Extension of payment terms due to delay in submitting transport documents

TC Kancelaria Prawna / Freepik

Payment terms are often a bone of contention between transport principals and carriers. Contracts may contain provisions indicating situations in which the payment term will be postponed. However, enforcing them can cause problems and lead to a dispute with a carrier who expects payment within the time frame consistent with the original order provisions.

An illustration of this phenomenon is a case that a client brought to a law firm. They entered into a contract for the delivery of goods with a carrier, who completed it on time and issued an invoice on the day the goods were delivered.

– In the contract, the client included a provision that makes timely payment for the service conditional upon the delivery of original transport documents within 7 to 14 days. Otherwise, the payment term may be extended to 90 days – explains Maurycy Kieruj, a lawyer at TC Kancelaria Prawna.

Because the carrier delivered the documents only after 25 days, the client decided to apply the above provision and withhold payment. The carrier challenged it, and due to not receiving payment on time, issued debit notes to the client. Did they have the right to challenge the contract provisions in this situation?

Time of document delivery versus contract provisions

The rules for payment and deadlines for submitting documents related to the performance of a transport contract can be regulated in the contract concluded between the sender and the carrier. In the described case, if the order contains a provision regarding the deadline for submitting original documents (from 7 to 14 days) and the possibility of extending the payment term to 90 days in case of delay, then these rules should be respected.

– While the deadline regulated as a range of “7 to 14 days” can be considered imprecise, it is not strictly a contractual penalty provision, therefore it would be too far-reaching to claim the invalidity of the contractual provision in its entirety – comments Maurycy Kieruj, a lawyer at TC Kancelaria Prawna.

On the other hand, the maximum indicated deadline, i.e., 14 days for the carrier to submit transport documents after the completion of transport, should be considered appropriate and achievable.

Contract regulations determine the application of penalties

If the carrier delivered the transport documents 25 days after the delivery of the goods, and the contract provides for the possibility of extending the payment term to 90 days in case of exceeding the document submission deadline, then according to the contract provisions, the client may extend the payment term.

However, if the carrier demands earlier payment or issues debit notes despite the deadline for submitting documents being exceeded, it is worth checking the contract provisions to see if such a scenario is regulated.

– If the contract does not provide for such a possibility, the company may rely on the contract provisions and maintain the payment term in accordance with the contractual conditions, i.e., the term extended to 90 days. Consequently, payment demands and debit notes for debt recovery costs or interest notes issued by the carrier for payment within the 90-day period will be unfounded – comments Maurycy Kieruj from TC Kancelaria Prawna.

In case of doubt or dispute, it is always worth consulting a lawyer to obtain an accurate interpretation of the contract provisions and determine what the rights and obligations of both parties are.

Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna