Incorrect data in a transport order and carrier liability

TC Kancelaria Prawna / Depositphotos

Despite the best intentions and a diligent approach by the carrier, the execution of a transport order may fail for other reasons. One of these is the inclusion of incorrect information in the order, which in practice can make it impossible to fulfill. What does this mean for the carrier?

The above problem is illustrated by a situation where a carrier receives incorrect data regarding the place of unloading. In accordance with the transport order, the carrier arrives at the loading point, the goods are correctly loaded in Poland, and a loading number is assigned. Subsequently, the driver transports the goods to the unloading point in Germany. Upon arrival, the carrier is informed that the goods cannot be unloaded because an incorrect loading number was assigned. The unloading should have taken place in Germany, but in a town 500 km away from the location indicated in the transport order.

Who bears the responsibility for the incorrect specification of the unloading place in the transport order, and can the carrier claim compensation for the unnecessarily performed route?

Immediate contact with the sender of the shipment

In the case described above, despite errors on the part of the principal, the correct conduct of the carrier will be essential.

– After receiving information about the inability to unload, the carrier should contact the sender and request instructions regarding further action. This is due to the fact that only the sender can dispose of the goods. Such an obligation of the carrier arises from Article 14(1) of the CMR Convention, which states that if for any reason it is or becomes impossible to carry out the contract of carriage in accordance with the terms laid down in the consignment note before the goods reach the place designated for delivery, the carrier shall ask for instructions from the person entitled to dispose of the goods – explains Beata Gądek, a lawyer at TC Kancelaria Prawna.

A common and at the same time incorrect action taken by carriers is making decisions on their own, for example, transporting the goods to a substitute warehouse.

In such a case, the carrier will not be able to claim compensation for the costs of storing the goods.

– Instructions regarding the carriage should be given by an authorized person and must be feasible. They also cannot lead to the splitting of the shipment. If the carrier is transporting shipments from several senders, the execution of instructions relating to one of these shipments cannot cause delays in the delivery of the others – explains Beata Gądek.

The sender is silent – the carrier reacts

What actions should a carrier take when there is no contact with the sender and instructions cannot be obtained?

In such a case, the CMR Convention also provides the answer. According to Article 14(2) of the CMR Convention, if circumstances allow for the carriage to be carried out under conditions differing from those provided for in the consignment note and if the carrier is unable to obtain instructions from the person entitled to dispose of the goods within a sufficiently short time, he should take the measures which seem to him to be in the best interests of the person entitled to dispose of the goods.

– Such a measure could be, for example, unloading the goods in a substitute warehouse – suggests the expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna.

Right to reimbursement of costs

According to Article 16(1) of the CMR Convention, the carrier is entitled to the reimbursement of costs caused by his request for instructions or the execution of such instructions, provided that these costs did not arise from his own fault. The CMR Convention does not specify the deadline by which the person issuing the instructions should compensate for these costs and damages, nor the method of their compensation. There is no doubt that compensation for damages includes, among other things, the profit lost by the carrier as a result of executing the instructions and the inability to provide other services during that time. However, it should be remembered that claiming compensation for lost profit in the event of receiving instructions must be based on evidence, and not merely on the carrier’s assertions.

The CMR Convention does not explicitly specify whether the carrier is entitled to additional freight charges when the consequence of executing the instructions is an extension of the transport route. However, it should be assumed that the carrier may demand from the authorized person not only the coverage of incurred costs but also remuneration that takes into account their profit.

Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna