Reporting a competition law violation: step by step

Reporting a competition law violation: step by step

What should you do if you have reasonable suspicion that an entrepreneur operating in the market is acting unethically and violating competition law? In such a case, you should inform the appropriate supervisory authority about this fact as soon as possible. In this article, we will explain who can report a competition law violation, to which institution, and how.

Behaviors classified as competition law violations
Freedom of economic activity is one of the fundamental rights guaranteed by the Constitution. The principle of freedom of economic activity is also included in the Entrepreneurs’ Law and EU legislation. According to this rule, every person has the same right to conduct business, including starting and ending it. However, it must be remembered that when conducting business, one must always act in accordance with the law and not violate the fundamental principles associated with it, primarily respecting the rules of fair competition. Conducting business in a way that causes harm to the legitimate interests of other entrepreneurs operating in the market is a violation of competition law.
What actions are classified as competition law violations? They fall into two categories. The first is multilateral actions, i.e., those involving multiple entrepreneurs. They can take the form of agreements or arrangements through which entrepreneurs outside of said agreement or arrangement will be eliminated from the market or their ability to conduct business will be limited. These types of agreements, according to Article 6 of the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection, are referred to as anti-competitive agreements. Their goal may be, for example:

  • fixing prices and other terms of purchase or sale of goods,
  • limiting or controlling production, sales, technical progress, or investment,
  • dividing sales or purchase markets,
  • agreeing on the terms of submitted offers by entrepreneurs participating in a tender or by those entrepreneurs and the entrepreneur organizing the tender, in particular the scope of work or price.

In the case of the second category of competition law violations, we are talking about unilateral nature. This is a violation committed by only one entrepreneur, whose action will be based on exploiting their dominant position against other entrepreneurs. This type of violation was characterized in Article 9 of the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection. According to this provision, abuse of a dominant position may consist of:

  • directly or indirectly imposing unfair prices,
  • limiting production, sales, or technical progress to the detriment of contractors or consumers,
  • applying burdensome or non-uniform contract terms in similar agreements with third parties, creating differentiated competitive conditions for these persons,
  • imposing burdensome contract terms by an entrepreneur that bring them unjustified benefits.

All the above actions have the hallmarks of competition law violations, which is why they should be reported to the appropriate authorities.

advice 2

Who can make a report? All authorized entities
When we notice that an entrepreneur is acting in an ethically questionable manner and, to our knowledge, their behavior can be classified as a competition law violation, we should report this fact to the appropriate authorities. According to the adopted rules, a report can be made by any person who possesses information about a competition law violation. This will therefore be a natural person, a legal person, as well as an organizational unit without legal personality.
It must also be kept in mind that the report should be made regardless of whether we are witnesses to the event or have been directly harmed as a result of the violation:

  • Whistleblower – i.e., a person who possesses information that is not publicly available and wants to share it with the supervisory authority, can report it anonymously, i.e., without revealing their personal details. In that case, the authority will guarantee the whistleblower the security of personal data and that the entity violating competition rules will not find out who made the report. This will be very important, for example, when a whistleblower reports a violation committed by their employer.
  • Member of an anti-competitive agreement – if someone has knowledge about a violation because they are participating in it themselves, but feels some discomfort regarding this fact, they can easily return to the path of the law. It is enough for them to immediately withdraw from such an agreement and then submit an application called leniency. We discuss the leniency procedure in the further part of the text.

Which authority must be notified in case of a violation?
The authority competent in matters of competition and consumer protection is the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK), headed by the President. It is a central government administration body that operates on the basis of the Act of February 16, 2007, on Competition and Consumer Protection. The Office’s activity is based primarily on providing support to consumers in relations with entrepreneurs and supporting and caring for the proper development of competition among entrepreneurs. One of the many tasks performed by the Office is precisely acting as a contact point for people reporting violations in the field of competition law.

How to make such a report? There are two available paths, and below we discuss what characterizes each of them.

advice 3

Formal reporting path: direct report to UOKiK
The basis for submitting a formal notification to the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection is Article 86 of the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection. According to this provision, a notification can be submitted by anyone – that is, by all persons possessing any information regarding a competition law violation.
In Article 86, we will also find a condition regarding the form of the report. It must be in writing and accompanied by appropriate justification. This means that the reporter is obliged to argue before the Office why (in their opinion) the behavior of a specific entrepreneur bears the hallmarks of a competition law violation. In addition, the report must include several mandatory elements:

  • indication of the entrepreneur accused of applying an anti-competitive practice;
  • description of the factual state forming the basis of the notification;
  • indication of the provision of the Act or EU treaty whose violation the reporter alleges;
  • substantiation of the violation of the provisions of the Act or EU treaty;
  • data identifying the person submitting the notification.

It must be remembered that by choosing this form of reporting, we will not remain anonymous. The Office requires identification of the sender of the report. In addition, if the person reporting has any evidence of such a violation, they must attach it to the notification. Most helpful from the Office’s perspective will be any internal evidence, i.e., notes, emails, or internal company correspondence. For these reasons, very valuable whistleblowers for the Office are usually former employees of the entrepreneur who committed the violations, as well as contractors.

advice 4

Informal reporting path: maintaining anonymity
The second option is a less formalized path for submitting notifications. There are several methods to use this route.
The first possibility is to submit a notification using the website created for this purpose: https://report.whistleb.com/pl/uokik. If for some reason we want to make a report anonymously, we can submit a notification to the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection without making our data public. The site will redirect the person to a special form where they can indicate the entrepreneur the report concerns, as well as describe in detail their suspicions, behavior, and actions of the entrepreneur.
Files can be attached to the report if we have evidence to support our words. And that is basically where all the actions end – just click “send” for the report to go straight to the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection. Because we do not provide any of our data in the report, the Office will not be able to contact us in any other way.
The second form of reporting a violation is sending an email to the address of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection: dok@uokik.gov.pl, or traditionally by paper mail to the address: Urząd Ochrony Konkurencji i Konsumentów Departament Ochrony Konkurencji, plac Powstańców Warszawy 1, 00-950 Warszawa.

Moreover, the report can be sent via the ePUAP platform. It should be noted that if the report is local in nature and concerns competition operating within a smaller area, e.g., a municipality or county, the notification can be submitted directly to the local representative of the Office. UOKiK regional offices are located in Bydgoszcz, Gdańsk, Katowice, Kraków, Lublin, Łódź, Wrocław, and Poznań.

advice 5

Leniency application. How does it work and what does it guarantee?
As mentioned earlier, even when the person reporting is one of the co-perpetrators of the violation, they can make a report to the Office and simultaneously apply for the leniency procedure.
Leniency is a program for reducing penalties for entrepreneurs and individuals who, as a result of active regret, report a violation and express a willingness to cooperate with the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection. In return, they can apply for a partial or total exemption from the financial penalty that could threaten them in the event of the detection of said violation by UOKiK.
The application must meet the requirements included in Article 113a paragraph 2 of the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection. Its mandatory elements include, among others:

  • indication of the entrepreneurs who entered into the agreement;
  • indication of the products or services the agreement concerns;
  • purpose of the agreement;
  • circumstances of entering into the agreement;
  • circumstances and manner of the agreement’s functioning;
  • duration of the agreement;
  • indication of the role of individual entrepreneurs participating in the agreement.

The leniency application can be submitted in writing – electronically or by mail, as well as in person at the Office’s headquarters or one of its regional offices. Importantly, only one entity can be covered by the leniency procedure – the one that first reports the violation to UOKiK. Therefore, when three entrepreneurs participate in an agreement, and two of them report the violation to the Office, only the one who did it first will be able to submit a leniency application.

What happens to the report later?
All reports, regardless of which submission path we chose, will be analyzed by employees of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection. At the same time, at this stage, they are not conducting proceedings against the entrepreneur (yet). Nevertheless, they are conducting proceedings in the case, meaning they are not bringing charges, but only checking whether a specific behavior actually meets the criteria for being considered a competition law violation.
After conducting the explanatory proceedings, the Office must inform the person submitting the report about the results of its investigation. Depending on the path through which they made the report, they receive feedback in an analogous way.
According to the main rule, UOKiK has one month from the date of submitting the notification to look into the case and provide an answer to the reporter. However, when the case turns out to be complicated and the Office needs more time, it may extend the indicated deadline for informing the reporter in accordance with the provisions of the Code of Administrative Procedure. It should also inform the notifier about this fact, taking into account the reason for the extension of the deadline.

Conclusions
Every participant in economic turnover, regardless of the function performed, should contribute to ensuring compliance with competition law rules. The very fact of the existence of competition has a positive impact on the market, and at the same time ensures its progress and growth as well as the development of entrepreneurs’ activity.
All this makes the observance and protection of competition law rules play such an important role. One of the ways is reporting all manifestations of such violations to the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection. The role of the Office is to ensure that the reporter (if they express such a will) can remain anonymous, as well as to thoroughly analyze and investigate the case, which will allow for the eradication of various manifestations of unfair competition from the market.