⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

How long should unclaimed goods be stored, and who pays for the storage?

How long should unclaimed goods be stored, and who pays for the storage?

In the transport industry, it sometimes happens that a consignee refuses to accept goods delivered by a carrier. As a result, the driver is left with a full delivery vehicle and is unable to carry out further transport operations. In such a situation, is the carrier obliged to store the cargo, and if so, who bears the resulting costs?

What are the carrier’s rights in the event of non-acceptance of goods under the CMR Convention?

International transport rules are governed by the CMR Convention. According to Article 15(1) of the Convention, if, upon arrival of the goods at the destination, obstacles to their delivery arise (e.g., the consignee refuses to accept the cargo), the carrier is obliged to request instructions from the sender as the person entitled to dispose of the goods. Article 16 of the CMR Convention grants the carrier two options:

  • unloading the goods at the expense of the entitled person – in such a situation, the carrier assumes custody of the goods, unless they entrust their care to a third party, in which case they are only liable for the choice of the custodian;
  • selling the goods without waiting for the sender’s instructions, but only in situations where this is justified by the nature of the goods or if the sender does not provide contrary instructions within a reasonable time.

The choice of the place to deposit the goods rests with the carrier, but they should choose it in such a way that the cargo is properly secured. A good solution would be to enter into a storage agreement with a company providing warehousing services.

It should also be noted that the rights provided for in Article 16 of the CMR Convention do not become active automatically, but only after the person entitled to dispose of the goods fails to provide instructions in a timely manner or provides instructions that are impossible to execute. Furthermore, the carrier has an obligation to keep the entitled person informed about the steps taken or intended.

How long must the carrier wait for the sender’s instructions?

The CMR Convention uses the general clause of a “reasonable time,” but it does not define what this means. Therefore, it is difficult to answer the question of how long a carrier must store unclaimed goods in an unambiguous way.

In legal doctrine, one can encounter the position that when assessing the time limit, all circumstances occurring in a given case should be taken into account, and local regulations governing transport law can be used as a supplementary reference. For transport carried out on the Polish market, one can refer to Article 58(3) of the Transport Law[1], which provides for the possibility of disposing of a shipment:

  • immediately after the expiry of the deadline for the collection of live animals, dangerous goods, or goods prone to rapid spoilage;
  • in other cases – after 30 days from the deadline for the collection of the shipment, but no earlier than 10 days from the date of notifying the entitled person (sender) of the intention to dispose of the shipment.

It is worth suggesting that for perishable goods and those exposed to damage or requiring very high storage costs, a shorter period should be adopted than, for example, for prefabricated construction elements.

The failure of the consignee to collect the goods immediately does not mean that they lose this right immediately. According to Article 15(2) of the CMR Convention, even if the consignee has previously refused to accept the goods, they may demand their delivery until the carrier receives contrary instructions from the sender. In the case of an immediate refusal to accept, it will be crucial for the carrier whether they receive instructions from the sender first or whether the consignee decides to collect the cargo after all.

Depositphotos 342267154 XL 750

Who pays for the storage of unclaimed goods?

Pursuant to Article 16(2) of the CMR Convention in fine, unclaimed goods unloaded by the carrier are charged with the amounts resulting from the consignment note and all other costs, which will also include any expenses related to their storage.

It should be remembered that in such a situation, the fact of storing the goods must be carefully documented (through a storage agreement or photographic documentation). This provides evidence in case the person entitled to dispose of the goods disagrees with the issued debit note.

It is worth noting that according to Article 16(1) of the CMR Convention, the carrier has the right to demand from the person entitled to dispose of the goods the reimbursement of costs resulting not only from the execution of instructions but also from requesting them. These may include, for example, the costs of sent correspondence, but also lost profit in connection with the inability to carry out subsequent orders.

Storage of unclaimed goods and domestic transport

In the case of domestic transport, the provisions of the Civil Code[2] and the Transport Law will apply. Pursuant to Article 787 of the Civil Code, if the consignee refuses to accept the shipment or if it cannot be delivered for other reasons, the carrier should immediately notify the sender. If the sender does not provide instructions in a timely manner, the carrier should place the shipment in storage or otherwise secure it, notifying the sender and the consignee. Sale is possible only if:

  • the shipment is prone to spoilage;
  • the storage of the shipment requires incurring costs that are not covered.

To secure claims arising from the transport contract and other related fees (e.g., freight, storage, customs duties), the carrier has a statutory right of lien on the shipment.

When requesting instructions from the sender, the carrier should remember to maintain a written form and specify a concrete date in the correspondence by which they expect instructions. This makes it possible to minimize the difficulties associated with storing the cargo, as well as to eliminate uncertainty regarding how long the goods must be secured.

The RPMS Law Firm provides comprehensive legal support for entities in the TSL industry. Our lawyers will help at the stage of negotiating the terms of the transport contract, as well as in court disputes.

[1] https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/isap.nsf/DocDetails.xsp?id=WDU19840530272
[2] https://isap.sejm.gov.pl/isap.nsf/DocDetails.xsp?id=wdu19640160093