Alternative ways of employing drivers

Alternative ways of employing drivers

In response to challenges such as rising labor costs, entrepreneurs are increasingly turning to alternative forms of cooperation with drivers. While these offer greater flexibility and potential savings, they also require a good knowledge of regulations and effective avoidance of formal errors. However, many misunderstandings, simplifications, and sometimes myths have grown around these types of contracts that have little to do with reality.

Why are transport companies looking for alternatives to employment contracts?

This solution is gaining popularity among carriers seeking greater flexibility in hiring and real reductions in operating costs. However, it must be remembered that a driver on a mandate contract cannot perform duties in circumstances that, in practice, meet the criteria of an employment relationship – otherwise, there is a risk that such a form of cooperation will be challenged by regulatory authorities.

Remuneration paid to a driver based on a mandate contract can be included in tax-deductible expenses, which automatically lowers the company’s tax base. This model of cooperation also offers more freedom – Labor Code regulations do not apply here, so there is no obligation to pay benefits such as vacation leave or sick pay. Moreover, upon meeting certain conditions, it is also possible to avoid paying full social security contributions, which can lead to significant savings – so important in the face of dynamically rising business operating costs.

What is driver self-employment and what are its advantages?

Self-employment is a model in which an individual conducts business on their own account, providing services to contractors based on civil law contracts (including mandate contracts). No employment relationship is created here, and the responsibility for the execution of the order, settlements, and proper organization of working time rests entirely with the self-employed person. For transport companies, this type of cooperation is a good solution, e.g., in the event of an employed driver’s illness, as well as during periodic staffing shortages or increased work intensity during peak season. This is also facilitated by greater flexibility related to the possibility of faster contract termination – without the notice period required in employment contracts.

Compared to employment contracts, mandate contracts also involve fewer administrative duties, which relieves the HR and accounting departments. Benefits for companies also include a number of financial issues. In certain cases, e.g., when the contractor is already insured from another source, the company is not obliged to pay full ZUS contributions. Paid vacations and sick pay also do not apply – unless the contractor pays the contributions themselves.

This model of cooperation can be beneficial for both parties, provided it is used consciously and in accordance with applicable law. Otherwise, it can bring more problems than savings – what should you pay special attention to? You will find the answer in the rest of the article.

Is self-employment beneficial for the driver?

The answer to this question, as with all other forms of employment, is not obvious. Everything depends on individual priorities and predispositions. From the driver’s point of view, self-employment primarily means greater autonomy – the ability to independently decide on the most important issues, such as the scope of cooperation, rates, or the number of orders accepted. A significant advantage is also the lack of restrictions on the number of contractors, which realistically increases professional flexibility and allows for better adjustment of the schedule to individual preferences. From a financial perspective, this is often a real chance for higher income, especially with a well-managed settlement model and the ability to deduct business expenses. At the same time, for companies cooperating with drivers on a B2B basis, this means lower employment costs – primarily in terms of the aforementioned ZUS contributions and employee benefits.

For many drivers, an argument for starting their own business is also the potential increase in creditworthiness, which can be helpful when purchasing a vehicle or investing in equipment. However, it must be remembered that greater independence also means greater responsibility – both formal and financial. A driver running a business does not benefit from the protection of the Labor Code: they are not entitled to vacation leave or sick benefits – therefore, they do not have the stability that full-time employees have.

Self-employment for a driver also involves a number of formal obligations – obtaining transport orders, keeping accounting records, paying due contributions (health, pension, disability, accident), and – which is particularly important in the transport industry – bearing responsibility for any damage caused during the transport, which often involves the need to purchase appropriate insurance policies.

What are the obligations and risks for the carrier?

Cooperation with drivers based on civil law contracts does not exempt carriers from the obligation to comply with regulations regarding the minimum hourly rate. This is an absolute minimum that must be provided to every contractor, regardless of the content of the contract or the form of settlement.

According to the announcement of the Prime Minister, as of January 1, 2025, the minimum hourly rate is 30.50 PLN gross. The principal is obliged to pay remuneration of at least this amount for every hour of service provision. Violation of this obligation, i.e., paying remuneration below this value, results in high administrative sanctions – a fine ranging from 1,000 PLN to 30,000 PLN.

As follows from the Act on Minimum Wage, the company must keep documents specifying the method of confirming and the actual number of hours of performing the order/service. If the method of confirming the number of hours has not been specified in the contract, the contractor must submit to the employer – in written, electronic, or document form – a statement of hours before the payment of remuneration. This can be done, for example, as part of an issued invoice or a separate attachment.

The carrier, as the party using the services, is obliged to keep documentation related to the record of hours for a period of at least three years from the date the remuneration becomes due.

In the reality of increasingly frequent and rigorous PIP (National Labor Inspectorate) inspections in transport companies, the lack of well-thought-out procedures in this area can result in financial penalties, as well as serious legal and reputational consequences.

Is a mandate contract a good form of cooperation with a driver?

According to the current legal status, a driver performing international road transport – regardless of the legal basis – cannot be treated as a person on a business trip. This follows clearly from Article 26f of the Act on Working Time of Drivers, which excludes the application of the “business trip” structure in relation to drivers performing transport tasks outside the country.

From the carrier’s perspective, the civil law model of cooperation can generate measurable financial benefits, which were mentioned earlier. However, it is worth emphasizing that the lack of obligations characteristic of an employment relationship does not mean complete freedom in shaping the terms of cooperation. The carrier is still responsible for the compliance of work organization with applicable regulations, including in particular compliance with the Act on Working Time of Drivers, EU transport regulations, and regulations regarding posting.

Consequently, although the civil law form of employment eliminates some formal obligations, it also carries certain risks – particularly in terms of the interpretation of the nature of the cooperation by regulatory authorities, e.g., the National Labor Inspectorate (PIP) or the Social Insurance Institution (ZUS).

What are the legal limitations of civil law contracts in transport?

One of the potential benefits of entering into a mandate contract with a driver is the possibility of limiting contribution obligations on the part of the carrier. Exemption from paying social security contributions is, however, conditional – it is only available if the contractor has another title to insurance from which the basis for calculating contributions is at least equal to the current minimum wage. In such a case, only the health insurance contribution remains mandatory.

Although this structure is often used in the transport industry as a cost optimization tool, one must remember the limits set by applicable regulations. According to Art. 22 § 1² of the Labor Code and judicial decisions, it is unacceptable to circumvent the law by replacing an employment contract with a civil law contract in a situation where the manner of performing duties indicates the real existence of an employment relationship.

For carriers, this means one thing: incorrect legal classification of cooperation with a driver carries serious risks – both in the context of ZUS or PIP inspections and civil liability. Cost optimization cannot mean actions that fictitiously and unjustifiably change a driver’s employment based on an employment contract to a civil law form.

Can a mandate contract meet the conditions of professional driver employment?

Carriers should be well aware of the boundary between a mandate contract and an employment relationship – failure to make a proper distinction can prove risky for the employer. In an era of increasingly restrictive inspections, especially in the TSL industry, incorrectly classifying relationships with drivers can result in serious consequences for the entire organization. What should you pay the most attention to?

In the operational practice of transport companies, there are situations where a mandate contract contains elements characteristic of an employment relationship. If the content of the contract shows that the driver:

  • is obliged to perform work personally,
  • in a fixed place and time,
  • under organizational and service subordination,
  • then regardless of the legal title, according to current regulations, we are de facto dealing with the establishment of an employment relationship.

In such a case, the principal – acting in practice like an employer – exposes themselves to liability for an offense against employee rights, as referred to in the Labor Code. A finding by state authorities that the conditions of cooperation meet the criteria of an employment relationship results in the obligation to convert the civil law contract into an employment contract – with retroactive effect.

As a result, the carrier is obliged to settle all amounts resulting from statutory employee rights:

  • overtime pay,
  • equivalent for unused vacation, bonuses, and supplements to the minimum wage,
  • outstanding social security contributions plus interest.

Conclusions? The legal form of the contract does not matter if its content and method of implementation correspond to an employment relationship. Attempts to circumvent regulations using civil law structures can be ineffective and generate real financial and legal risks.

What procedures apply when hiring foreigners?

As we have already written on our blog, in a situation of a regularly deepening shortage of professional drivers in Europe – the scale of which is currently estimated at over 230,000 vacancies, and within a few years – even at 745,000 – more and more transport companies are turning their attention to hiring foreigners.

It is an obvious fact that regardless of the driver’s nationality, the entrepreneur is obliged to strictly adhere to the principle of equal treatment in employment, both in terms of working conditions and remuneration. Hiring foreigners in the TSL industry is one of the answers to the problem of staff shortages, but it requires a high level of compliance with migration regulations and labor law. This is a fairly complex process, and its details largely depend on the citizenship of the potential driver. In many cases, the standard procedure includes, among others:

  • verification of the legality of stay,
  • obtaining a work permit (or a single permit – for residence and work),
  • concluding a contract in accordance with applicable regulations (employment contract or civil law contract),
  • notifying the employment to the appropriate administrative authorities (e.g., the voivode),
  • submitting a copy of the contract to the appropriate office.

Can non-EU citizens drive vehicles in Poland?

From the perspective of a Polish carrier, checking and regulating the driver’s documentation is essential for maintaining compliance with national and EU regulations, and thus for avoiding the risk of administrative sanctions, financial penalties, or vehicle impoundment during inspections.

Hiring a foreigner for a professional driver position is a multi-stage process, the details of which depend, among other things, on the candidate’s citizenship and the nature of the planned transport. In addition to legalizing stay and work, it is also necessary to have documents confirming the qualifications to perform the profession of a driver in the European Union. The foreigner should have current and valid documents confirming professional qualifications, such as a driver’s license, driver card, and in the case of international transport – a driver attestation. Importantly, a person staying in Poland for more than 185 days a year is obliged to exchange their driver’s license for a Polish document.

However, if the candidate comes from a country that is a party to the Vienna Convention on Road Traffic (e.g., Ukraine, Georgia, Azerbaijan) or from a country belonging to the EU or the European Free Trade Association (EFTA), the process of exchanging the document is a formality that does not require retaking the exam. In other cases – when the country of origin is not a party to the convention – it is necessary to obtain a new Polish driver’s license, which usually involves the obligation to pass a theoretical exam.

The document exchange takes place at the Communication Department appropriate for the foreigner’s place of residence. It should be remembered that detailed rules often result from bilateral agreements concluded by Poland with individual third countries, so we recommend seeking up-to-date information at the district office (starostwo) or the voivodeship office each time. We also encourage you to contact OCRK experts who will help you stay compliant with the latest regulations.

What are the most common myths about alternative forms of driver employment?

Can running a business by a driver be equated with a typical employment relationship? This is an interpretative error that can have serious legal and tax consequences. Although self-employment is sometimes treated as an alternative to an employment contract, in reality, it is a form of conducting business, not an employment relationship – which means completely different obligations for both parties to the contract, as well as separate rules for settlements, insurance, and a different scope of responsibility. An alarming phenomenon remains the unjustified attribution of rights reserved exclusively for full-time employees to self-employed drivers.

Does outsourcing eliminate the employer’s obligations?

Although self-employment in transport is often perceived as a simplified form of cooperation, it does not exempt one from administrative and documentation obligations, which in practice can be just as demanding as in the case of classic forms of cooperation.

According to Art. 26d of the Act of April 16, 2004, on the Working Time of Drivers, an entrepreneur personally performing road transport based on Regulation (EC) No 561/2006 is obliged to keep records of working time independently. This documentation should be based on data from tachograph charts or the driver card and kept for a period of at least two years.

In practice, it is recommended that working time records be kept only by drivers who perform transport based on their own license. In other cases – especially when the self-employed driver does not have a license – a more justified solution is for the principal to keep the records, which facilitates subsequent settlements and ensures consistency with requirements regarding sectoral wages.

It should be noted that the obligation to document working time is universal and applies to all forms of providing transport services. Self-employed drivers are subject to regulations regarding the settlement of remuneration for work abroad, as well as the obligation to report posting in the IMI system. Furthermore, according to Article 26c of the discussed act, drivers performing transport based on civil law contracts must respect weekly and average weekly working time standards.

Is employee leasing safe for the company?

In conditions of intense work pace in transport, flexible forms of employment are gaining importance. Especially during periods of increased demand – such as temporary spikes in orders or vacation seasons, entrepreneurs are increasingly turning to solutions that allow for quick replenishment of staffing shortages. One such solution is employee leasing. Although it can be an effective tool, it also carries risks that must be kept in mind.

Employee leasing can take the form of cooperation between two transport companies, but a more common practice is using the services of a temporary employment agency. In such a situation, all obligations toward the driver rest with the agency. The carrier who uses the services of the seconded employee settles with the agency based on the agreed fee for the service.

However, it is worth being aware that this solution also carries a certain risk – it is the carrier to whom the driver has been seconded who remains responsible for any shortcomings and errors regarding the application of social regulations, the use of tachographs, or road violations.

How do ZUS and PIP view alternative forms of driver employment?

Let’s look at the current legal status. Currently, if a mandate contract constitutes a fictitious substitute for an employment relationship, the employer faces a fine ranging from 1,000 PLN to 30,000 PLN. However, the consequences of such a classification go much further – including the obligation to recognize all employee rights, as well as the necessity to settle tax and contribution arrears. The employer may therefore be obliged to pay benefits due under an employment contract (e.g., vacation, overtime, etc.), as well as to pay all required ZUS contributions.

In the public sphere, announcements of changes regarding the fight against fictitious self-employment are becoming increasingly clear. The Ministry of Family, Labor and Social Policy is planning an amendment to the Act on the National Labor Inspectorate (PIP), aiming to equip inspectors with new tools enabling effective prevention of illegal replacement of employment contracts with civil law contracts. What exactly can be expected?

The planned reform assumes that in justified cases, a PIP inspector will be authorized to issue a decision ordering the replacement of a civil law contract with an employment contract. This type of solution constitutes the implementation of one of the so-called milestones of the National Recovery Plan (KPO) – and as the ministry assesses – it will clearly accelerate actions related to verifying and limiting abuses in the scope of so-called fictitious self-employment. The upcoming changes mean greater protection for the employee and a real risk for entrepreneurs who decide to circumvent labor law regulations.

Source: EUROWAG