
Events such as the recent flooding in the south of the country or the Covid-19 pandemic from a few years ago can cause problems with the transport of goods, including failure to deliver them on time, or their loss or damage. The carrier has no influence on their occurrence and is unable to prevent their consequences. Do such circumstances provide grounds for invoking force majeure?
Force majeure in Polish transport law
In Article 65 of the Transport Law Act, the legislator strictly indicated that the carrier is not liable for damage to goods, their loss or shortage, and delay in delivery resulting from the occurrence of force majeure.
Under the concept of force majeure, we will understand:
- an external event,
- impossible to foresee,
- with no possibility of preventing its effects
– Examples of force majeure include, among others, actions of state authorities, e.g., closing a border or war, strikes, riots, as well as natural disasters extraordinary for a given area or season, i.e., floods, earthquakes, storms, or blizzards. To treat them as force majeure, the carrier must demonstrate that the circumstances that occurred exclude their liability – explains Paweł Łazarewicz, legal counsel at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
The CMR Convention and force majeure
The CMR Convention does not use the term force majeure; however, the structure excluding the carrier’s liability is indicated in Article 17. According to it, the carrier is not liable for circumstances that could not be avoided and the consequences of which could not be prevented. This provision therefore has a similar character to our force majeure, although in this case, it is a much broader concept. Nevertheless, even in such a case, the carrier is obliged to demonstrate the circumstances excluding their liability.
– It should be emphasized that not every situation will be considered force majeure. For example, the state of the Covid-19 pandemic itself maintained in a given country is not force majeure, but closing the border with a given country during a pandemic can be considered as such. Likewise, a flood that has been ongoing for some time will not provide the possibility of invoking force majeure – points out Paweł Łazarewicz.
Events allowing for the exclusion of carrier liability
- Road accidents – in such a case, the lack of fault on the part of the carrier or another road user is not enough. The driver must demonstrate that they could have avoided the accident, e.g., by performing a specific maneuver, which will be aided by the findings of the police or a court expert in the field of road traffic.
- Strikes – can exclude liability if the carrier demonstrates that it was the strike that led to a situation that could not be avoided. This refers, for example, to the necessity of changing the route, which affected the delivery deadline of the goods.
- Atmospheric conditions – these include unexpected violent and sudden snowfall or rain or gales in a given place. If such an event occurs in a place where it is foreseeable (for example, snowfall in winter in mountainous areas), the exclusion of liability for improperly performed transport cannot be applied.
- Fires or arson of vehicles – the carrier may invoke circumstances exempting them from liability in the event of an external fire of a vehicle located in a guarded parking lot or hangar. The situation will be different when a driver leaves their car in an unguarded parking lot near their home for the entire weekend and the car burns down in the meantime. In such a case, we are dealing with gross negligence on the part of the carrier.
- Attacks by armed assailants – in this situation, the possibility of excluding liability depends on the circumstances lying on the side of both the driver, the carrier, and the assailants. The driver must demonstrate its course, including their behavior before the attack (place and time of the stop, time of day, or route), during its duration (reasons for stopping and leaving the vehicle), and after the event – here it is important how quickly they notified the appropriate services. In the case of the carrier, the type of vehicle, its equipment, and the organization of transport will be important. To exclude liability in this case, it is also necessary to analyze the actions of the assailants, in particular their number, behavior, or level of aggression, including the use of a specific type of weapon.
We should analyze every situation in terms of excluding our liability by invoking force majeure with a great deal of caution. Not always what meets the hallmarks of force majeure in our eyes will be as unambiguous for the court after presenting evidence.
Can force majeure clauses be included in transport contracts?
One of the main principles of civil law is the principle of freedom of contract, regulated in Article 353^1 of the Civil Code. Entrepreneurs have the ability to freely, but not arbitrarily, shape their legal relationships. What is the purpose of including a force majeure clause in their contracts, since both transport law and the CMR Convention regulate this issue?
– Both transport law and the CMR Convention treat these issues very narrowly. Therefore, through a force majeure clause, we can narrow our liability, e.g., to natural disasters, or expand it and recognize that the occurrence of force majeure is a basis for terminating the contract. Such a clause must be formulated in a precise and unambiguous manner. If we do not do this, it may be considered invalid and non-binding for the other party to the contract. Remember to formulate such clauses in a precise and unambiguous manner. Otherwise, such a clause may be considered invalid and non-binding for the other party to the contract. Additionally, according to Article 41 of the CMR Convention, any clause that directly or indirectly violates the provisions of the Convention, including in particular any clause shifting the burden of proof, is invalid and void – emphasizes the expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
In the event of a lack of force majeure regulation in your contract, remember to be able to demonstrate a causal link between the event with the hallmarks of force majeure and the damage that occurred, and also that you have taken all steps to fulfill your contract.
Additionally, if we have ongoing cooperation with a given client, we have the possibility of invoking the clause of extraordinary change of circumstances (Article 357^1 of the Civil Code). This applies to situations where, due to an unforeseen situation, we are unable to perform the contract without excessive problems or losses. However, a requirement in such a situation is the obligation to refer such a case to court, which is consequently time-consuming and expensive.
Problematic force majeure
When analyzing the circumstances of a given case, we must always take into account its individual character. Not every situation that is obvious to us at first glance constitutes a circumstance excluding our liability due to force majeure. In such cases, one must exercise special caution and remember that the burden of proof lies with the carrier.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna







