A four-day work week in the transport industry?

A four-day work week in the transport industry?

Western Europe and large countries like Australia or Canada have long been introducing a 4-day work week. In Poland, a discussion on this topic has been ongoing for a long time, and traditionally, this solution has both supporters and opponents. However, when it comes to transport, we have only opponents of shorter working hours. It is certain that changes to the Labor Code in this regard will not take place before 2027.

Mariusz Frąc and Wojciech Romaniuk, founders of the Polish Transport Ambassador Association, talk about why a 4-day work week currently has no place in the transport industry.

Looking at administrative, management, or online service industries, it is already easy to apply a shorter work week there today. However, in transport, specialists do not see the possibility of introducing such an option at this moment.

– I see no advantages for transport entrepreneurs. I am convinced that if a four-day work week were to come into effect, drivers would still work as much as they do now. And the owner of a transport company will pay more social security contributions for overtime. And the most important issue with transport introducing a shorter work week – unfortunately, it will cause further, significant price increases for products transported by trucks, which is practically everything we use on a daily basis – says Mariusz Frąc, CEO of MaWo Group, an expert on the development of the Polish transport market.

– We must also remember what lies behind the idea of a 4-day work week. It is about being able to spend more time with family and dedicating it to one’s passions. In transport, especially for drivers, this is simply not possible for “technical” reasons. A driver is often on the road for several weeks; there is no chance for them to return to the base every 4 days. It is as if we wanted to introduce such a work mode for sailors; there is absolutely no chance for that there. Such solutions are realistic in “stationary” workplaces – the expert adds.

The economic situation will not allow for shorter working hours in transport

The transport industry believes that even in the distant future, the introduction of a shortened work week will not be applicable. Economic factors will not allow it. There are timid voices that perhaps transport-related industries might try such a solution, e.g., service centers and tire replacement, however, either way, it will affect the increase in transport costs themselves and the prices of these products or services. A huge increase in costs is the most common and flagship argument of Polish carriers. Some suggest that due to this solution, transport rates could increase by as much as 40%. The same arguments also apply to freight forwarding and logistics, which are directly related to road transport.

There are also employee issues, i.e., professional drivers. One cannot ignore people’s expectations. And drivers, like transport company owners, also do not see the possibility of introducing a four-day work week in their profession.

– Let’s try to imagine, in a situation of a shortened work week, replacements, or a quick replacement for a driver who is currently in France with a load. Remember that a driver is obliged to comply with standards regarding driving time, breaks, and rest periods resulting from other regulations. These standards are currently much longer than the working time resulting from the Labor Code. As of today, the National Labor Inspectorate (PIP) imposes multi-thousand fines, and if the proposed change is added, it will be multiplied even further; it would practically be a harvest for the PIP – explains Wojciech Romaniuk, CEO of MaWo Group and the Polish Transport Ambassador Association, a specialist in driver settlements.

Regulations concerning drivers’ work cannot be transferred and implemented in a 4-day work week now (even in a 5-day week there are problems with it). These regulations differ from those in the Labor Code. They are not a duplication of the Labor Code, because in this matter, one must remember the Act on Working Time of Drivers, which regulates many things but is not perfect and often does not correspond to the reality of the daily work of drivers. Transport industry specialists simultaneously say that the record of drivers’ working time is able to “handle” a 4-day work week and technically it will be possible to settle it correctly. But the problem does not lie in theory, but in the practical conduct of transport business.

– Yes, our settlement systems regarding the record of drivers’ working time will calculate everything without a problem. It’s arithmetic. But transport company owners will no longer positively calculate the profitability of the delivery business. From my perspective, looking at Polish transport companies as a whole, this is an unimaginable situation – concludes Wojciech Romaniuk.

When discussing a shortened work week in transport, the argument about the lack of a sufficient number of professional drivers appears again. Today, the transport industry still offers tens of thousands of vacancies, and this will not change over the next 3–4 years. Transport cannot have such long breaks in operations, which is why a discussion immediately arises about driver replacements, which are supposed to ensure the continuity of deliveries. Not to mention the strikes of Polish carriers, which have been taking place regularly in various parts of Poland for several months. The protest actions are intended to draw the Ministry of Infrastructure’s attention to the dramatic situation of Polish transport companies today. Therefore, discussions about a shortened work week do not fall on fertile ground given the growing problems of Polish transport.

Or perhaps a day will come in the distant future when a 4-day work week will exist in the transport industry?

– When Polish roads are dominated by autonomous trucks – summarizes Mariusz Frąc with a wink.

Source: Newseria/ MaWo Group/ Polish Transport Ambassador Association