We usually associate the term “legitymacja” (ID card) with a document confirming our membership in a specific group, such as students or company employees. However, this word also has another meaning. In legal terms, it refers to the right to perform certain actions – and it is in this sense that it appears in transport law.
Legal standing (legitymacja) can arise from documents, such as a transport order or a consignment note, or from other circumstances of the case. Having legal standing is particularly important in the context of claiming compensation for improperly performed transport. On this basis, the entitled party can file a complaint with the carrier and effectively pursue payment in court.
Legal standing in the light of transport law
– The issue of the right to pursue claims under a contract of carriage is one of the more complex issues in international transport subject to the CMR Convention – says Maurycy Kieruj, a lawyer at TC Kancelaria Prawna, and adds: – Since the Convention does not in all cases clearly indicate who has legal standing, we also refer subsidiarily to national law (Polish transport law for transport carried out in Poland), as well as to the Civil Code.
Importantly, the legal standing to claim compensation has been formally defined in the CMR Convention and transport law. This means that the entity that suffered the damage during transport will not always be the one entitled to compensation. Examples of cases handled by TC Kancelaria Prawna will help in understanding these complexities.
The goods did not reach the recipient
In the first case, company A (the buyer) entered into a contract with B as the seller for the sale of pork. The transport of the goods from Belgium to the plaintiff’s registered office was carried out by P based on a transport order received from company R. The goods were loaded at the seller B’s company and a consignment note was issued, according to which the goods were to be delivered to A’s registered office. During transport, the driver of P followed the instructions of X, who was indicated in the transport order as the contact person. Following his instruction regarding a change in the place of delivery, he went to city C, where the goods were unloaded and handed over to X. Company A, which paid for the goods but did not receive them, is claiming compensation from carrier P.
According to the CMR Convention (Art. 13(1)), after the arrival of the goods at the place designated for delivery, the consignee is entitled to require the carrier to deliver the second copy of the consignment note and the goods against a receipt. If the loss of the goods is established or if the goods have not arrived after the deadline, the consignee may, in their own name, enforce the rights arising from the contract of carriage against the carrier. It follows that the cited provision of the CMR Convention refers to two different situations: the first, when the goods have arrived at the place designated for delivery, and the second, when the loss of the goods has been established or if the goods have not arrived after a specified deadline.
Translating this to the described case, it should be stated that the release of goods by the carrier to unidentified persons not authorized to receive them, such as person X, can be treated as the loss of goods. It has the characteristics of permanence – the goods were not recovered, and the 30-day period from the agreed delivery date has passed. In such a case, the CMR Convention explicitly states that the consignee may, in their own name, enforce the rights arising from the contract of carriage against the carrier. The consignee therefore has the legal standing to claim compensation from the carrier.
– The described case of a lost shipment is unique in that the legal standing to claim compensation belongs to the consignee, provided that they submit such a claim to the carrier. If the sender submits a complaint earlier and, as the person disposing of the shipment, receives compensation, the consignee will lose this standing. In the case described, the court ruled that company A had the legal standing to claim compensation from carrier P – points out Maurycy Kieruj.
Damage to the shipment in transit
In the second case, company A commissioned transport to B, and B further commissioned transport to C. The transported goods were fertilizer. The goods were transported in bulk in a dump truck. During transport, the tarpaulin was damaged as a result of a downpour, and the goods became wet. This fact was noted in the consignment note, and the information was signed by the driver. Company X (the buyer) filed a complaint with company A, informing them that the damage covered 55% of the value of the goods. The amount of damage included soaking, hardening, loss of granulation, low quality of application, and additional costs associated with further handling of the fertilizer. The letter stated that attempts had been made to stop the hardening process, but this process affects the structure of the fertilizer and limits the possibility of using it.
Due to the damage to the goods, A charged B with the amount of compensation and then set off its claim against the claim due to B for remuneration for performing other transports for A. Consequently, B charged C with the amount of compensation indicated above and called on C to pay within the specified deadline for the performance of the obligation. Is the actual carrier C liable to B? Company B did indeed suffer damage in the form of compensation deducted from its remuneration, but should it rightly agree to such a charge and claim compensation from C?
– In this case, the court hearing the case rightly ruled that B lacked the legal standing to obtain compensation from C. B also failed to prove that its principal, i.e., A, had settled the liabilities for the damage to the entitled person. Only proving this circumstance would entitle B, under certain conditions, to claim compensation from C by way of recourse – says the expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
The person with legal standing to pursue compensation claims for damage to goods is, according to the regulations, the sender or the consignee, depending on which of them has the right to dispose of the goods. This right expires on the part of the sender generally at the moment the goods arrive at the consignee (Art. 12(2) of the Convention). After the undisputed transfer of the shipment, against a receipt and with the second copy of the consignment note, the right to compensation claims is taken over by its original consignee. Where the shipment was actually delivered does not matter.
In the case described, company B was neither the sender nor the consignee of the goods, therefore it has no legal standing to pursue compensation claims against C.
TC Kancelaria Prawna







