
One of the most difficult situations a carrier can experience is cargo theft. Whether they will be held liable for such an event depends primarily on the accompanying circumstances. Some of these are resolved by transport law, but in disputed cases, the carrier must rely on the court, whose decisions can be controversial.
Cargo theft is a common and growing problem in European transport. Data on this is maintained by the organization TAPA EMEA, which covers Europe, Asia, and the Middle East. In 2021, it recorded just over 6,000 such incidents, and in 2022 – almost 11,000, with about 90% of them occurring on the Old Continent. In the first quarter of 2023, the “leaders” in this regard were Germany – this country accounted for almost one-third of cargo thefts in Europe.
Crimes are usually committed by organized groups interested in easily resalable, high-value goods such as cosmetics, electronic equipment, clothing, or alcohol. Year after year, their strategies become increasingly sophisticated – they use spyware to track routes, use the help of paid informants, and even impersonate transport companies. Their actions are often facilitated by the carriers themselves, who do not use necessary security measures and leave vehicles in unguarded places during stops.
Cargo theft in light of regulations
The basic principle is that from the moment the goods are received from the sender, the carrier (as well as any other person performing transport on their behalf) has a duty of care over the goods. This means that if a theft occurs during this time, the recipient or sender may claim compensation from the carrier.
– According to the CMR Convention, in order to be released from this liability, the carrier will have to demonstrate that there were circumstances that they could not avoid and the consequences of which they could not prevent. In the case of domestic transport, they will have to prove that the loss of the shipment occurred due to reasons on the part of the sender or recipient, not caused by the carrier’s fault, resulting from the nature of the goods, or due to force majeure – says Beata Gądek, legal counsel at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Force majeure and cargo theft
It should be remembered that for an event to be called force majeure, it must be sudden and unavoidable. A carrier can only invoke force majeure in exceptional circumstances. Whether cargo theft will meet the criteria of force majeure will be decided by the adjudicating court after analyzing the specific case. This assessment will include circumstances such as the route, the organization of transport, or the use of appropriate security measures. The organization of transport should also take into account the specific requirements of the goods, including, for example, their value.
– It is difficult to clearly indicate which situations will have the characteristics of force majeure. The Supreme Court in its resolution of December 13, 2007, III CZP 100/07, OSNC 2008/12, item 139, stated, for example, that the loss of a shipment as a result of robbery combined with stopping a truck under the guise of a police road check is not the result of force majeure – explains the legal counsel at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Will the carrier be liable for cargo theft at a parking lot?
Drivers’ working hours are strictly defined by law and assume that a driver in road transport is entitled to a break during the workday, a daily rest period, and a weekly rest period. The first of these depends on the daily working time and can be 30 or 45 minutes after 6 hours of work. The daily rest period is at least 11 hours of uninterrupted rest. Drivers usually spend these breaks in specially designated parking lots.
What is the carrier’s liability if the goods are stolen during a break at a parking lot?
– In such a situation, a circumstance that the court will assess is the fact of leaving the vehicle in a guarded or unguarded parking lot. Leaving a vehicle in an unguarded parking lot generally makes it impossible to effectively release the carrier from liability. Nor will a carrier avoid it if, even though they stopped at a guarded parking lot, they would not have had to take a break if they had properly organized the transport. The carrier also cannot invoke the applicable driver working time standards or the assumed transport time to justify stopping in an unsafe place. The lack of precise information about the nature of the transported goods also cannot be a reason to release the carrier from liability for cargo theft – says Beata Gądek from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Theft committed by a subcontractor carrier
What will the carrier’s liability look like when the theft is committed by a driver performing transport on their behalf? In jurisprudence, there is no doubt that cargo theft by a subcontractor carrier is not a circumstance that releases the carrier from liability. Exercising care over the shipment and delivering it to its destination are essential obligations arising from the contract of carriage. At the same time, for the assessment of the carrier’s liability, it does not matter whether the person the carrier used acted in accordance with their instructions.
In general, both in the case of international and domestic transport, the jurisprudence presents positions that strictly evaluate the behavior of carriers. For example, the Hoge Raad der Nederlanden in its judgment of April 24, 2009, ETL 2009, pp. 707–713, pointed to the impossibility of releasing the carrier from liability under Article 17(2) of the CMR in the case of theft of theft-prone shipments committed by people dressed as police officers, in a situation where the carrier entrusted the transport to a single driver without prior experience on the route, outside of peak traffic times, and without an escort.1
Both the CMR Convention, which will apply in international transport, and the Transport Law, which is the basis for resolving disputes in domestic transport, allow the carrier to be released from liability for damage. In practice, however, the circumstances surrounding the theft play a key role. A seemingly obvious case may turn out to be the beginning of a long and complicated court process.
1 K. Wesołowski [in:] D. Ambrożuk, D. Dąbrowski, K. Wesołowski, Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR). Commentary, Warsaw 2015, Annex Art. 17.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna







