Is a receipt required to return goods purchased online?

Is a receipt required to return goods purchased online?

Purchasing products in an online store always involves a certain amount of risk. An item bought without seeing it beforehand may not look like it does in the attached photo. It may also be damaged during transport, or simply not appeal to us visually. In the case of clothing, it also happens that a given size simply does not fit us. For this reason, it is natural that as consumers shopping online, we want to have the option to return goods. However, what should you do if there is no receipt in the package?

Consumer Rights Act

To begin with, it is worth mentioning that an online seller does not have to have a fiscal cash register. If they receive full payment via post, bank, or cooperative savings and credit union into their account, and the records and proof of payment clearly indicate which transaction it concerned and for whose benefit it was made, they will not be obliged to issue receipts to consumers.

Online store customers may therefore wonder: does the lack of a receipt mean it is impossible to return goods?

The answer can be found in Article 27 of the Consumer Rights Act, according to which a consumer entering into a distance or off-premises contract may withdraw from it within 14 days without giving any reason and without incurring costs. The only cost they will bear is related to the fee for returning the item and the costs of transporting the item to the consumer if they chose a delivery method other than the cheapest one offered by the seller.

The 14-day period is counted from the moment the consumer or a third party other than the carrier indicated by the consumer takes possession of the goods. In practice, this is counted from the time the package is received. Importantly, if the seller does not inform the consumer about the right to withdraw from the contract, this period is extended to 12 months.

In summary, this provision does not mention an obligation to document the purchase with a receipt. The goods do not have to be defective or damaged either. It is enough that they do not satisfy the consumer. At the same time, the right to withdraw from the contract should not be confused with a complaint.

As a rule, the goods should be sent back to the seller as soon as possible, no later than 14 days from the withdrawal from the contract. The seller must return the payment within the same period. It must be noted that the consumer is responsible for any reduction in the value of the item resulting from using it in a way that goes beyond what is necessary to establish the nature, characteristics, and functioning of the item (except in situations where the entrepreneur did not inform the consumer about the right to withdraw from the contract).

We can therefore unpack the item, check if it suits us, and also damage the packaging it was in, if it was necessary to establish the characteristics, nature, and functioning of the purchase. However, the seller has the right to reduce the amount of the refunded payment if we damage the product in another way, e.g., by scratching the surface, putting a hole in clothing, or losing parts of it. In such a case, the seller provides information about the damage to the goods and proposes a partial refund – depending on how much its value has decreased.

Proof of purchase of goods online

At the same time, it is the consumer who bears the burden of proving that they purchased the goods from the seller. When they do not have a receipt, according to the position of the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (expressed, among others, in the decision of May 4, 2015, no. RBG 7/2015), they can use any other proof that confirms the purchase, e.g., an email confirming the placement and payment of the order along with a list of products, a warranty stamped by the seller, or a bank account statement. Data from the system and witness testimony can also serve as proof.

Is a receipt required to return goods purchased online?

Prohibited contractual clauses in store regulations

It happens that sellers include clauses in their store regulations stating that the return of goods is possible only upon presentation of an invoice or receipt. These are prohibited contractual clauses that in no way bind the customer, and their use may result in the imposition of a fine on the seller of up to 10% of the turnover achieved in the financial year preceding the year the fine was imposed.

According to the position of the UOKiK, prohibited contractual clauses include, among others, the following examples:

  • A necessary condition for returning goods is having proof of purchase for the goods (VAT invoice, original receipt);
  • Returned goods must be sent back together with the receipt received with them;
  • Attention! Without a fiscal receipt, the goods are not subject to return;
  • Goods returned in this mode will be accepted only and exclusively if they are sent back in the original, undamaged box;

The return of goods can be realized only if the goods were not custom-ordered, were not used, are originally packed, and the packaging is not destroyed, soaked, etc. In the case of finding damage to the packaging, non-original packaging, or traces of use of the goods, the Seller reserves the right to refuse to accept the goods.

Does the seller have to issue an invoice for an online purchase?

Some are convinced that a seller in an online store is obliged to issue a VAT invoice or a non-VAT invoice, especially when they have not issued a receipt. However, the seller has no such obligation, as stated in Art. 106b sec. 1 points 1 and 2 of the Act on Tax on Goods and Services. According to this provision, a domestic seller must issue an invoice only for another VAT taxpayer or for a legal entity that is not a taxpayer, or in the case of distance selling to another EU country.

Nevertheless, the consumer has the right to demand the issuance of an invoice within three months – counting from the end of the month in which the product was delivered or the full or partial payment was received. In that case, the seller is obliged to issue an invoice. Furthermore, in the case of a consumer, it does not matter whether the issued receipt contained the buyer’s tax identification number (NIP), or whether a receipt was issued at all. An invoice can also be issued for sales documented in another way.

Receipts and online shopping. Conclusions

In summary, the lack of a receipt or invoice does not result in the exclusion of the possibility of returning goods purchased online. Such a purchase can be documented in any other, arbitrary way. On the other hand, if such provisions are found in the store’s regulations, they absolutely do not bind the customer. However, they may be associated with the imposition of a fine on the seller by the President of the UOKiK.

Looking at it from this perspective, it will be more beneficial for the seller to simply send the customer a receipt (if they have a fiscal cash register). Nevertheless, neither the lack of a receipt nor the lack of an invoice results in the inability to record a sales correction in the goods return records. In addition, every online seller should remember that failing to inform the customer about the right to withdraw from the contract carries many severe, negative legal consequences.