
A study conducted for the Transcash report “Payments in the transport industry 2019-2022” showed that more than half of the respondents do not regularly receive payment on time. Due to this lack of payment, carriers are unable to meet their own obligations, which results in very high debt across the entire TSL industry – KRD estimates it at PLN 1.13 billion. Attempting to recover money from contractors can end up in court, where the key to success is well-prepared documentation. So, how can you properly document your claims in court proceedings? Beata Gądek, a legal advisor at TC Kancelaria Prawna, answers this question.
To shorten the time it takes for courts to hear business cases, the legislature introduced legal provisions regulating civil proceedings in commercial matters. This separate proceeding is characterized by many formal rigors imposed on both the plaintiff and the defendant.
Statement of claim and response to the statement of claim in commercial transport cases
Civil proceedings in commercial matters begin with the filing of a statement of claim by the plaintiff. In accordance with Art. 458(5) § 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, the plaintiff is required to cite all allegations and evidence in the statement of claim, and the defendant in the response to the statement of claim.
– This seemingly simple rule has a very large impact on the ongoing proceedings and sometimes determines whether the claim is granted or dismissed – says Beata Gądek, a legal advisor at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Art. 458(5) § 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure indicates that evidence presented at a later stage of the proceedings may be disregarded by the court, unless the party makes it probable that its presentation was not possible or that the need to present it arose later.
What documents are necessary when filing a transport-related lawsuit?
A carrier whose client has not settled the due remuneration has the option of taking the case to court. When issuing a judgment in commercial proceedings, the court will grant their claim and attach an enforcement clause, which allows for the commencement of enforcement proceedings. For the court to issue a judgment granting the claim, the party must prove that the transport contract was concluded, duly performed, and then a VAT invoice was correctly issued and delivered along with transport documents to the client within the appropriate time limit.
– The carrier must therefore remember to ensure that all arrangements regarding the transport contract and its implementation are properly documented. Elements of the transport contract, such as the designation of the transport route, the carrier’s remuneration, and the subject of transport, should be confirmed in writing or via SMS. The content of telephone conversations can be very difficult to establish, especially when the other party denies it – explains Beata Gądek, a legal advisor at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
How to prove properly performed transport? The most important documents will be the transport order, the consignment note, and a correctly issued VAT invoice with confirmation of its dispatch along with transport documents to the client.
Transport order in transport cases
There is no single template for transport orders, so clients present carriers with documents prepared for their own needs. Sometimes the order contains only the date, place of loading, unloading, and remuneration; in other cases, it will be a multi-page document burdened with a number of conditions and rigors. An e-mail, SMS, or messenger conversation with the indicated necessary elements of the transport contract can also serve as a transport order. What is worth remembering after receiving a transport order?
– First of all, you need to read it carefully and pay attention to whether all the data matches – how the remuneration, deadline, and currency of payment are defined, and whether it is a net or gross amount. In the transport order, you can specify the method of sending transport documents to the client or the obligation to inform about the stages of transport implementation. Even if the content of the transport order conditions was created solely by the client, their provisions can be negotiated. Any changes to the provisions of the transport order should be clearly marked – so as to prove that a payment deadline other than the standard one for a given client was agreed upon – says the expert from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
Consignment note in transport law
A consignment note is not essential in court proceedings, but when properly filled out, it constitutes undeniable proof of the proper performance of the obligation by the carrier. In accordance with Art. 4 paragraphs 1 and 2 of the CMR Convention, the consignment note is proof of the conclusion of a transport contract. The absence, irregularity, or loss of the consignment note does not affect the existence or validity of the transport contract, which is nevertheless subject to the provisions of this Convention. At the same time, in accordance with Art. 38 of the Transport Law, the sender submits a consignment note to the carrier for the cargo shipment, and if it is commonly accepted for a given type of transport, provides the information necessary for the proper performance of the transport in another way. In the consignment note, the sender includes the name and address of the sender, their signature, and the designation of the carrier’s facility concluding the contract, the place of destination of the shipment, and the name and address of the recipient, the description of the goods, mass, number of pieces of the shipment, method of packaging and marking, and other indications and declarations required or permitted in accordance with the regulations due to the conditions of a given contract or method of settlement.
Confirmation of the performance of the obligation can also be a “WZ” (release note) document or confirmation of receipt of goods by the recipient.

VAT invoice along with confirmation of its dispatch and receipt
An extremely important document proving the proper performance of the transport contract by the carrier is a correctly issued VAT invoice. One must pay attention to the conditions specified in the transport order, regarding, for example, the payment deadline, the currency in which the payment is to be made, or the elements that must be indicated on the VAT invoice. Any issuance of a VAT invoice correction means that the payment deadline will start running from the date of issuance of that invoice. For example, it can be pointed out that if the parties agreed on a payment deadline of 60 days and it falls on March 8, 2022, then issuing a VAT invoice correction on March 7, 2022, will mean that the other party is obliged to pay the remuneration by May 6, 2022.
– The carrier should exercise special caution when sending transport documents and the VAT invoice to the client. The transport order usually indicates the address to which the documents are to be sent. If it has not been provided, and the client does not respond to contact attempts, it is safest to send the documents to the current address of the client indicated in the Central Register and Information on Economic Activity (CEIDG) or the National Court Register (KRS). It is also worth keeping confirmation of the dispatch of documents – comments Beata Gądek from TC Kancelaria Prawna.
A document that business owners often forget about is the confirmation of sending the VAT invoice to the contractor. When claiming compensation for debt recovery costs equivalent to the amount of 40 EURO, 70 EURO, or 100 EURO, in accordance with Art. 10 point 1 of the Act on Counteracting Excessive Delays in Commercial Transactions, it is necessary to present confirmation of sending the VAT invoice to the debtor to prove that the payment deadline has passed. The lack of such a document may mean the court issues a dismissal judgment, even though the creditor remained without payment for the service longer than agreed by the parties.
Other documents
The transport order, consignment note, and VAT invoice are the basic documents constituting evidence in court proceedings. However, the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure do not contain a closed catalog of evidence – it is open. E-mails with the transport order sent by the client, the content of conversations between the parties regarding the execution of the order, but also any other documents – parking cards, confirmation of payment of additional fees, or documents received during loading or unloading – have significant evidentiary value.
Court proceedings in commercial matters
Court proceedings in commercial matters begin at the moment of filing a statement of claim. It is worth filing it in electronic writ-of-payment proceedings, because it is definitely faster, and the court fee is 1/4 of the fee charged in ordinary proceedings. The only condition is that the debtor must have a place of residence or an address for service in Poland. In electronic writ-of-payment proceedings, claims that became due within three years before the date of filing the statement of claim can be pursued. If the court has no doubts about the circumstances of the case, the proceedings will end with the issuance of a payment order, which will become final if the defendant does not file an objection. After the defendant files an objection, the payment order will be set aside, and the proceedings discontinued.
– At this stage, the creditor may, within three months from the date of issuance of the order to discontinue the electronic writ-of-payment proceedings, file a lawsuit against the defendant for the same claim in proceedings other than electronic writ-of-payment proceedings. In such a situation, the fee paid in the electronic writ-of-payment proceedings is credited towards the court fee necessary to be paid in other proceedings. While in electronic writ-of-payment proceedings one only needs to indicate the evidence confirming the claim, without the need to attach them, in other proceedings it is already necessary – says Beata Gądek, a legal advisor at TC Kancelaria Prawna.
It is worth emphasizing that a properly documented claim has a huge impact on the course of court proceedings. Obtaining a judgment granting a claim in a case based on incomplete documentation or only the testimony of witnesses or parties can be much more difficult. In accordance with Art. 458(10) of the Code of Civil Procedure, the court may admit evidence from witness testimony only when, after exhausting other means of evidence or in their absence, facts essential for the resolution of the case remain unexplained. It is in the interest of every person, and especially a person conducting business activity, to keep documentation confirming the proper performance of the service. Thanks to this, in the event of a lack of payment by the contractor, one can effectively pursue their rights in court.
Source: TC Kancelaria Prawna







