
Unfair practices, low rates, and poor working conditions for drivers are some of the numerous challenges faced by the transport industry in Poland. Spain and Hungary have recently dealt with similar problems. Could the introduction of analogous legal regulations be a step towards improving the situation in the domestic market? What potential benefits would these changes bring to the Polish transport industry?
The implementation of new regulations in Spain and Hungary still sparks much discussion and consideration. However, analysis suggests that similar regulations could contribute to improving the situation for drivers and the quality of transport services in Poland. What specific problems did these two European countries solve, and how?
Spain – ban on loading and unloading of goods by drivers
One of the problems in the transport industry is the frequent loading and unloading of goods by drivers. Although these activities are often voluntary and may involve a symbolic fee, many logistics operators impose this duty on drivers – even under the threat of contract termination.
– Such practices often result in shifting the responsibility for potential damage to goods onto the drivers. It also worsens their working conditions – as loading or unloading of goods takes place after a long route, without proper rest. Let us remember that this action is often performed alone, with loads weighing even several tons. For this reason, carriers are notoriously exposed to additional burdens and risks, as well as high financial penalties – says Maciej Maroszyk, Chief Operating Officer at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
The solution implemented in Spain on September 2, 2022, was the introduction of a ban on the loading and unloading of goods by drivers. This practice is now treated as a serious violation of regulations, punishable by a high fine – from 4,001 to 6,000 euros, and in the case of recidivism (within a year) – up to 18,000 euros.
– The regulations cover most road transport of goods by vehicles with a permissible total weight exceeding 7.5 tons. An exception to this is moving transport, transport of aggregates, or transport in tankers. There is also the possibility of loading and unloading goods by employees of transport companies – however, this can only be done for an additional fee and provided that an appropriate contract is concluded before loading. This separation of transport services from loading and unloading is intended to increase safety and improve working conditions for drivers – explains Maciej Maroszyk.
Is it worth introducing this regulation in Poland? The expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna confirms that it would be a good solution. At the same time, he points out that other countries, such as Portugal and France, are also considering introducing similar regulations. This shows a growing awareness of the need to protect the rights and safety of drivers in road transport.
Hungary – limiting the number of intermediaries and minimum rates
Another problem affecting the transport industry is the practice of “passing” loads through a long chain of subcontractors. This is a situation where principals use the services of many intermediaries who successively pass the transport task on, until it reaches the final contractor.
– Such a chain of subcontractors can result in excessive fragmentation of the transport process. This not only hinders control over the execution of the order but also forces drivers to accept increasingly lower rates for the service. As a result, given the complicated settlement structure and excessive competition, drivers are often forced to agree to financial conditions that do not reflect the actual costs of their work and vehicle maintenance – says the Chief Operating Officer from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Low rates contribute to the deterioration of drivers’ working conditions and a decrease in the quality of services provided. Additionally, the excess of intermediaries makes financial settlements unclear and can lead to disputes and payment delays.
The solution to the problem turned out to be the establishment of minimum rates in domestic cargo transport. The number of intermediaries and transport subcontractors was also limited to one. The regulations entered into force on January 28, 2024, in Hungary. The new regulation introduced a minimum, basic fee for the transport service, a fee for loading and sorting pallets, and downtime. This is an important step towards ensuring fair working conditions and decent remuneration for drivers.
– It is worth noting that similar regulations have been in force for over a year in Spain. And carrier associations in other countries – such as Romania, among others – are also considering introducing such solutions – explains the Chief Operating Officer of TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Regulations from abroad – will they work in Poland?
Knowing the difficulties faced by the transport industry, it is worth considering the implementation of regulations from Spain and Hungary in Poland as well. Problems related to unfair practices, low rates, and poor working conditions for drivers are common here and require urgent action. The introduction of appropriate regulations in Poland would have the potential to contribute to increasing safety and improving working conditions for drivers. In turn, ensuring fair rates for transport services would stabilize the transport market and prevent unfair practices that often lead to the exploitation of drivers and a decrease in the quality of services provided.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna







