisfied creditors were still demanding repayment. Today, an entrepreneur can decide either to file for bankruptcy as an entrepreneur (then they must have funds for the costs of the proceedings and at least partial satisfaction of creditors), or immediately as a consumer.
  • The possibility of filing for bankruptcy by a debtor has appeared even when they were at fault for causing insolvency or at fault for deepening the state of such insolvency. Obtaining the status of a bankrupt has therefore been significantly simplified. However, if it turns out that the debtor independently and intentionally led to a state of insolvency or intentionally increased the degree of insolvency, the court may refuse debt relief in the final decision ending the proceedings, and thus the discharge of obligations remaining after the repayment plan.
  • Another novelty is enabling persons conducting sole proprietorships to retain part of the funds obtained from the sale of an apartment or single-family house in bankruptcy proceedings, to enable them to find other accommodation.
  • There has also been a change in the forms of debt relief, which are now the same as those available to a consumer. Although there is still the possibility of a classic preparation of a creditor repayment plan at the debtor’s request, currently additionally:
    ⮚ There is a possibility of complete discharge of obligations without establishing a creditor repayment plan in a situation where the debtor’s personal situation indicates that they are permanently unable to make repayments under the creditor repayment plan;
    ⮚ A possibility of conditional discharge of obligations without a creditor repayment plan for a period of 5 years has been introduced when the inability to make any repayments under the creditor repayment plan results from the debtor’s personal situation, which, however, will not be of a permanent nature.
  • Furthermore, the repayment plan now covers a maximum period of 3 years, and in the case of the debtor’s intentional actions leading to their insolvency, from a minimum of 3 to 7 years.

The last change that should be mentioned is the possibility of protecting part of the income from the bankruptcy estate at a level allowing for the coverage of necessary living costs. Usually, this is the amount of the minimum wage.

Bankruptcy procedure step by step

At the beginning, the former entrepreneur-consumer must file an application for bankruptcy. It contains, among other things:

  • the debtor’s first and last name,
  • their PESEL number,
  • and if they used a NIP number for a period of 10 years until the day of filing the application (in practice: most often as an entrepreneur) – also the NIP number.

Additionally, the debtor specifies where their assets are located, describes the circumstances that justify filing the application, presents a current list of assets with their estimated value, lists creditors, their disputed receivables, information about achieved income and costs incurred for their own maintenance, as well as other persons who remain in their care.

For filing an application for consumer bankruptcy, there is a fee of 30 PLN. If the court does not dismiss the application, it will issue a decision in which it will appoint a bankruptcy trustee. This decision also contains a call for creditors to report their rights and claims. The bankrupt will be identified, i.e., their NIP number, which they used as an entrepreneur, will be provided, as well as information that they no longer conduct business activity.

Subsequent stages are related to the trustee’s actions. They determine the state of obligations and the bankruptcy estate, the method of its liquidation, and can also adopt: the form of a repayment plan, discharge of obligations without establishing a repayment plan, and conditional discharge of obligations without establishing a repayment plan. Of course, the least favorable variant for the entrepreneur is the one in which the trustee refuses to discharge obligations and establish a repayment plan. Such a situation may occur when insolvency is the result of the bankrupt’s intentional action or gross negligence. In that case, the bankrupt will not obtain the discharge of their obligations.

When the form of repayment is determined, the court will issue a decision in which it will indicate the method of dividing the bankruptcy estate and establish a creditor repayment plan. The repayment plan specifies what amounts the debtor will have to pay to creditors. It results, among other things, in the extent to which creditors’ claims will be repaid. Importantly, the plan cannot be set for a period longer than 3 years.

In summary, this process is divided into several consecutive stages:

  1. First, the debtor decides to file an application for consumer bankruptcy.
  2. This begins the preparatory stage, lasting from 1 to 2 months and consisting of analyzing the situation, gathering all necessary documents certifying the debt, and contacting creditors.
  3. Then, a complete and coherent application for bankruptcy and necessary attachments must be prepared, including a list of receivables, a list of the debtor’s assets, and justification.
  4. The application is filed with the court, which conducts a formal check and begins approximately two-month proceedings.
  5. The court at a hearing makes a decision on declaring consumer bankruptcy, which then becomes final. At that point, the bankrupt gains the suspension of collection, enforcement, and payment court proceedings, as well as the cessation of interest accrual on obligations.
  6. Later, the so-called proper bankruptcy proceedings take place.
  7. The court appoints a bankruptcy trustee to determine the composition and value of the bankruptcy estate, i.e., the assets, income of the bankrupt consumer, and the list of receivables.
  8. After these issues are determined by the trustee, the sale of assets belonging to the bankrupt and the division of the obtained funds among creditors take place.
  9. Furthermore, the Court issues a decision on establishing a Creditor Repayment Plan, which begins a period of installment repayments to creditors lasting up to 36 months.
  10. The debtor makes repayments to creditors according to the established plan.
  11. If there are still any debts not performed in the bankruptcy proceedings, the court orders by decision their discharge.

What are the rights and obligations on the part of the trustee?

During bankruptcy proceedings, the consumer’s assets are the bankruptcy estate. The trustee manages this estate. The bankrupt, in turn, loses the right to use and dispose of their own assets, as almost all of their assets are handed over to the trustee. Furthermore, the trustee covers the costs of the assets’ operation, secures them against destruction or damage, bears the costs of their maintenance, and also performs repairs or renovations. Any actions on the part of the trustee can also serve to prepare the assets for sale.

The obligations on the part of the trustee are similar in the case of entrepreneur bankruptcy and consumer bankruptcy. Of course, the entrepreneur will not be completely deprived of the means necessary for life. Certain items needed to maintain a minimum existence will be left to them, such as: household appliances, clothes, apartment, furniture, personal accessories such as bedding, underwear, and things necessary for gainful employment: laptop, car (e.g., for a sales representative), or musical instruments (e.g., for a musician).

The trustee also liquidates the assets as part of their sale. They prepare an inventory and balance sheet, possibly submitting a report. As part of the liquidation of the bankruptcy estate, they sell movable and immovable property, realize the property rights belonging to the bankrupt, and also collect receivables from their debtors.

Consumer bankruptcy

What are the consequences of declaring consumer bankruptcy?

Apart from debt relief, consumer bankruptcy also carries many other consequences for the debtor.

Its declaration is primarily associated with making such information public, usually by posting information in the court building. This information will also be published in the Central Register of Restructuring and Bankruptcy. This register is maintained by the Minister of Justice and allows for quickly determining whether a given natural person has filed for bankruptcy and at what stage their bankruptcy proceedings are.

The second effect of declaring bankruptcy by a consumer is the suspension by operation of law of enforcement proceedings directed against them at the time of declaring bankruptcy. More importantly, enforcement proceedings are discontinued after the decision on declaring bankruptcy becomes final. So if bankruptcy is declared, there is no need to worry that a bailiff will seize wages for work. Additionally, this gives a chance to get rid of collection agencies.

Another, less favorable consequence is that for some time it is practically impossible to obtain a loan or bank credit. Banks will long consider that a former, bankrupt entrepreneur does not have creditworthiness.

Of course, as the most important effect of declaring consumer bankruptcy, it is pointed out that it leads to the liquidation of most of the debtor’s assets. From the funds obtained in this way, their debts are repaid. Sometimes it is also possible to discharge debts without repayment, but only when the debtor had no assets at all.

An interesting issue is the impact of declaring bankruptcy on interest. From the bankruptcy estate, interest on receivables for the period up to the day of declaring bankruptcy can be satisfied. Interest accrued after this date cannot, therefore, be claimed from the bankruptcy estate. The creditor, however, has the right to demand their payment from property other than the bankruptcy estate. Unfortunately for the creditor, such a lawsuit will be rather ineffective – it will only be effective if, after the bankruptcy proceedings, there is an appropriate value of the debtor’s assets left. And that does not happen very often.

Importantly, not every debt can be discharged as part of bankruptcy proceedings. The proceedings do not cover debts resulting from:

  • alimony, fines, annuities,
  • the obligation to repair damage for causing health impairment,
  • inability to work or death,
  • obligations intentionally undisclosed during the proceedings,
  • as well as certain benefits resulting from criminal proceedings: damages or monetary benefits ordered by the court as a penal measure or a measure related to subjecting the perpetrator to a trial, or the obligation to repair damage resulting from a crime or misdemeanor confirmed by a final decision.

Benefits of consumer bankruptcy of a former entrepreneur vs. entrepreneur bankruptcy

Between consumer bankruptcy and entrepreneur bankruptcy, there are several important differences. One of them, favorable to the consumer, appears already in the case of the goals of the proceedings. While the goal of entrepreneur bankruptcy is to satisfy creditors to the greatest extent possible and (as far as possible) preserve the bankrupt’s enterprise, the goal of consumer bankruptcy is also the debt relief of the bankrupt.

This contributes to improving the situation of the bankrupt-consumer compared to the bankrupt-entrepreneur. Moreover, a consumer does not have to file for bankruptcy. They only have such a right, which allows them to file for it at the most convenient moment for themselves. Besides, an apartment or house during consumer bankruptcy will not be taken over by the trustee. Ex officio, they take into account the consumer’s housing needs, while an active entrepreneur is not covered by such preferential treatment.

An additional benefit for the consumer is the creditor repayment plan, which was not provided for in the case of a bankrupt entrepreneur. If the repayment plan is implemented, the court will be obliged to discharge the bankrupt consumer’s obligations. In turn, an entrepreneur during bankruptcy proceedings will obtain the discharge of obligations only on the condition that the insolvency did not occur through their fault.

Conclusions

Taking the above into account, it is not surprising that the number of proceedings in the case of consumer bankruptcy has recorded a significant increase since 2020 from about 8 thousand to about 14 thousand per year.
Consumer bankruptcy is a chance for former entrepreneurs for debt relief, a new start, and getting rid of a bailiff. It also provides definitely greater peace and psychological comfort. The process of liquidating the bankruptcy estate is the trustee’s task, while the bankrupt can still use the funds left to them, which enable a reasonably free existence.