Challenges of the pallet market in Poland

The conference “Challenges of the pallet market in Poland,” which took place at the beginning of October in Warsaw, summarized a study conducted from December 2007 to June 2008 with supply chain managers in over 80 companies operating in our market. The study, carried out by DGL Polska on behalf of CHEP Polska using individual interviews, is a premiere in this sector on the Polish market. Thanks to this method, it was possible to obtain extremely reliable information illustrating the problems and challenges facing supply chain participants.

During the conference, which was attended by nearly 150 representatives of the largest manufacturing, distribution, and logistics companies, the conclusions of the report were presented. It provides a cross-sectional view of the consequences of a lack of control over pallet circulation, as well as their impact on cost items. Proper pallet management is a challenge that can lead to significant cost optimization. At the moment, this element is overlooked or marginalized, primarily due to a lack of knowledge about the actual value of pallets in the costs of each enterprise.

The conference was attended by representatives of CHEP: Peter Mackie, President CHEP Europe, Christophe Loiseau, SVP, Western Europe & Strategic Marketing, CHEP Europe, and Jacek Machocki, President of the Board, DGL Polska. Key findings from the study were presented by Aleksander Domaradzki, partner at DGL Polska. After the presentation, a very lively panel discussion took place, moderated by Prof. Krzysztof Rutkowski from the Department of Logistics at the Warsaw School of Economics.

The study conducted by DGL Polska on behalf of CHEP Polska regarding the challenges of the pallet market in Poland points to the fundamental factors that determine pallet management, while simultaneously showing which elements of the management process are crucial for cost optimization.

The study was conducted from December 2007 to June 2008 among supply chain managers in over 80 companies operating in our market. The individual interview method used in the study is a premiere in this sector on the Polish market. This approach allowed for obtaining reliable information illustrating the problems and challenges facing all supply chain participants: transport companies, distributors, and suppliers.

All market participants agree: pallets received in the exchange process are of lower quality than those sent by the company. 30% of transporters, 45% of suppliers, and 42% of distributors always receive lower-quality pallets in the exchange process. Elements that can contribute to improving the pallet system in Poland are primarily cost reduction and improving the quality of pallets introduced into circulation. The biggest problem blocking proper pallet management is time commitment and financial expenditure. The need for constant supervision appears primarily in the responses of transport companies, representing a smaller problem in the understanding of distributors, as is the risk associated with pallet exchange, which in their case is shifted to suppliers.

Differences also appear in the criteria used when assessing damaged pallets. 80% of transport companies use the definition of a damaged pallet consistent with ECR Polska, and 20% use their own subjective definition based on the degree of pallet destruction. Similar results can be noted in the group of suppliers: 74% of issuers use the definition consistent with ECR Polska, while 18% use their own criteria. In the case of distributors, these figures are 92% and 8%, respectively. Further discrepancies appear in the approach to repairs: the lack of standardization in this area can be seen as a real problem. 39% of suppliers, 37% of transport companies, and 59% of distributors do not perform pallet repairs at all.

The factor that emerges as the biggest obstacle to improving the pallet system in Poland is the human factor. People’s attitudes are cited much more often than environmental protection requirements. Distributors and transport companies also cite insufficient competence of people involved in pallet circulation. For suppliers, however, the level of management commitment is an important point.

Enterprises do not have an overview of the flows and volumes of pallets in circulation, nor do they calculate the total costs associated with pallet management. Few companies have a unit in their structure responsible for comprehensive pallet management and related processes. The current pallet management system causes the creation of numerous procedures, processes, and disputes, while generating additional costs. The common denominator in all cases turns out to be cost consequences. In pallet circulation, the cost structure is quite complex and should include many factors: the balance between purchase costs and sales revenue (69% of the total cost of pallet management), transport and storage costs, costs associated with circulation control and the quality of the pallets themselves (17%), as well as administrative costs and those related to frozen capital. The average cost per pallet of 9.02 PLN represents only 69% of the actual total cost, which means that most organizations do not even take into account up to 31% of the actual cost.