Is your contractor not paying? Learn about the pros and cons of factoring

Is your contractor not paying? Learn about the pros and cons of factoring

The current economic crisis makes maintaining financial liquidity in a company difficult. This is confirmed by, among others, the results of annual studies conducted by the Economic Information Bureau, according to which 70% of companies experience payment bottlenecks lasting over 60 days in their operations. Problems with obtaining payment for delivered goods or services rendered can have a negative impact on a company’s financial situation. Apart from debt collection, is there another method to protect ourselves against non-payment from a contractor?

What is factoring?
One of the solutions that supports debt collection in a company is a factoring agreement. It is an unnamed contract, meaning it is not explicitly regulated in the Civil Code (we will not find specific provisions for this form of contract in it, just as in the case of a mandate contract or a contract for specific work). Therefore, the general principle of freedom of contract is indicated as the basis for concluding factoring agreements.

According to the definition set out in international law, the subject of a factoring agreement is the transfer of receivables resulting from contracts by the factorant to the factor. This means that if a contractor requires an invoice with a deferred payment term – 30, 60, or 90 days – such an invoice can be “sold” as part of factoring. In this way, the entrepreneur receives payment for the invoice much earlier and without the burdensome necessity of later collecting from the contractor.

It should be noted that factoring most often takes place in relation to non-overdue invoices. Note: factoring in this regard is not the same as the assignment of receivables.

How to use factoring in a company?

Larger entrepreneurs with a dominant position in relationships with suppliers often impose deferred payment terms. Of course, this has a negative impact on the financial condition of the company, as for a certain period (a month, two, or more) the supplier does not receive remuneration. As a result, they are forced to finance the costs of running their business from other funds, e.g., from other contracts. Due to deferred payment terms and shortages in payments of current receivables (e.g., with short payment terms), the financial liquidity of entrepreneurs is temporarily disrupted.

By using the factoring procedure, we can obtain the due funds much faster – often even within a few days. What are the main advantages and disadvantages of this solution?

Advantages of factoring

The primary benefit of factoring is the ability to quickly receive funds from invoices that the contractor should settle at a later date. This allows the company to maintain financial liquidity at an appropriate level.
In addition, in the case of a process such as factoring, you generally do not have to go through any complicated contractor verification procedure. We also do not have to examine their creditworthiness. Sometimes, obtaining funds from an invoice earlier is only possible after signing a receivable assignment document.

Another advantage of factoring is the lack of need for debt collection, and in some situations (in so-called full factoring), completely getting rid of the risk resulting from the contractor’s insolvency. Furthermore, factoring is not only a form of selling invoices but also an opportunity to use numerous additional services, e.g., examining the contractor’s financial condition or monitoring receivables in the company.

Disadvantages of factoring

Unfortunately, factoring also has some downsides, and the main one is the costs incurred. Apart from administrative fees related to handling the sale of a specific invoice, the factor almost never transfers the full amount of the invoice to the factorant. The purchase price of the invoice is lower than its original value. It can therefore be considered a form of remuneration for the factor for taking on the risk of collecting from the client. It must be emphasized here that the discrepancies between the invoice value and the sum paid by the factor can amount to even several dozen percent.

Besides that, one must remember that factoring can cause a deterioration of business relations with the contractor. After all, in case of a delay, they will be pursued by the factor, who generally conducts much more aggressive debt collection than the original creditor.
Factoring cannot be used in every case, and the factoring agreement itself may contain provisions unfavorable to the entrepreneur. Therefore, if we want factoring to be fully profitable and effective for us, we should seek professional legal advice beforehand.

Factoring

When can you not use factoring?

There are many types of factoring in legal circulation, but as we mentioned earlier, we do not always have the possibility to apply this procedure.

We cannot do this primarily when the contract with the contractor contains a prohibition on the assignment of receivables. Factoring most often consists of receiving payment for an invoice in exchange for the assignment of rights resulting from that invoice. However, when the contract does not allow for the assignment of receivables, individual consent from the creditor for factoring must be obtained.

Traditional factoring, when there is a prohibition on assignment in the contract, is not possible without the creditor’s consent.

In addition, factoring of overdue invoices is definitely difficult, and sometimes even impossible. This type of invoice (classified as debt) can be disposed of as part of a sale of receivables, not through factoring.

Another problematic situation may be the factoring of invoices of contractors who are in bankruptcy or restructuring. Payment for such receivables may be at risk. Therefore, there is a high risk that the creditor will not receive the full amount from a given invoice. Of course, companies providing factoring services are aware of this, which is why obtaining earlier payment for invoices issued to an insolvent company may simply turn out to be impossible.

Potential problems that factoring can generate

Although factoring is usually a good way out, it sometimes becomes the cause of serious problems. Among them, we have distinguished two basic ones: lack of payment from the contractor in connection with factoring and lack of payment from the factor:

  • Refusal to pay the invoice by the contractor

Most often, we have to inform the contractor about the factoring. Unfortunately, it may happen that when the contractor is aware that their direct business partner does not suffer damage as a result of non-payment (because they sold the invoice to another entity in the financial industry), they may deliberately not pay the invoice covered by the factoring process.
Sometimes this is because the factor buying the receivables is an anonymous fund whose collection can be delayed. Other times, it is the result of a deliberate and dishonest desire to expose the contractor to additional, higher factoring costs. In both situations, factoring can therefore cause severe problems in relations with contractors.

  • Refusal to pay for the invoice by the factor

Problems can also occur on the part of the factor themselves. In most cases, factoring involves the obligation to accept the regulations and procedures adopted by the factor. Mainly in the case of invoices with a short payment term or issued to contractors with a bad financial history (e.g., entries of execution in the National Court Register or being in a state of restructuring or bankruptcy), the factor may refuse payment, so the invoice sale transaction will not take place.
Another example is the insolvency of the factor. Of course, this is unlikely, as large entities from the financial sector become factors, but such a possibility cannot be ruled out. We should be on our guard especially when the factor is an entity that has recently started operating in the industry.

Conclusions

The current crisis and the poor payment morality of Polish entrepreneurs make factoring an interesting alternative to later debt collection. This procedure allows for maintaining financial liquidity and peace of mind about the company’s future. At the same time, it is not a tool that will work in every situation and for every type of financial problem. For this reason, before we use this tool, we should seek legal advice.