
The conclusions of the report, which premiered on September 27 during the 2023 New Mobility Congress (KNM) in Łódź, are optimistic. Clean Transport Zones (CTZ) mean better air for us and future generations, and are associated by respondents with a healthier and calmer life. However, there are reservations regarding the pace and costs of their implementation.
The qualitative research report “Motivations and barriers to establishing clean transport zones in Polish cities” was developed as part of the Clean Transport Zone Laboratory project, funded by the Norway Grants. The key findings of the report were presented by its author – Agata Tkaczyk, Director of Qualitative Research at ARC Rynek i Opinia.
– The report gives a sense of optimism; not a single opinion negating the existence of clean transport zones was voiced. However, there were many questions, doubts, and specific issues that are worth clarifying and resolving – says Agata Tkaczyk.
The author of the report explains that clean transport zones were primarily associated by the interviewees with clean air and its impact on health and bodily functions, but for some, the broader aspect of quality of life in the city was also important.
– Many people imagine that such a zone will improve the conditions in which they live and move around on a daily basis. That it will be calmer, without haste, cleaner, cooler in the summer, and that, just like in Danish or Dutch cities, there will be more space for greenery. These expectations are overestimated because such changes do not happen overnight – explains Agata Tkaczyk.
The task of clean transport zones is to improve air quality in city centers, not to reduce car traffic or increase space for greenery and pedestrians. In the opinion of the report’s author, if expectations for a quick improvement in quality of life are not met, deep disappointment will arise.
– One of the conditions for a CTZ to be introduced in a city for the general benefit is the implementation of changes in the organization of public transport. In other words, the better the transport in the city, the greater the chance that clean transport zones will be met with approval and will be something that residents appreciate – notes Agata Tkaczyk.
The study’s respondents also expressed concerns that the exclusion of older cars from CTZs would lead to transport exclusion for poorer residents. Entrepreneurs also pointed to the increase in costs associated with running local businesses within the zone.
According to Agata Tkaczyk, a change in attitude towards CTZs will require effort, mainly regarding habits and views, and a key task, primarily for local governments, is to educate residents about what is truly necessary for life and what has a negative impact on health and well-being.
– We must realize that we are not the only ones here on this earth. The next generations will come soon, and what will we leave them then? – comments the author of the report.
In her opinion, it should also be explained to residents that the CTZ will not operate without exceptions, so public utility vehicles, people with disabilities, or parents of small children will have the opportunity to use certain amenities.
– The most important thing in the discussion about clean transport zones is to realize the need to make certain concessions, to partially give up one’s own convenience for the sake of the environment, because this will have a positive impact on the quality of life and health of us all – emphasizes Agata Tkaczyk.
The study was conducted in June and July 2023 on 32 people from 8 cities: Katowice, Lublin, Łódź, Poznań, Rzeszów, Sopot, Toruń, and Warsaw – representatives of local government administration, local community leaders, and entrepreneurs.
The “Clean Transport Zone Laboratory” project was created as part of the Bilateral Cooperation Fund of the European Economic Area Financial Mechanism 2014-2021 and the Norwegian Financial Mechanism 2014-2021 under the “Environment, Energy and Climate Change” Program.
The full report is available on the website: https://sctlab.ios.edu.pl/raport-z-badania-jakosciowego/
Source: PAP MediaRoom







