⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

Termination of an employment contract by the employer. How to do it legally?

Termination of an employment contract by the employer. How to do it legally?

Termination of an employment contract by the employer is one of the ways to end an employment relationship. Although it is a frequently used measure that does not require any special procedure, it still raises many doubts. Questions arise primarily from employers who are unsure how to legally and properly terminate an employee’s contract. Indeed, violating regulations in this matter can lead to numerous negative legal consequences for the employer. What should they know before taking such a step?

A standard measure for terminating an employment contract

First of all, termination of an employment contract by the employer is a standard, legal measure for ending an employment contract. According to the Act of June 26, 1974, the Labor Code (consolidated text: Journal of Laws of 2022, item 1510, as amended; hereinafter: “Labor Code”), an employment contract can be terminated by:

  • termination by mutual agreement;
  • termination by a statement of one of the parties with a notice period;
  • termination by a statement of one of the parties without a notice period;
  • termination upon the expiry of the time for which the contract was concluded.

In this article, we will focus on termination of an employment contract by the employer. This type of termination can follow different courses depending on the circumstances and the content of the contract itself.

What is the significance of employment contract notice periods?

The notice period for a probationary contract, which is also an employment contract, will be much shorter than in the case of other types of contracts. It amounts to:

  • 3 working days if the probationary period does not exceed 2 weeks;
  • 1 week if the probationary period is longer than 2 weeks;
  • 2 weeks if the probationary period is 3 months.

In turn, the notice periods for a fixed-term employment contract by the employer and termination of an indefinite employment contract by the employer are the same. Their duration will depend on the employee’s length of service, namely:

  • 2 weeks if the employee has been employed for less than 6 months;
  • 1 month if the employee has been employed for at least 6 months;
  • 3 months if the employee has been employed for at least 3 years.

It should be noted that changes to the Labor Code are planned. The amendment is intended to ensure that the requirement to provide a justification for terminating an employment relationship will not apply only to indefinite employment contracts, but also to fixed-term contracts.

The draft amendment also includes the obligation for trade union consultation in situations where there is an intention to terminate a fixed-term contract with an employee. Changes in labor law are the result of two EU directives: 2019/1152 (transparency directive) and 2019/1158 (work-life balance directive).

Importantly, in cases where the reason for the employer’s termination of an indefinite or fixed-term employment contract is the declaration of bankruptcy or liquidation of the employer, or other reasons unrelated to the employees, the employer may—but is not required to—shorten the three-month notice period to a maximum of 1 month in order to terminate the contract earlier. However, it must be remembered that in such a case, the employee is entitled to compensation in the amount of remuneration for the remainder of the notice period.

Exempting an employee from the obligation to perform work during the notice period

Sometimes, for various reasons, e.g., hiring a new employee earlier, the employer may want to release the employee from the obligation to perform work until the end of the notice period. Such a move by the employer is fully permitted and optional; however, the employee still retains the right to remuneration for the period of such exemption.

Can an employee request days off to look for a job?

An employee has the right to submit a request for two (during a two-week and one-month notice period) or three (during a three-month notice period) days off to look for a new job. The employer is obliged to grant them, and the employee still retains the right to remuneration for these days.

What are the limitations on the employer’s ability to terminate a contract?

It is not always possible for an employer to terminate an employment contract. First, they cannot do so to an employee who is no more than four years away from reaching retirement age—provided that the period of employment gives them the possibility of obtaining the right to a pension upon reaching that age. This protection is limited only if the employee has the right to a disability pension due to total incapacity for work.

In addition, the employer cannot terminate an employment contract during the employee’s leave. They also do not have the right to do so during any other justified absence of the employee from the workplace, if the period entitling to termination without notice has not yet expired.

When an employee is employed under an indefinite employment contract and is simultaneously represented by a company trade union organization, the employer must inform the trade union organization—in writing—of the intention to terminate the contract. They must justify the need to terminate the contract. If the company trade union organization, after considering the information received, decides that the termination would be unjustified, it may submit reasoned objections to the employer (also in writing) within 5 days of receiving the notification.

Note: all the above-mentioned limitations do not apply in the case of liquidation of the enterprise or declaration of bankruptcy by the employer.

What about the employee’s outstanding leave in the case of contract termination?

According to Article 167 § 1 of the Labor Code, during the notice period of an employment contract (including one terminated by the employer), the employee is obliged to use their entitled leave if the employer grants it during this period. As a result, if the employer obliges the employee to do so, they must use the outstanding annual leave. Such a mechanism is often used for cost-saving purposes, as it means the employer does not have to pay the employee an equivalent.

It must be emphasized that jurisprudence has indicated for years that if the employer does not draw up a leave plan, the date of sending the employee on leave should be agreed upon jointly (e.g., Supreme Court judgment of May 13, 1998, file no. I PKN 99/98). At the same time, the employer does not have the right to order employees to use leave at a specific time. Such a possibility arises only when the employee is settling outstanding leave during the notice period.

1977803

Form of termination of an employment contract by the employer

According to Article 30 § 3 of the Labor Code, termination of an employment contract should always be in writing. However, despite the existence of this provision, the act does not indicate anywhere a penalty of invalidity in the event of failure to comply with the written form. It can therefore be concluded that failure to maintain the written form in the case of termination of an employment contract by the employer or employee is not unequivocally considered an invalid act.

Of course, it is still worth acting in accordance with the regulations. The employer should ensure that the form of contract termination by the employer (and employee) is written and bears a handwritten signature.

Failure by the employer to comply with this form, i.e., e.g., oral termination, is still effective, but as defective, it gives the employee the opportunity to pursue employee claims and file an appeal to the labor court.

What can be the reasons for contract termination by the employer?

In the case of termination of an indefinite employment contract by the employer, the exact reason for termination must always be provided. We do not have to indicate such a reason in the case of termination of an employment contract concluded for a probationary period or a fixed term. However, the reason must also be indicated when, based on an indefinite employment contract, the employee’s terms of remuneration and work are being terminated (not the contract itself).

Importantly, in the event of a potential dispute before the labor court, the employer cannot rely on a different reason than the one indicated in the termination notice (!). That is why it is so important to provide every valid reason for termination and to argue it appropriately.

Although it seems simple and obvious, many employers make many mistakes in this matter, which later result in huge problems—which we see especially in labor court rulings.

Most common mistakes made by employers when terminating an employment contract

  • Failure to indicate a reason or failure to indicate it in writing

As we noted in the previous paragraph, providing a reason is mandatory in the case of termination of an indefinite employment contract by the employer. Failure to indicate it increases the risk of the employer’s failure during a potential dispute before the labor court. On the other hand, termination of a fixed-term contract by the employer without providing a reason is fully possible and permissible.

Besides, it is very difficult to defend all kinds of terminations submitted in a form other than the one mentioned in the act, i.e., written.

  • Failure to indicate all valid reasons

After issuing a termination notice for an indefinite employment contract, the employer cannot supplement the termination with additional reasons. This will not be possible even if court proceedings have not yet been initiated.

Therefore, the last moment to realistically define the scope of potential future evidentiary proceedings before the labor court is the moment of handing over the contract termination by the employer. This moment is very important and should be carefully thought out. Employers often make the mistake of treating the moment of contract termination without much attention and reflection. Only later, when the employee files a lawsuit, do they devote their time and attention to developing appropriate reasons for termination. Unfortunately, it is then too late, which results in frequent losses for employers in court disputes.

  • Indicating untrue reasons

Court proceedings before the labor court are quite specific. Although the employer is the defendant in such a process, they must appropriately argue and prove all the reasons behind the issued employment contract termination. Despite the fact that the proceedings are initiated by the employee, the burden of proof rests here on the employer. As a result, it is the employee, not the employer, who benefits here from the so-called presumption of innocence.

Before an employer issues an employment contract termination to an employee, they should secure appropriate evidence that they will be able to present in the event of a potential court trial. Among the standard, untrue reasons are, for example:

  • providing information about the liquidation of a department, although only its name has changed;
  • lack of qualification improvement by the employee, when there was no such need or opportunity until now;
  • information about the liquidation of a position, while the position is maintained.
  • Providing overly general reasons for termination

As can be seen, it is mandatory in the case of termination of an indefinite employment contract by the employer to provide the reasons for this termination. This is applied not only to satisfy the curiosity of the person being dismissed. It also serves to allow the employee to decide whether their dismissal occurred for valid reasons or whether it should be analyzed by the labor court.

Therefore, the employer must avoid indicating the reasons for contract termination too generally. Reasons such as “insufficient employee commitment,” “lack of due diligence in performing tasks entrusted by the employer,” or “failure to meet the employer’s expectations” without any broader justification will likely contribute to the employer losing the case.

Ideal practice, however, does not mean that we should overdo it in the other direction. Describing in detail every bad behavior and action that the employee performed poorly or which, despite the obligation, they did not complete in a given period of time is also not a good idea. It is also not recommended to present specific evidence to confirm the information mentioned in the termination. It is worth securing such evidence appropriately so that it can be presented in the event of a potential court dispute before the labor court, but indicating it directly in the termination gives the employee more room to undermine it.

Therefore, the termination statement must be informational in nature. However, the reasons provided should only be slightly detailed and deepened, e.g., this can be done in the following way: “failure to meet the requirements set by the employer by achieving the lowest results in the team and significantly deviating from the previously presented assumptions in the 2022 tax year.”

  • Indicating outdated reasons

Another common mistake on the part of employers is indicating outdated reasons for contract termination in the termination document. Although neither the act nor the applicable jurisprudence and doctrine explicitly state that there is a specific date for the occurrence and end of the reason that the employer can rely on, taking into account the judgments issued by courts, it is better to be careful not to provide extremely outdated reasons. As “extremely outdated,” one can indicate, for example, reasons that are more than a dozen months old.

Then it may turn out that the labor court will consider the reason outdated. Among such reasons are, for example:

  • criminal proceedings pending against the employee that were concluded a long time ago;
  • relying on the employee’s lack of qualifications in a situation where they were recently sent to training and completed it.

What and how many reasons must the employer indicate in the termination of an indefinite employment contract?

The law does not indicate the concept of a closed catalog of reasons that an employer can indicate to terminate an employment contract with an employee. There is also no specific number of reasons that is optimal in such a situation. Neither doctrine, nor regulations, nor jurisprudence indicate this.

Among the most frequently cited general reasons by employers (which they should simultaneously properly justify and deepen) are:

  • liquidation of the employee’s position,
  • loss of trust,
  • failure to achieve the plans set by the employer regarding the employee’s work,
  • unjustified criticism of the employer,
  • the employee committing unauthorized and illegal competitive activities,
  • too frequent absences of the employee and the associated costs for the employer.

What about the number of reasons provided in the termination? It must be at least one reason (justifying the validity of the termination, as jurisprudence says), but there can also be many reasons listed by the employer.

It must be noted that providing a very large number of reasons can significantly prolong the duration of the court dispute. This will be the result of the court having to address a huge number of arguments and the employer attempting to prove the truth of each of them. Of course, this will also contribute to increasing the costs of conducting the proceedings, which will be burdensome both for the party filing the lawsuit—the employee, and (or rather primarily) for the defendant—the employer.

Furthermore, the Supreme Court judgment of April 14, 2015, file no. II PK 140/14, clearly indicates that when an employer provides a larger number of reasons, although they do not have to properly prove and justify all of them for the employment contract termination to be considered justified, the true reasons (i.e., those properly justified) must remain “in significant proportion” to the untrue (or undocumented) reasons. If this is not the case, according to the aforementioned court, such termination will be challenged and considered unjustified—even despite the finding of the validity of one or several reasons.

Unfortunately, there is no explanation for the phrase “in significant proportion” used by the Supreme Court. For this reason, it is better to be cautious about the number of reasons presented in the employment contract termination and choose only those that will be possible to defend later.

Depositphotos 534646250 XL

For what reasons can an employer dismiss an employee?

Termination of an employment contract by the employer is a standard measure for ending an employment contract. It is not associated with any extraordinary procedure, which we deal with in the case of disciplinary dismissal. The reason provided by the employer in the employment contract termination does not have to be extraordinary, exceptional, or significant. As a result, it can stem, for example, from a desire to improve the general functioning and situation of the enterprise.

However, it must be pointed out that as an exception to this rule, the Act on Group Dismissals functions. It does not give the employer full freedom in re-educating employment. Instead, it orders that objective and fair criteria be taken into account, such as:

  • qualifications;
  • education;
  • length of service;
  • employment history;

In group dismissals, the employer must still adhere to the principle of non-discrimination.

Importantly, despite specific objections to the employee, they do not have to call them to improve and change their behavior or discipline them in any way beforehand. It can therefore be concluded that termination of an employment contract by the employer can be the only and first measure in which the employee will be informed that they do not meet certain assumptions of the employer.

However, such a situation happens rarely and does not constitute a model situation. Modern management concepts use instruments that give employees ongoing feedback on the quality of the work they perform. Formally, however, the employer does not have to tell the employee about the reasons for their dissatisfaction with their work beforehand. They can express it only at the moment of dismissing the employee.

It must also be emphasized that the employer can terminate an employment contract with an employee even when the reasons indicated in the termination are not the employee’s fault. This will be, for example, a situation in which the employer plans to change the form of activity or reduce its scale.

However, on the other hand, the employer still does not have the right to dismiss an employee for extremely trivial reasons. A one-time lateness or a minor mistake without consequences for the employer—are certainly not sufficient reasons for the court that would justify dismissing a specific employee from their position.

Much depends, however, on the situation, the scope of duties, and the nature of the work—and thus individual conditions. After all, it may be, for example, that it is precisely one minor mistake or lateness that turns out to be catastrophic in its effects and causes many negative, serious consequences for the employer.

When should an employee receive severance pay?

Although the Labor Code does not include an obligation for the employer to issue severance pay to dismissed employees (except for retirement and death severance pay), such severance pay may be due to employees in exceptional cases. This is dealt with by the Act of March 13, 2003, on special rules for terminating employment relationships with employees for reasons not related to employees (consolidated text: Journal of Laws of 2018, item 1969, as amended).

Such cases mainly include the situation in which an employer employing at least 20 employees at once, for reasons not related to employees, dismisses by way of termination or by mutual agreement within a period not exceeding 30 days a minimum of:

  • 10 employees, when the employer employs fewer than 100 employees;
  • 10% of employees, when the employer employs at least 100, but fewer than 300 employees;
  • 30 employees, when the employer employs at least 300 or more employees.

Furthermore, severance pay is due when the employer employs at least 20 employees and terminates employment relationships for reasons not related to employees.

In the above-mentioned situations, the dismissal must concern at least 5 employees, and temporary employees and those performing work on a basis other than an employment relationship are not included in determining the number of employed persons.

In the Act on Group Dismissals, Article 10, paragraph 4, also provides for the obligation to pay a compensatory allowance to employees for whom termination of work and pay conditions has been made, and this circumstance causes a reduction in remuneration. This allowance is paid for a period not exceeding 6 months. The amount of the compensatory allowance is the difference between the remuneration preceding the change in employment conditions and the conditions after this change.

Employer’s actions after the termination of the employment relationship

After every termination or expiry of an employment relationship, the employer is obliged to issue an employment certificate to the employee. They do this on the day the employment relationship ends, if they do not plan to enter into another employment relationship with them within 7 days from the date of termination of the previous employment relationship.

In the act, however, we will find (often used by employers) a possibility regarding situations in which, for so-called objective reasons, the employer cannot hand this document to the employee on the day the employment relationship ends. Then they must send it to the employee by traditional mail within 7 days from the date of termination of this relationship.

Besides the employment certificate, the employer, after the termination or expiry of the employment relationship, must also: issue in paper or electronic form information about the storage period of employee documentation; the possibility of its collection by the employee until the end of the calendar month after the storage period expires; and also about the destruction of employee documentation if it is not collected within the indicated time.