Are synthetic fuels a good alternative?

Are synthetic fuels a good alternative?

Issues regarding synthetic fuels systematically appear in discussions about climate protection efforts in the transport industry. Some see them as a valuable technology of the future, while for others, they are uneconomical and absurd.

Synthetic fuels (Synfuels) are gaseous or liquid fuels that can be produced using electricity. They can also be referred to as power-to-X (PtX), power-to-liquid (PtL), or power-to-gas (PtG) fuels. Sometimes the term Powerfuels is used interchangeably. At the European Union (EU) level, they are defined as Renewable Fuels of Non-Biological Origin (RFNBO). In other words, they are produced from electricity generated from renewable sources (mainly solar and wind). At the beginning of 2023, the European Commission issued regulations regarding the production of RFNBO as a supplement to the Renewable Energy Directive (RED II). According to these regulations, nuclear energy is still not recognized as renewable, but according to some EU member states, it should play a decisive role in the production of synthetic fuels in the future. This issue is still subject to negotiation.

Energy-intensive production

The production of kerosene, diesel, and gasoline as synthetic fuel is usually based on the Fischer-Tropsch process, which has been known for a century. In this method, long hydrocarbon chains are created from synthesis gas – a mixture of hydrogen (H) and carbon monoxide (CO) – and the resulting “e-crude oil” can then be refined into fuels. However, to qualify them as “green,” the hydrogen must be produced using electricity generated from renewable sources in accordance with the RED II directive. This is usually done via electrolysis. Carbon monoxide must come from carbon dioxide (CO2) previously extracted from the atmosphere (direct air capture).

Recent studies indicate that this entire process – including the desalination of seawater necessary for hydrogen production – means that the energy content in e-crude oil is equivalent to only 1/3 or even less of that used to produce it. The subsequent refining process requires even more energy. As a result, this option is considered highly energy-intensive and uneconomical compared to fossil fuels or the direct use of electricity in electric motors.

New horizons in air and sea transport

Currently, however, synthetic fuels produced using the Fischer-Tropsch process are the only way to reduce the carbon footprint of long-haul flights to almost zero. Along with biogenic sustainable aviation fuels (SAF), e-kerosene (a type of synthetic fuel referring to a subcategory of e-fuels suitable for aviation) is seen today as a light at the end of the tunnel for the aviation industry. This is because a byproduct of the refining process that creates e-kerosene is renewable diesel. Some believe this could be the future for synthetic fuels intended for road transport.

However, this will not happen in the short or medium term. It is expected that in Germany, e-kerosene production will account for 2% of total production in 2030, or about 200,000 metric tons per year. This process would also generate about 100,000 metric tons of renewable diesel. However, this corresponds to only 0.3% of current consumption of this fuel in Germany. Due to limited availability and significantly higher costs, renewable diesel will therefore be used only in special applications where there is no technical or economic alternative to the diesel engine, or as an additive to fossil fuels, similar to today’s bio-blends in gasoline and diesel.

Synthetic fuels are also in demand in the maritime industry. Large cargo ships, which are currently powered by heavy oil, will soon be refueled with e-methanol (CH4O). The shipping company Maersk has already ordered 19 such ships. E-methanol is produced in a separate process, directly from green hydrogen and CO2. In addition to the shipping industry, this product is mainly sought after in the chemical industry. Further processing into diesel, while possible, also involves high costs.

In the long term, the maritime industry is also focusing on e-ammonia (NH₃). Modern engine technologies are not yet fully developed, and the fuel is highly toxic, so its use only makes sense in large vessels. Looking to the future, however, in the coming decade, it is synthetic fuels that may replace e-methanol. This is because green hydrogen is needed to produce e-ammonia, not CO2. Using nitrogen (N) obtained from the surrounding air in the process is much more efficient than capturing CO2 molecules.

Synthetic fuels are part of the green hydrogen economy and thus a technology of the future that society urgently needs for the transition towards zero-emission solutions. However, they are produced in very different processes and needed for diverse purposes – in particular for intercontinental energy transport and the decarbonization of maritime shipping and aviation. Currently, synthetic fuels do not play a significant role in European road traffic.

Source: Dachser