Can an employer impose a vacation date on an employee?

Can an employer impose a vacation date on an employee?

The holiday season is underway, so it is worth recalling the regulations defining rights related to rest. Is the right to vacation actually a “sacred right” of the employee, as is often said? And can an employer impose a date for such rest on an employee? In this article, we answer the most important questions regarding vacation.

Vacation according to the Labor Code

According to Article 14 of the Labor Code, an employee has the right to rest. This constitutes (right next to the right to remuneration for work) one of the fundamental, most important rights to which an employee is entitled. It is also a personal human right. For these reasons, an employee cannot waive their vacation, nor transfer it to a third party. The Labor Code meshes here with Article 66(2) of the Constitution of the Republic of Poland, which states that an employee has the right to days off from work and annual paid vacations as specified by statute, and that maximum working time standards are determined by statute.

There is, therefore, no doubt that rest is an extremely important issue from the legislator’s point of view. It is the foundation for safe and hygienic working conditions. Because of this, the legislator strives for vacation to be granted in kind in the first place. And contrary to appearances, this is not about an obligation to spend vacation in the open air.

The legislator’s intention is for the nature of the vacation to be its use in the form of free time away from work – only when this is impossible is the employee entitled to an equivalent in financial form. In order to prevent “trading” vacation in exchange for monetary gratification, the legislator indicates that the equivalent is due to the employee only in one case – when they decide to resign from work and do not use their accrued excess vacation during the notice period.

At the same time, it must be noted that the right to vacation is granted only to employees, i.e., persons employed under an employment relationship. Persons performing tasks under other types of relationships gain such a right only when regulations explicitly provide for it. This will be the case, for example, when this fact arises from the provisions of an agreement concluded between the parties.

Employees are entitled to the right to spend time away from work in daily, weekly, and annual periods. According to Article 152(1) of the Labor Code, an employee has the right to an annual, uninterrupted, paid vacation. In turn, the amount of vacation to which a specific employee is entitled is determined based on their length of service.

  • If an employee has been employed (in general, not just with one employer, whereby years of education also count towards length of service in an appropriate manner) for less than ten years, then they are entitled to 20 days of vacation per year.
  • However, if an employee has been employed for more than 10 years, they will be able to take 26 days off annually.

What about employees employed part-time? Here, vacation is calculated proportionally to the employment dimension. It should also be noted that an employee can “take” their vacation in parts. In that case, at least one of the parts of such rest should not be shorter than 14 days.

The issue of setting vacation dates is regulated by employers within the framework of the practice developed between them and the employees. In most workplaces, therefore, so-called vacation plans are in operation. Employees determine and declare when they would like to use their days off, and the employer tries to plan the plant’s work in such a way as to ensure, as far as possible, rest for employees and uninterrupted work.

What to do in a situation where an employer imposes a vacation date on an employee by way of an arbitrary decision? Can an employee express their objection, or must they comply with the employer’s provision? When does such behavior constitute a violation of human rights, and when is it a legal and permitted action? We answer below.

Forcing the use of overdue vacation

According to the wording of Article 161 of the Labor Code, an employer is obliged to grant an employee vacation in the calendar year in which the employee acquired the right to it. Therefore, according to this rule, when an employee acquired the right to 26 days of vacation on January 1, 2022, they are entitled to use all 26 days in 2022.

It often happens that an employee does not use all the days of “time off” they are entitled to. What happens to such vacation? Well, vacation not used in a given calendar year is “carried over” to the next year (the employee can use it until September 30 of the following year).

As we mentioned earlier, if the vacation was not granted in kind, i.e., in the form of time off from work, the employee is entitled to a monetary equivalent. The employer will therefore have to make a decision whether to create a reserve in the books in case a given employee were to terminate the employment relationship and the equivalent for unused vacation becomes due. Furthermore, an employer who prevents or hinders an employee from using overdue vacation within the time limit specified in the act is subject to a fine of 1,000 to 30,000 PLN. This is one of the reasons why so many employers prefer their employees to use the days of “time off” they are entitled to. However, can an employer force an employee to use overdue vacation at a time specified by them?

The answer in this case is affirmative. Yes, an employer can order an employee to use their overdue vacation. Nevertheless, in the first instance, the date of this vacation should be mutually agreed upon by them. Only when the employer and the employee do not reach an agreement does the employer gain the right to grant the employee overdue vacation even without their consent.

It is worth mentioning here also the so-called special act on countering COVID-19, Article 15gc of which states that during the period of an epidemic threat or epidemic state declared due to COVID-19, an employer may grant an employee, on a date indicated by them, without receiving the employee’s consent and bypassing their vacation plans, vacation leave not used by the employee in previous calendar years, in an amount of up to 30 days of vacation, and the employee is obliged to use such vacation.

This provision, although two years have passed since its introduction, still remains in force. This means that it still applies in all workplaces.

Can an employer impose a vacation date on an employee?

Forcing rest on an imposed date

At this point, it should be noted that an employee has the right to vacation. It is, therefore, not their duty. Of course, they still cannot waive the vacation or transfer it to someone else, but as a rule, they should have the freedom to decide when to take the vacation.
The Code takes into account several cases in which an employer has the right to refuse an employee vacation on a given date. The first of these is, for example, a situation in which circumstances arise in the workplace where it will not be possible to continue work without the presence of a specific employee. Then, after meeting the conditions, the employer can recall the employee from vacation, even if they have already gone on it.

Besides that, an employer may (if the employee’s absence disrupts the plant’s work) postpone the employee’s vacation even if this vacation was planned in accordance with the vacation plan. In each of these situations, however, one must carefully consider whether the situation of the workplace actually requires taking such actions as recalling an employee from vacation or postponing their planned rest. One must always precede this with a thorough analysis and consideration of every potential solution.

It looks different in a case where there are no objective reasons indicating that an employee cannot exercise their right to rest, and the employer nevertheless imposes a vacation date on them. Such action is prohibited. An employee can independently apply for vacation in the manner customarily accepted at a specific employer and decide on a date that will be suitable for them. When there is no objective reason why they cannot receive vacation on the date preferred by the employee, the employer cannot refuse them or dictate any date.

In summary, the vacation date must be the result of a consensus between the employer and the employee.

Secondment to vacation during the notice period

The last case requiring discussion in this regard is the situation in which an employee is entitled to vacation during the notice period of an employment contract. This constitutes a case that is crucial in that failure to use the vacation causes the necessity to pay the departing employee a monetary equivalent. For this reason, it is worth remembering that during the notice period, an employer can send an employee on vacation, and that without their consent. The employee does not then have to express consent to being granted vacation or to the date on which they will use it.

What to do when it is the employee on notice who would like to go on vacation, and the employer does not want to grant this vacation? Well, for some employers, an employee on notice no longer constitutes added value in the plant. Usually, they are already focused on their next, new job, which is why they show significantly less commitment to the duties performed. The employer usually prefers to send such an employee on vacation. If, however, it is different, because, for example, the employer cannot find a replacement for the person leaving the plant, or their departure will result in the necessity to train someone new for this position, then they may want to keep the employee as long as possible. Does the employer actually have such a right?

Although the basic right of an employee is the possibility of submitting a vacation request, during the notice period, the employer themselves makes the decision about whether they will grant the employee vacation or pay them the due equivalent. Article 167 of the Labor Code speaks directly about this. During the notice period of an employment contract, an employee is obliged to use the vacation they are entitled to, but only if the employer allows them to do so.

Can an employer impose a vacation date on an employee?

Secondment to so-called collective vacation

During the year, a situation may occur in which one or two working days fall between statutory holidays. Then, employees themselves willingly apply for vacation. However, it also happens that the employer would prefer to leave the workplace closed on that day. Can they then force the entire team to use vacation leave?

No – they can only suggest such a solution, but whether the employees agree to it depends solely on them. If not all employees decide to do so, and yet the employer wants that day to be a day of rest for the entire crew, they can simply grant them an additional, paid day of vacation outside the amount they are entitled to by law.

Yet another example of so-called collective vacation, i.e., a situation in which an employer wants to send all their employees on vacation at once, is downtime in the plant’s operations. Such cases happened en masse quite recently, during the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic. During this period, factories and workplaces placed in lockdown were forced to temporarily suspend operations, which resulted in a lack of work for those employed.

One must remember, however, that even the circumstances indicated above do not constitute a justification for an employer who forces employees to use vacation in a specific period. Such action is illegal – deciding on the date of current vacation constitutes an exclusive right of the employee.

Of course, we can imagine a case in which all employees take vacation at the same time, and then the plant is closed – however, this could only happen if it were their completely voluntary and conscious decision. At the same time, we emphasize that in practice, especially in larger plants employing a large number of people, this is sometimes physically impossible.

Conclusions

In summary, the employee and the employer should reach an agreement on the issue of setting a vacation date. The employer is therefore obliged to respect the employee’s right to rest. On the other hand, the employee should understand that in the event of a greater workload, the employer will be less willing to grant their vacation request.

Furthermore, according to the provisions of the law, an employer can impose a date for using vacation only during the notice period. In other situations, the employee decides for themselves when they will exercise their right to rest.