A transport contract without pitfalls

A transport contract without pitfalls

Proper drafting of contracts and transport orders, as well as other transport documents, allows for the protection of the interests of both the freight forwarder and the carrier. Unfortunately, in practice, a transport contract is most often drafted in favor of the principal, containing provisions that may be troublesome for the carrier.

To reduce the likelihood of legal disputes, at the stage of negotiating the terms of a transport order, we should familiarize ourselves with it in detail and submit comments before accepting it. By seeking the advice of lawyers proficient in transport law, we can identify problematic provisions. And thanks to this, protect ourselves against potential losses. So, how to draft a transport order without pitfalls?

Transport contract

A transport contract, also called a transport order, is a document defining the terms of cooperation between the parties to a transport contract concluded in light of Art. 774 of the Civil Code. In turn, Art. 779 of the Civil Code specifies what information should be provided there. These are: the sender’s address, the recipient’s address, the place of destination, the designation of the shipment by type, quantity, and method of packaging, as well as the value of particularly valuable items, as well as the place and date of loading and unloading, the freight amount, and the payment deadline.

Importantly, in the event of non-payment for the execution of a transport order and debt collection, the preserved documentation confirming the concluded order may influence the course and final result of the debt collection proceedings.

Transport order vs. forwarding order

It happens that a transport order is confused with a forwarding order. Under a forwarding order, the principal entrusts the organization of the entire logistics process to a freight forwarder. When executing the order, the forwarder may transport the goods using their own fleet or use the services of a transport company.

In the case of a transport order, the carrier only deals with the transport of goods, without the need to organize the entire logistics process.

How to conclude a transport contract?

A transport contract does not require a written order containing the signatures of both parties for its validity. Such contracts are binding as long as both parties had the opportunity to familiarize themselves with the terms of the order sent by email, instant messenger, or other means of electronic communication. Such a situation allows for the presumption that the other party knows the content of the order and accepts it.

We can also conclude a transport order in oral form. However, let us remember that the lack of a written form may expose the carrier to unnecessary problems. In the event of non-payment after the execution of a transport order (concluded, for example, by phone), it is of course possible to recover the debt through court proceedings. However, the proceedings may require more time and the carrier’s participation in hearings.

These inconveniences can be avoided by concluding a transport order in writing.

Contractual penalties in transport orders

It is very important to pay attention to provisions that may violate our interests before accepting an order, as contractual penalties in transport orders can be downright absurd.

The content of a transport order must, of course, be consistent with applicable regulations. This refers to the CMR Convention and the provisions of transport law. Importantly, contractual penalties written into the order will be ineffective if they are not in accordance with national or international law and the Civil Code.

Cancellation of a transport order

Neither transport law nor the CMR Convention regulates the issue of canceling a transport order. General provisions apply here. According to Art. 471 of the Civil Code, “the debtor is obliged to repair the damage resulting from non-performance or improper performance of the obligation, unless the non-performance or improper performance is the result of circumstances for which the debtor is not responsible.” However, remember that the content of the contract may provide for a contractual penalty in the event of order cancellation.

Consignment note

Another important element in the transport of goods is the consignment note. However, remember that its absence or the appearance of errors in it does not constitute a basis for challenging the validity of the entire contract.

From the perspective of domestic transport, the Transport Law Act mentions the consignment note as proof of the conclusion of a contract. The document itself may take the form of an electronic transmission, a printout, or another document that contains the information specified in Art. 38 of the aforementioned act. These include the sender’s data – name, address, and signature, as well as the recipient’s data – name, address, place of destination of the shipment, and its exact description. The consignment note should also contain all declarations and indications that are required or permitted under the regulations, in connection with the terms of the contract or the method of settlement.

The CMR Convention expands the catalog of data that must be included in the consignment note. These are: the place and date of issue of the aforementioned document, the name and address of the sender, carrier, and recipient, as well as the place and date of receipt of the goods along with the intended place of delivery. The CMR Convention also expands the list to include the commonly used name or description of the goods and the method of their packaging.

In the case of dangerous goods, mention is made, among other things, of their generally accepted description, number of pieces, and their characteristics, numbers, and gross weight. All instructions necessary to complete formalities must also be included. As well as a statement confirming that the transport of goods is subject to the provisions of the CMR Convention – regardless of any contrary clauses.

Customs documents

The sender should also remember to attach customs documents and inform the freight forwarder about all necessary formalities.

Note – a clause in a contract that transfers responsibility for failure to fulfill customs obligations to the carrier is not consistent with the CMR Convention and transport law.

The consignment note is also the place where the carrier can place their reservations regarding the condition of the transported goods. If they do not do so – according to Art. 9 of the CMR Convention, there is a presumption that the goods and their packaging were in good condition at the time of receipt by the carrier. Also, the number of pieces, as well as their characteristics and numbers, were in accordance with the statements in the consignment note.

Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna