Is greater state trust in entrepreneurs needed?

The state creates the legal environment in which companies operate. It is responsible for the tax system and the transparency of the rules for conducting economic activity. However, the vast majority of companies rate the conditions for doing business in Poland negatively. Is greater state trust in entrepreneurs needed? Commentary provided by Dr. Anna Czarczyńska – lecturer at Kozminski University. Head of the Manager Competence Academy and the ALK Center for Sustainable Development.

 Anna CzarczyńskaThe small and medium-sized enterprise sector is one of the most sensitive elements of the national economy to disruptions. At the same time, it is also a stabilizer and shock absorber for economic fluctuations in the business cycle. In the last few years, we have dealt with exceptional economic volatility caused by external shocks such as the pandemic or war. Absorbing the resulting changes is impossible without a flexible and innovative SME sector. The role of the state, however, should consist mainly of reducing the effects of rapid global changes: that is, maintaining demand during the pandemic through direct transfers, leveling the playing field in access to raw materials in a situation of energy crisis, and above all – not interfering with market and adaptive mechanisms in their operation.

The state creates the legal environment in which companies operate. It is responsible for the tax system and the transparency of the rules for conducting economic activity. However, as the latest Polish Entrepreneurship Survey and the resulting InFakt Index for 2022 at the level of -19.3 points show, the vast majority of companies rate the conditions for doing business in Poland negatively.

Lack of trust in the state

For “consolation,” it can be added that this assessment has been very negative for years. In the last year, due to the introduced tax changes, it deteriorated particularly drastically among micro-firms, while at the same time improving in the eyes of small entities. It is significant that as many as 69% of all surveyed enterprises considered that the legal situation had worsened, and no one rated the changes as definitely good. What is worrying, therefore, is not so much the instability of the economic situation itself in the face of recent disruptions in the global economy, but the general trend. It deprives small entities of environmental stability, further increasing the uncertainty caused by the market situation. Moreover, forecasts regarding subsequent potential actions of the authorities are definitely negative. As many as 80% of respondents assess them as potentially worsening the business situation even further. This testifies to a total lack of business trust in the state and the treatment of state institutions as oppressive. A micro and small company means micro and small, limited human resources, which make it difficult to keep track of changes in regulations on an ongoing basis. The respondents identified the lack of legal stability and formalities and burdens such as ZUS contributions, regulations, taxes, etc., as the main systemic flaws. Moreover, regulations introduced such as the Polish Deal are considered unfair by 80% of respondents.

Non-uniform financial situation

It is assumed that a company’s success is the result of several factors: its growth and development, as well as its competitive position and expansion plans, while maintaining financial balance and a positive social impact. In the opinion of 45% of respondents, the financial condition of their enterprises compared to last year is good or rather good. However, at the same time, 46% rate it as worse than in the previous year. The predictions of almost half of the entrepreneurs regarding the current year are negative.

As you can see, there is no uniform trend. Some companies used the financial cushion from the pandemic era last year, while others felt a clear drop in turnover, which can be seen, for example, in the PMI index. For several months, it has been below 50 points for Poland, which means a decline in activity in the manufacturing sector.

The most valuable human capital

It is clear that the main capital of micro and small companies is human capital. Committed employees and good quality accounting services (which are outsourced by an average of 75% of respondents) are mentioned as the primary value for the enterprise. 84% of respondents were affected by the pandemic, which limited business growth opportunities and caused a decline in investment. In some companies, it also led to an increase in wages, most likely in connection with the growing number of tasks and increased employee productivity. Everywhere, however, it brought the need for cost reduction. Enterprises also noted the impact of the war on their operations, especially in sectors such as trade, transport, and logistics. However, inflation had the strongest consequences for them in the last year.

In Poland, in February, producer price inflation was at a very high level – 26.7%. Companies declare raising the prices of offered products and services by an average of 18%, while still maintaining competitiveness. At the same time, as many as 62% of the surveyed entities took actions to ensure business continuity, such as looking for new markets, saving energy and costs, and – unfortunately – limiting investments.

An entrepreneur is predisposed to implementing innovative solutions, improving the market offer, taking risks, or being proactive. The success of the Schumpeterian “small is beautiful” is cooperation based on participation, commitment, and activity. It is no wonder, then, that despite the difficulties, the level of entrepreneur satisfaction exceeds 60%, and its basis is independence and a sense of influence. The expectations of the smallest entities on the market are very simple, to quote one of the respondents: for the entrepreneur to be treated like a human being, not like a thief. Fewer inspections, more trust. Just that.