Charging infrastructure in Polish cities is insufficient

Charging infrastructure in Polish cities is insufficient

Cities are currently driving the Polish electromobility market. Today, nearly 3/4 of electric vehicles in Poland are registered in municipalities with over 50,000 inhabitants. At the same time, 56% of all publicly accessible charging stations in Poland are located in the 37 largest cities with over 100,000 inhabitants. Theoretically, this is a very good result, but in practice, the expansion of infrastructure for electric vehicles in Polish urban centers faces numerous, serious obstacles.

– Regardless of the challenges in the connection area – which are common to the entire sector – the biggest barriers in this area include, among others, very lengthy approval procedures, architectural requirements not adapted to market conditions (in practice, making it impossible to launch DC stations in some cities), or finally, very diverse lease rates. As a result, in as many as 19 out of 37 of the largest cities in Poland, the share of publicly accessible, fast DC charging points is no more than 20%, and in 11 out of 37 of the largest cities in Poland, the number of publicly accessible DC charging points does not exceed 10 – says Jan Wiśniewski, Director of the PSNM Research and Analysis Center.

PSNM points out that the level of fulfillment of obligations resulting from Article 60 of the Act on Electromobility and Alternative Fuels is very symbolic in this context. Based on this provision, a specific, minimum number of publicly accessible charging points should have been operating in the largest Polish municipalities by March 2021. Meanwhile, as of mid-2024 – i.e., more than three years after the statutory deadline – these obligations have been met in only 20 out of 37 obligated municipalities. The level of meeting the goals resulting from EU regulations is even worse. Based on the AFIR regulation, charging infrastructure intended to serve electric heavy-duty vehicles should be operating in 30 urban nodes in Poland by the end of 2025. Currently, there are no required stations in any Polish city.

To determine the procedural and cost differences that occur in individual Polish cities and have a direct impact on the implementation of infrastructure investments, PSNM, in cooperation with Volvo Cars Poland, initiated a unique project that involved both local governments and leading charging station operators.

– The project was implemented in stages, with the active participation of over 20 cities associated in the PSNM Local Government Committee. We also involved a dozen or so operators of publicly accessible charging stations in the initiative. As a result, we have collected a very rich database that allowed for a comprehensive comparison of the administrative and financial conditions under which infrastructure for electric vehicles is being built in individual cities. We paid particular attention to the level of land lease rates for charging stations, both in the road lane and outside this lane. We presented the conclusions of the project in a substantive report – says Agata Wiśniewska-Mazur, Coordinator of the PSNM Local Government Committee.

The PSNM report shows a very significant discrepancy in the level of land lease rates for charging stations in Polish cities. Taking into account additional parking space fees, annual net lease costs (in the case of occupying 1 m2 for a station and 36 m2 for EV parking spaces) can range from PLN 50 (Rzeszów) to PLN 18,542 (Szczecin). As a result, the lowest annual lease costs are as much as 371 times lower than the highest costs. In the case of spaces outside the road lane, annual net lease costs can range from PLN 156.60 (Kielce) to PLN 11,052 (Sopot). As a result, the lowest annual lease costs are as much as 83 times lower than the highest costs.

– The excessively high land lease rates currently in force in some cities, where publicly accessible charging stations are to be installed, constitute – from the operators’ perspective – one of the biggest barriers to the expansion of charging infrastructure in cities, making it practically impossible to achieve a return on investment. Meanwhile, publicly accessible stations are absolutely necessary to encourage a larger number of city residents (many of whom do not and will not have access to private charging points) to purchase electric cars in the coming years. Therefore, as part of the project we carried out, together with leading CPOs, we prepared a number of recommendations, the implementation of which by local governments could lead to a decisive acceleration in the expansion of infrastructure for electric vehicles – says Aleksander Rajch, Member of the PSNM Management Board.

PSNM recommendations include, among others, establishing specialized bodies responsible for the area of charging infrastructure and introducing a “one-stop-shop” principle, standardizing and adjusting land lease rates for charging stations to market conditions in e-mobility, as well as extending the contractual land lease period for a charging station (the 3-year period currently provided for in many cities makes it practically impossible to achieve a return on investment). PSNM also postulates, among other things, adjusting architectural or aesthetic requirements to the product offer in the e-mobility sector, and furthermore recommends making information about the procedure for concluding land lease agreements for charging stations available on official websites or launching a hotline for this purpose (similar practices have already been implemented in some urban centers, e.g., in Poznań and Gdańsk).

– The road to replacing combustion transport with electric is long, and one of the most important elements of this process is the development of vehicle charging station infrastructure. The problem in Poland is not only the insufficient number of fast chargers, but also the low density of the network. The low power of points and the so-called “white spots” on the map of electric car charging stations constitute an insurmountable obstacle for people planning a longer trip by electric car. Zero-emission transport means a reduction in harmful gas emissions, and thus an improvement in air quality, and consequently an increase in the quality of life for Poles. For drivers to want to switch from combustion cars to electric ones, the charging experience should be similar to a visit to a gas station. Drivers must have the prospect of fast EV charging, i.e., within about 20 minutes to about 70–80%, in a conveniently accessible location. Today, we have only about 300 such fast chargers with a power of over 150 kW in Poland, of which 38 have already been installed by Volvo dealers. We plan to add another 100 by the end of next year – says Emil Dembiński, Managing Director of Volvo Car Poland.

The full version of the PSNM report is available at the link.

Source: PSNM