What traps might await carriers in contracts?

What traps might await carriers in contracts?

In an industry as dynamic as the TSL sector, it is easy to be inattentive when reading contracts. Negligence can have serious consequences if the principal shows great “creativity” regarding contractual penalties. An expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna, Maurycy Kieruj, advises on what to keep in mind to avoid falling into the trap of contractual penalties and to avoid having to assert your rights in court.

Reading contracts before signing is a matter of course in any situation, but the devil is in the details. Not all provisions sound absurd or exceptionally unfavorable, yet they may still be inconsistent with transport law and expose the carrier to loss. In a potential dispute, however, such inconsistency must be proven, and there is no obligation to conclude transport contracts in writing. Nevertheless, a carrier or freight forwarder should strive for this, keeping their own interests in mind.

– In the event of a dispute, it is the contract of carriage, which contains the terms of the order’s execution, that will be the primary evidence in court. To avoid these consequences, you must carefully read its content before accepting the order – the expert advises.

Keep this in mind when reading a contract of carriage

The fundamental issue is establishing clear and unambiguous requirements regarding the transport – including delivery time, type and quantity of goods transported, and general transport conditions. Regarding contractual penalties, it is crucial to pay attention to the clauses, especially their amount. The imposed penalty should be proportionate to the value of the cargo and the potential losses incurred in connection with late delivery, loss, or damage to the goods. This is a common trick used by principals.

Equally important are the circumstances under which a penalty may be imposed. For this reason, it is good to include a provision in the contract regarding force majeure events that may affect the proper execution of the order. This refers to difficult weather conditions, traffic delays, or vehicle breakdowns that could not have been foreseen. This will help avoid a situation where the carrier is forced to pay a high contractual penalty due to circumstances beyond their control.

– Accepting orders with little time buffer between unloading at one location and loading at another, while tempting from a business perspective, should give way to a rational consideration of an appropriate buffer for unforeseen situations – suggests Maurycy Kieruj.

After concluding the contract, it is also worth tracking the progress of its execution and staying in constant contact with the contractor or driver. This helps avoid situations where the contractor is unable to deliver the goods on time.

“Fine print” and the validity of contractual penalties

The way a penalty is described in the contract matters, but not necessarily in relation to the font size. Its content should be clearly and explicitly defined in the contract so that the parties know exactly what triggers its imposition. The use of fine print may suggest an attempt to hide the penalty from the contractor, but as such, it does not make the penalty ineffective. The key is its provisions, which must be fully understandable and clear in their meaning.

– A signature under a contract implies consent, but if a contractual penalty was presented in an insufficiently legible manner or with the intent to mislead the other party, its validity can be challenged – explains Maurycy Kieruj and adds – In this situation, the contractual penalty may be considered grossly disproportionate to the damage it was intended to prevent, and thus inconsistent with the principles of social coexistence.

A contractual penalty written in fine print can therefore be effective if it has been clearly and explicitly defined in the contract and the parties have been informed of it and have consented to it. The mere fact that provisions are expressed in fine print does not provide grounds for challenging the validity of an imposed penalty.

Depositphotos 357618372 XL 750x500

Can the amount of a contractual penalty be reduced?

Grossly high contractual penalties are sometimes a reason for withdrawing from a contract of carriage, but their amount can be influenced both before accepting the order and after its execution. From the contractor’s point of view, the best approach is to reduce the penalty during the contract negotiation stage. Arguments can include the value of the cargo or legal provisions that limit the amount of penalties. The principal may, but does not have to, make changes – if the carrier decides to carry out the transport anyway, they should be aware that in case of problems, the matter may end up in court. In such a situation, it is worth consulting a legal advisor in advance, who will assess the chances of challenging the validity of the penalty if it is imposed.

In some contracts, one may encounter attempts to impose multiple penalties for the same offense. In the following case, which was submitted to TC Kancelaria Prawna, the court allowed only a 200 euro fee per day of loading delay:

“Untimely provision of the means of transport for loading or unloading or failure to undertake the order authorizes the Principal to cancel the order and charge a contractual penalty in the following amount: 10% of the freight amount for untimely provision of the vehicle for reasons attributable to the carrier, 100% of the freight amount and the obligation to reimburse the costs of providing a replacement means of transport and any other costs incurred for the cancellation of the order by the carrier on the day of or the day before loading, 200 euros for each day of delay in loading/unloading the goods.”

Regulations allow for the reduction of the penalty amount or declaring it ineffective if it is inconsistent with the contract. This refers to a situation where a contractual penalty is introduced in an illegible or misleading manner, or its imposition has no rational basis and is inconsistent with the principles of social coexistence. An example of a penalty in the absurd category, which experts from TC Kancelaria Prawna have encountered, is:

“The Contractor also undertakes to ensure that the driver (as a representative of the Principal before clients) behaves politely and professionally both at the loading and unloading sites and in the immediate vicinity of these places. Violation of the obligations indicated in this point authorizes the Principal to impose a contractual penalty on the Contractor in the amount of the agreed freight.”

Polite behavior of a driver is difficult to classify as an additional obligation to a contract of carriage. Furthermore, it is a very subjective circumstance, hence such a contractual penalty should be considered ineffective. Another basis for challenging a penalty is phrasing it in a way that assumes inequality between the parties:

“The lack of a written refusal to accept the order by the Contractor (carrier) within half an hour of receiving it and the lack of objections by the Contractor (carrier) regarding the content of the order terms and all the above provisions within half an hour of receiving it automatically means the voluntary and conscious conclusion of a contract of carriage based on this order and all its provisions.”

This provision is ineffective if the potential carrier and the counterparty do not have ongoing business relations. The primary argument against this contractual provision is the unequal treatment of the parties.

Regardless of the grounds for reducing a penalty, effectiveness in this regard will be increased by quick action and professional support, advises TC Kancelaria Prawna expert Maurycy Kieruj:

– Consultation with a legal advisor will help us determine whether the penalty can be avoided or reduced and what steps are necessary to implement these actions. This principle also works the other way around – it is worth seeking advice even before signing the contract if its provisions, especially regarding penalties, raise doubts.

Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna