
The transport industry, like other sectors of the economy, is increasingly becoming a target for cybercriminals who use fake emails to extort funds. One common method is so-called email fraud or phishing, where criminals impersonate employees or contractors to redirect payments to their own accounts. The application of this method in transport is often particularly effective due to the high frequency of transactions and the international nature of cooperation, which often makes it difficult to detect fraud.
How does fund extortion via a fake email address work?
The mechanism of this type of fraud is relatively simple.
– Fraudsters impersonate a person or company (most often a supplier of services or goods) to intercept a payment that, according to the contract, should go to the actual recipient’s account. Criminals gain access to email inboxes or create an email address deceptively similar to the real one (for example, with a slightly changed letter or domain extension), and then send a message with instructions to transfer funds to a “new” bank account – says Paulina Eliasz-Pietrusewicz, legal counsel at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Most often, these schemes involve fake invoices – the fraudster sends an email with an invoice that looks like the original, often with seemingly authentic sender details, but with a fake account number provided.
Instructions to change a bank account are also dangerous – criminals inform that the supplier’s bank account has changed and ask for funds to be transferred to a new, fake account.
Impersonating management is also used. The criminal sends a message in which they pose as a board member or financial director, ordering an urgent transfer to a specified account.
Transfer to a fake account number – court verdict
In Poland, a situation recently occurred where a transport company fell victim to fraud. After receiving a message from an email address where the sender impersonated a key supplier, the company transferred the payment to a fake account in another country. The criminals exploited a loophole in email security and a lack of payment verification procedures. Eventually, the case went to court. The carrier sued its contractor, who had sent the payment to the account number indicated in the fake email instead of the account on the invoice. The contractor explained that along with the payment reminder, they received an invoice with a new account number from the email address from which they had previously received emails from the carrier. For this reason, the contractor believed they had fulfilled their obligation and had no duty to pay for the same service a second time. However, the court ruled that the contractor is responsible for verifying payment details and should have exercised greater caution. Even if they fell victim to fraud, they did not fulfill their obligation to the carrier. Since the contractor did not exercise special caution when verifying the account, they should pay the plaintiff again, as the plaintiff did not receive the transferred funds. (Judgment of the District Court in Kalisz of 30.11.2022, case file: V GC 460/18)
Why is transport particularly vulnerable to fraud?
The legal counsel from TC Kancelaria Prawna sees the reason for this state of affairs in the specifics of the TSL sector:
– The transport industry involves frequent and rapid international transactions. Orders are carried out in various countries and on a large scale, which increases the difficulty of tracking all payments and communication. In such conditions, it is difficult to catch fake messages, especially when fraudsters prepare the message well – for example, by attaching documents that look like real invoices and waybills – says Paulina Eliasz-Pietrusewicz.
Additionally, transport requires cooperation with many partners, which increases the chance that fraud will be overlooked. Criminals often take advantage of moments when companies are under pressure, e.g., due to the need for quick delivery or paying for services on time, to create urgency and reduce the chance of data verification.
How to protect yourself against fraud via fake email addresses?
Protection against phishing and fraud in the transport industry requires a number of precautions and the implementation of special procedures. The first and basic line of defense is education, i.e., training for employees. They must know how to recognize potentially suspicious emails, especially those containing payment instructions. Verification of changes in payment details is also important – every notification regarding a change of bank account should be verified by contacting the person who issued the invoice by phone. This is especially important when the message appears at an unexpected moment or from a contractor with whom contact has been rare so far. Furthermore, every change in a bank account or payment terms should go through a dedicated person in the company responsible for verifying this information. Employees of financial departments should be trained to react with caution to every unusual request to change data and to verify the truthfulness of the notification.
Let us also remember to use secure communication channels. Using financial management systems with two-factor authentication (2FA) and appropriate security measures can help avoid situations where someone gains access to confidential information or takes over email communication.
Let us also pay attention to regular monitoring of all changes in supplier and customer data – this can help in faster detection of fraud. In case of any suspicions, all contact details should be carefully checked to rule out that they are fake.
What to do in case of suspected fraud?
If a transport company discovers that it has fallen victim to fraud, it is crucial to take a few steps immediately. First, report it to the bank immediately – this may increase the chances of reversing the transfer if the fraud is detected early enough. Then, the police should be notified. Cybercrimes, such as the extortion of funds, should be reported to law enforcement agencies. In the case of international activities, the police can initiate cooperation with foreign services.
Analyzing the incident and strengthening security is also important. Every company that has experienced fraud should conduct a security audit and implement additional procedures to prevent future fraud.
Extorting funds via fake emails is a growing threat, and the transport industry, due to its specificity, is particularly vulnerable to such incidents. The consequences of email fraud can be very severe for transport companies. In addition to direct financial loss, companies incur additional costs related to investigating and recovering funds, which is particularly difficult in the case of international fraud. Such incidents can negatively affect business relationships if companies are unable to fulfill their payment obligations.
If the case goes to court, the process of asserting one’s rights is long-term, and the recovery of funds is uncertain.
– Effective defense against this type of crime requires, above all, employee education, meticulous verification procedures, and quick reactions to suspicious situations. These actions can not only prevent significant financial losses but also increase the level of security of cooperation in international markets. The use of advanced anti-fraud systems and cooperation with financial institutions and law enforcement agencies can significantly reduce the number of such incidents – advises the expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna








