
More and more regulations are appearing in Polish law that aim to systematize the rules related to online stores and online sales. At the beginning of 2023, amendments to the Consumer Rights Act and other legal acts will come into force, introducing the Omnibus, Digital, and Goods directives into the Polish legal order. The new regulations will have a significant impact on the domestic e-commerce market. What do the new rules mean for sellers and consumers?
At the beginning of the year, new, important regulations are coming into force that will change Polish e-commerce. The well-known Omnibus directive, which has already been implemented in most EU countries, as well as the Digital and Goods directives. The provisions of both amendments refer to each other and complement one another. How will they change e-commerce in Poland?
The Omnibus Directive
This is a legal act aimed at strengthening and unifying consumer protection rules. In simple terms, it is an enforcement and modernization directive that increases transparency and strengthens the informational awareness of the consumer who, among other things, buys digital goods and services online. Under the influence of the EU directive, the Consumer Rights Act will change the most, but not only that. The changes will also cover the Act on Informing about Prices of Goods and Services and the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection.
In the world of e-commerce, the Omnibus directive has been widely discussed since the end of 2019. How will these regulations affect the daily operation of e-businesses?
– Entrepreneurs should adapt to the new regulations, in particular to information obligations. Both in terms of changing terms and conditions and related documentation, and by preparing appropriate interfaces on the website – says Gabriela Halla-Popławska, a lawyer at IdoSell.
So how to comply with the Omnibus directive in practice? Apart from the issue of promotions, e-store owners must provide information on the rules under which product reviews are published on their websites, e.g., whether both positive and negative ones are posted, or whether they are sponsored. An important point is also information on whether the presented price is personalized (based on automated consumer behavior profiling).
– Additional obligations have also been provided for entrepreneurs who offer digital services and content in exchange for personal data. Processing of personal data in such situations should be in accordance with the GDPR – emphasizes Gabriela Halla-Popławska.
What are the penalties for non-compliance?
An important element of the Omnibus directive is the introduction of appropriate safeguards to ensure compliance with the regulations. This concerns a system of fines and monetary penalties aimed at enforcing the regulations in practice.
The maximum amount of fines for violating the regulations should be set at a level of at least 4 percent of the entrepreneur’s annual turnover.
– In cases where information about the annual turnover of the seller or supplier is not available, member states are required to introduce provisions providing for the possibility of imposing fines. Their maximum amount is at least 2 million euros, but they can also introduce higher penalties – explains Gabriela Halla-Popławska.
Furthermore, according to the directive’s provisions, consumers who have suffered as a result of unfair commercial practices should be provided with access to effective legal remedies such as compensation, or even price reduction or contract termination.
The implementation of the Omnibus directive in Poland is dispersed across several acts that complement each other and also refer to one another, including in terms of adopted definitions.
The government draft implementing Omnibus is a legal act amending, among others, the Consumer Rights Act, the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection, the Act on Counteracting Unfair Market Practices, and the Act on Informing about Prices of Goods and Services.
– New definitions such as ‘online marketplace’ or ‘provider of an online marketplace’ will be introduced into the Consumer Rights Act. New information obligations will be imposed on the provider of an online marketplace, consisting of: the necessity to inform the consumer, in a clear and understandable way, about the main parameters determining the ranking of offers presented to the consumer and whether the third party offering their goods, services, or digital content on the online marketplace is an entrepreneur. Thanks to the latter, the consumer will know whether the purchase contract concluded on the online marketplace will be subject to consumer law protection – explains Gabriela Halla-Popławska.
Regulations regarding withdrawal from a contract ‘paid for’ with data have also been introduced. In this situation, the entrepreneur should comply with the obligations resulting from the GDPR regulation.
A commonly used practice in the e-commerce world is the publication by sellers of reviews of the products they offer or services they provide. It is no secret that many abuses occur in this area on the part of dishonest sellers. Therefore, the amendment to the Act on Counteracting Unfair Market Practices, which follows the Omnibus directive, regulates the issue of publishing reviews. As part of the amendment, a definition of ‘ranking’ was added, which is understood as giving specific visibility to products or the weight given to search results by entrepreneurs.
– To the catalog of essential information needed by an average consumer to make a decision to enter into a contract, a provision has been added that obliges to inform buyers about how reviews are posted on the site. In particular, how the seller verifies whether the reviews posted on the website actually come from consumers who have used or purchased a given product – says Gabriela Halla-Popławska.
The entrepreneur is also obliged to inform the consumer about paid advertising if they have paid the search function provider for a higher product ranking. Failure to fulfill this obligation constitutes an unfair market practice.
– As for the Act on Informing about Prices of Goods and Services, it introduces the now-famous information obligation for promotions. It is about indicating the lowest price of a given good or service that was in effect during the 30 days before the price reduction was introduced – adds Halla-Popławska. – Compliance with this obligation will be enforced by the Trade Inspection, which will be able to impose a monetary penalty of up to 20,000 PLN on a dishonest seller. For an entrepreneur who notoriously violates the provisions of the act (at least three times in a 12-month period), the penalty can be as high as 40,000 PLN.
Digital and Goods Directive
The Digital and Goods directives will also leave a significant mark on Polish e-commerce. The changes will primarily affect the obligations that sellers and content creators have. So what changes are taking place in Polish legislation, why is it important for merchants, and what is actually being modified? Until now, sellers had an obligation to respond to a complaint within 30 days. Now this time is to be shortened to 14 days.
– If the seller or provider of a digital service or content does not respond to the complaint within this time, it means that they have accepted the complaint – explains Rafał Malujda, a legal advisor at IdoSell.
Another novelty is related to liability (warranty) for defects. In the case of goods, the entrepreneur will be liable for defects in the goods revealed within two years from the date of their delivery.
– It will be assumed that defects revealed within this period existed at the time of delivery of the goods – emphasizes Rafał Malujda.
In the case of digital content and services, the entrepreneur will also be liable for defects revealed within two years from their delivery. However, the presumption of lack of conformity of digital content or service with the contract will only apply for one year from the moment the content is delivered. A similar regulation currently applies to physical goods.
– If it were to be otherwise, the seller must prove that they did not conceal it and that the defect arose later. With digital content, it is a bit different – due to its specificity, the period of presumption of defectiveness is shorter – lists Rafał Malujda.
The provisions of the directives introduce many changes at the level of the Consumer Rights Act, but to some extent, they operate on the conceptual framework that we know from existing regulations, for example, from the current regulation of the warranty for defects in goods – i.e., conformity, non-conformity with the contract. Consumers know that they can demand the removal of a defect, exchange the goods for new ones, or possibly demand a price reduction or withdraw from the contract and demand a refund of the entire value if the product is defective.
– This structure is more or less maintained, especially for goods. For digital services, it introduces a new category – non-conformity of a digital service with the contract and bringing the digital service into conformity with the contract. It clarifies in what situation, what, and when we can demand, and when liability is excluded – explains Rafał Malujda.
A complete novelty in the regulations is the appearance of the category of goods with digital elements (‘smart’), an example of which could be, for example, a smartwatch. In such a case, the watch itself should be considered a good with digital elements that can perform its functions only with an application that is made available under the same sales contract, but which the consumer must download to their smartphone – the application would then be a mutually connected digital element.
The new regulations will also address the issue of personal data trading. Currently, this is already permissible, e.g., exchanging data for access to a service and the possibility for the entrepreneur to send marketing emails. Here, situations that are not subject to the regulation of the Consumer Rights Act (e.g., providing data for the purpose of performing a contract) will be clarified.
The new regulations also clarify the issue of public assurances, acceptance of certain defects in goods or services by the consumer.
– On the other hand, the entrepreneur’s acceptance requires, for example, that the delivery date or specific properties are important to the consumer. All this means that statements by sales departments on chats and messengers posted on store websites will have increasing importance – says Rafał Malujda.
Source: IdoSell







