
The terms “advance payment” (zaliczka) and “deposit” (zadatek) are often used interchangeably, which indicates a misunderstanding of their nature. Although both are forms of transaction security in business, they differ significantly. Above all, the consequences resulting from the use of an advance payment versus a deposit will be different. In this article, you will learn which form of security to choose and what its consequences are.
Advance payment, or a part of a future obligation
The Civil Code contains the concept of an advance payment (Article 743 of the Civil Code), but it does not provide any definition of this form of security, which causes many problems.
Currently, advance payments are most often used in mandate contracts, agency contracts, and commission contracts. In the simplest terms, an advance payment is a part of a future obligation paid by one of the parties to the contract before the due date or before the moment the other party receives the performance.
Both parties to the contract indicate themselves what part of the amount will be treated as an advance payment collected before the performance is realized. Usually, it is determined by specifying a specific amount, but it can also be done by a percentage ratio. Examples:
“The Buyer undertakes to pay the amount of PLN 2,000.00 by June 3rd of this year as an advance payment. The indicated amount should be paid to the bank account indicated by the Seller.”
“Under this agreement, the Service Recipient is obliged to pay an advance payment in the amount of 20% of the service price specified in the contract. The advance payment should be made on the day of signing the contract.”
The most important thing in the case of an advance payment is that in the event of withdrawal from the contract or its termination by mutual agreement, the paid amount is returned to the one who paid it. However, if the party obliged to perform the service delays its execution before withdrawing from the contract, an additional deadline must be set for the obligor. Only after this deadline can one demand the return of the paid advance. Such a requirement will not be mandatory if we specify a strictly defined deadline in the contract – then there is no need to set another one.
If the parties do not fulfill their obligations, they are liable under Article 471 of the Civil Code, ex contracto, meaning they must compensate for the damage resulting from non-performance or improper performance of the obligation. Therefore, when the debtor is the party collecting the advance, one can demand both the return of the paid amount and compensation for the damage that occurred due to the non-performance of the obligation.
If, however, it is the party paying the advance that does not perform the contract, this amount is credited towards the contract amount, while the remaining part of the debt is treated as a failure to fulfill the due performance. This gives the possibility of filing a lawsuit for payment together with interest. It may also result in an obligation to compensate for damage under Article 471 of the Civil Code.
Does an advance payment always have to be returned?
In accordance with the freedom of contract, the parties can independently establish and change the provisions related to the advance payment. This applies primarily to business relations, because the consumer, as a non-specialized entity, is covered by special protection.
As part of the modifications, one can, for example:
- Specify in what situations the advance payment is non-refundable;
- Specify what amounts and titles the total advance payment consists of;
- Create a non-refundable advance payment clause.
The last point will be an abusive (prohibited) clause in contracts where one of the parties is a consumer. As an example of such a provision, one can point to the entry found in the register of prohibited clauses based on the judgment of the Regional Court in Warsaw, the Court for Competition and Consumer Protection, file number XVII Amc 56/05:
“In the event of withdrawal from the contract by the Ordering Party, the advance payment is forfeited to the Contractor in its entirety”
When the withdrawal from the contract by the consumer is reported within the time limit available to the party, the contract is considered not concluded, and the advance payment must be returned.
Besides, there is no deadline that would specify the time for returning an advance payment. In the regulations, we only find information that when one of the parties to the contract from which one has withdrawn is a consumer, the return of the performance is to take place immediately. In other cases, this deadline is to result from the contract concluded by the parties or (in its absence) the advance payment should be paid after the other party is called upon to return it.
Deposit – effective security for contract performance
Unlike an advance payment, a deposit (zadatek) is legally defined in Article 394 of the Civil Code. As in the case of an advance payment, upon performance of the service, the deposit is credited towards the final amount. However, its main role is to secure the performance of the contract. Therefore, when one of the parties to the contract does not perform the service to which it committed itself in that contract, the deposit is treated as a form of compensation for the party entitled to collect it. In this situation, it is not subject to return.
The deposit is settled differently when the person entitled to collect it does not perform the contract due to their own fault. Then, this party must return the paid amount in double the amount. Such a demand from the other party can only occur when the responsibility for the lack of performance of the obligation lies exclusively with the party collecting the deposit.
However, when the lack of performance of the contract is caused by circumstances over which neither party had influence and for which they are not responsible, or when both parties bear such responsibility, the deposit is settled. It should therefore be returned, but without the need to pay double its amount.
Another issue that distinguishes a deposit from an advance payment is the possibility of withdrawing from the contract – this is required by law if the contract contains a clause specifying the obligation to pay a deposit. Therefore, there is no need to introduce any additional contractual provisions.
The very act of handing over a deposit is a real legal act, i.e., it consists of handing it over – so for such an institution to be effective, not only must its amount be agreed upon, but the deposit must also be actually handed over. It is worth knowing, however, that this does not have to happen at the moment of signing the contract. This view has evolved over the years, but currently, the Supreme Court, in its judgment of February 8, 2008, file number I CSK 328/07, allows the possibility of handing over the deposit after the conclusion of the contract if the parties make such provisions in the contract:
(…) this provision (Art. 394 § 1 of the Civil Code) is dispositive in nature, so it is not excluded, as is pointed out in the doctrine, for the parties to agree in the contract that the amount intended to be a deposit will be transferred to the contractor within an agreed time after the conclusion of the contract, in such a way that it will be paid into their account. Excluding such a possibility, especially with a deposit representing a significant value, would expose the parties to additional difficulties related to the security of such a transaction.
Which form to choose? Advance payment vs. deposit
Unfortunately, there is no single correct answer to this question. Each of these forms of transaction security has its pros, and they can be beneficial to the parties to the contract depending on its purpose.
Nevertheless, it is pointed out that it is the deposit that gives significantly more benefits to the party to the contract that undertakes to perform the service. Then, if the other party withdraws from the contract, the loss of the order will be, at least in part, compensated by the paid deposit. This makes it accepted that it is the deposit that is a more favorable option than an advance payment.
The most important advantages resulting from choosing a deposit are:
- securing the performance of the contract;
- in the event of withdrawal from the contract by the party paying the deposit, it is forfeited as compensation;
- when the party collecting the deposit withdraws from the contract, the amount is returned in double the amount;
- it is possible to construct a contract in such a way that it is concluded on the condition of paying a deposit;
- there is a possibility of modifying the effects of the deposit.
As for the disadvantages, one will certainly be the lack of an upper limit for the deposit. Additionally, the Supreme Court in judgment V CK 577/04 allowed for the possibility of determining a deposit with a value exceeding even half the price of the entire service. In addition, the freedom of contract can go so far in this case that the institution of the deposit will absorb other options provided for by civil law, e.g., a contractual penalty.
Sometimes, however, the parties to a contract only want to cover costs appearing before the finalization of the contractual service. Then, an advance payment will definitely be a better solution. What are its key advantages? Well, a paid advance payment:
- is credited towards the total amount;
- can be returned if there is a withdrawal from the contract or its termination;
- can be settled and returned to the party that paid it – when the fault lies with both parties;
- gives the possibility of freely modifying advance payment clauses in the contract.
The disadvantage will be the lack of sufficient security for the contract, because the advance payment can be returned. Besides, using an advance payment clause means that in order to be able to withdraw from the contract, one must set an additional deadline for the performance of the obligation. Furthermore, one must remember that an advance payment is subject to a 2-year limitation period on the same basis as a claim for remuneration in accordance with Article 751 of the Civil Code.
Taxes in the case of an advance payment and a deposit
An advance payment and a deposit are perceived in the same way by tax law regulations. In this case, we distinguish two tax obligations, i.e., VAT and income tax.
The tax obligation in the case of tax on goods and services arises at the moment of receiving the payment. It does not matter whether the whole or only part of the payment was transferred. Therefore, both a deposit and an advance payment cause a tax obligation for the entrepreneur (in the place where they received them).
When the contract is not performed due to the fault of the other party, the advance payment must be returned, while the entrepreneur must issue a corrective invoice and make the refund. As for the deposit, it is retained, but it will no longer constitute part of the future price. Then it changes its character to a security for the contract – it thus becomes compensation not subject to VAT.
The obligation to pay personal income tax does not arise as a result of receiving an advance payment or a deposit, but because the act does not treat collected receivables towards the supply of goods and services as income. Therefore, the obligation to pay PIT arises only at the moment of issuing the final invoice.
Conclusions
Although an advance payment and a deposit function on a daily basis in business, they are still quite problematic. For the effective use of these forms of contract security, it is worth knowing their consequences, disadvantages, and advantages. In the case of entrepreneurs, it is also a necessity to regulate the tax obligation that results from their collection.
However, in order to effectively construct a contract and choose the best form of transaction security, it is best to consult a law firm that will take into account the interests of both parties.







