Civil lawsuits for debt recovery can drag on for years, as there is no legal provision limiting their duration. During this time, the debtor’s financial situation may deteriorate, making it difficult to recover money even after a favorable judgment. To avoid this situation, a creditor can file an application for securing a claim. What is worth knowing about this?
Securing a claim means seizing a portion of the debtor’s assets equal to the amount owed to the creditor, or another asset that is the subject of the dispute. Most often, this refers to funds in a bank account, but the law provides for many other types of security. Thanks to this, the creditor does not have to worry about the debtor’s insolvency if they win, because the funds to pay off the debt have been ensured. Depending on the subject of the dispute, both monetary and non-monetary claims are subject to security.
An application supported by evidence
An application for security can be filed by any party or participant in the proceedings. The person filing such an application should substantiate their claim and indicate their legal interest in granting it. The purpose of the application is to demonstrate that the lack of security will prevent or seriously hinder the execution of the judgment that will be issued in the case.
– In practice, this means that the creditor should present evidence in court confirming the existence of the claim, for example, a VAT invoice, a contract, or a settlement – explains Beata Gądek, legal advisor at TC Kancelaria Prawna, and adds: – They must also indicate the reason why, in their opinion, such security should be granted, for example, by presenting circumstances confirming the debtor’s attempt to deplete their assets.
Creditors pursuing claims in an amount lower than 75,000 PLN arising from a commercial transaction that has not yet been settled or for which at least three months have passed since the payment deadline do not have to additionally substantiate their legal interest in granting security. This simplified path to securing a claim is an excellent solution when pursuing a claim resulting, for example, from an unpaid VAT invoice.
Elements of the security application
An application for security should meet the requirements of a pleading. Therefore, it must contain the designation of the court to which it is addressed, the names or titles of the parties, their legal representatives and attorneys, the designation of the type of document, and the subject matter, i.e., a description of the object of the application or statement. In cases where it is necessary for a decision on the application or statement, it is also necessary to indicate the facts on which the party bases their application or statement and to indicate evidence to prove each of these facts.
The application must also include the signature of the party or their legal representative or attorney and a list of attachments. Additionally, the document should be supplemented with an indication of the method of security, and in cases involving monetary claims, also an indication of the security sum, and substantiation of the circumstances justifying the application, i.e., a description of the circumstances in which the debt arose. The court decides on granting security by way of a court order.
Costs of security proceedings
The court fee for filing an application for security is low – it is 100 PLN. It is not necessary if the application was included in the statement of claim or in the application initiating non-litigious proceedings. The court order granting security is submitted, along with the application and the appropriate fee of 300 PLN, to a court bailiff.
– On this basis, the bailiff can execute the security on the debtor’s bank account. If the funds are effectively seized, the court bailiff collects a proportional fee from the creditor in the amount of 10% of the value of the property covered by the security, minus the aforementioned 300 PLN fee – explains Beata Gądek from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
In the course of civil proceedings, the creditor may also file an application for the court to award the costs of the security proceedings from the debtor.
Securing monetary claims
Seizing the debtor’s assets from their bank accounts is the most obvious way to secure monetary claims, although not the only one. The regulations provide for several methods, the catalog of which can be found in Article 747 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Seizure of movable property – however, seized movable property cannot be placed under the creditor’s custody; seized money is deposited into the Ministry of Finance’s deposit account, and seized securities are deposited by the court in a bank. Seizing movable property has the effect that even further disposal of it will not affect the course of the proceedings, because enforcement proceedings from the seized movable property can be conducted even against the purchaser.
- Seizure of remuneration for work – this occurs by notifying the debtor of the prohibition on collecting a specific part of their remuneration for work, and their employer is summoned not to pay the seized part of the remuneration to the debtor.
- Seizure of receivables from a bank account or other receivables or other property rights – this is the most popular and simplest way to secure monetary claims. In the application for security, one does not even have to indicate the debtor’s bank account; in such a situation, the bailiff will seize the receivable on any of the debtor’s bank accounts. As for other receivables or property rights, it must be ensured that a specific receivable or property right is indicated in the order granting security.
- Encumbering the debtor’s real estate with a compulsory mortgage – based on the mortgage, the creditor obtains the right to seek satisfaction from its subject regardless of whose ownership it becomes.
- Establishing a prohibition on selling or encumbering real estate – a prohibition on selling or encumbering real estate can be established as part of the security if the real estate does not have a land and mortgage register.
- Encumbering a ship or a ship under construction with a maritime mortgage – sea-going ships are formally movable property, but in terms of security and enforcement, the provisions on real estate apply to them. Therefore, it is also possible to establish a mortgage on sea-going ships and even sea-going ships under construction.
- Establishing a prohibition on selling a cooperative ownership right to premises – a legal act performed contrary to the prohibition on selling a cooperative ownership right to premises is invalid, thus the creditor’s claim will remain secured.
- Establishing compulsory management over the debtor’s enterprise or farm, or an establishment that is part of the enterprise or its part, or part of the debtor’s farm – in this case, the manager takes over the rights and obligations from the debtor regarding the managed enterprise or farm; it is assumed that this substitution is absolute, so it completely excludes the possibility of the debtor taking any actions. The manager has the right to collect all benefits instead of the debtor, monetize them within the limits of ordinary management, and conduct matters that prove necessary in the performance of management.
Can every monetary claim be secured?
It is worth remembering that securing monetary claims will not be possible if the State Treasury is a party to the dispute, which is regulated by Article 749 of the Code of Civil Procedure. Likewise, the security of monetary claims cannot cover items, receivables, and rights from which enforcement is excluded. These include, for example, household items necessary for the debtor and their household members, such as a washing machine, vacuum cleaner, oven, clothing items, and the like. The full list is covered by Articles 829 – 837 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
– If the methods specified above are not sufficient and it is not possible to secure the claim according to them, there is still one loophole – advises the lawyer from TC Kancelaria Prawna, Mateusz Pernak – We are talking about items that, due to their properties, are subject to rapid spoilage. As a rule, this will be food, plants, and the like. When the debtor has no other assets that could secure the creditor’s claim, it is possible to secure the claim through the immediate sale of items subject to rapid spoilage.
The sale is carried out by the bailiff at the court’s order, and the amount obtained from such a transaction is deposited into the Ministry of Finance’s deposit account.
Non-monetary claims
The subject of a claim will not always be money. As examples of such claims, Mateusz Pernak mentions, among others, a claim for the release of real estate or a ship, for the performance of certain actions, or for refraining from an action, and many others:
– In such cases, it is also possible to secure the claim, which the court grants in a manner it deems appropriate according to the circumstances, not excluding the methods provided for securing monetary claims. However, the creditor should include the method in which the claim is to be secured in the application for security – says the expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Fortunately, the regulations also provide examples of how to secure non-monetary claims, which indicate that the court may:
- Regulate the rights and obligations of the parties or participants in the proceedings for the duration of the proceedings;
- Establish a prohibition on selling items or rights covered by the proceedings;
- Suspend enforcement proceedings or other proceedings aimed at executing the judgment;
- Regulate the manner of providing care for minor children and contact with the child;
- Order the entry of an appropriate warning in the land and mortgage register or in the relevant register.
We should consider that the above list, despite being in the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure, is an exemplary list. This results from the wording used by the legislator “in particular, the court may”.
The finale of court proceedings with claim security
If the court issues a judgment favorable to the creditor, the security of the claim is not enforced automatically. From the moment the judgment is issued, the debtor has two weeks to pay the debt, and during the same period, they also have the right to file an objection or an appeal. If they do neither of these things, the judgment becomes final, which allows the case to be referred to a bailiff. Thanks to the fact that the claim has been secured, the enforcement will be primarily effective, but also much shorter than in standard proceedings.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna







