How to protect a product label? Brand protection methods

How to protect a product label? Brand protection methods

Every entrepreneur should be aware of the issues arising from intellectual property protection. Many encounter this topic right at the beginning of their business operations, especially in the manufacturing sector. How can you effectively protect your product label and your brand’s trademark?

Why is it worth taking care of company protection? Several important reasons

A company (firma) is a common term for a business activity. However, according to the legal definition, it is the name under which a given entrepreneur operates. This approach is consistent with the Civil Code (Article 43 and subsequent).

Importantly, when registering a company in the CEIDG or KRS, the name used by the enterprise is not reserved. This means that any other legal or natural person can easily register an enterprise under an identical company name. Registrars and judges do not check by default whether a specific name is under legal protection. Officials only ensure that the submitted applications are correct and complete, and they check information regarding any bans on conducting business activities.

As a result, when we type the name “Transpol” into the search engine of the Central Registration and Information on Business (CEIDG) or the National Court Register (KRS), over 150 results appear, and just as many in the KRS itself. Therefore, if a given enterprise wants to have a brand exclusively in its possession, it must register it with the Patent Office.

Trademark registration is also an effective method of protection against its loss. It often happens that a third party registers a trademark used by another entrepreneur in their own name. They then blackmail them and force them to buy back the brand or obtain a paid license from them.

Nevertheless, it should be noted that there is a possibility of protection against an attempt to register an identical or similar trademark. This involves blocking or invalidating a trademark registration. The opposition procedure (until 2016, an examination procedure was in place) is an effective legal tool, within which one must present evidence of the right to the brand. In turn, the best, irrefutable evidence is the trademark registration certificate.

The registered mark is published in an open official register, made available on the Patent Office website. It will therefore effectively deter and discourage others from unlawfully using our designation. In addition, a person infringing on the right to a mark cannot defend themselves by claiming ignorance. Due to the fact that the Patent Office maintains a public register of marks, anyone can easily obtain information about rights reserved for someone else. Consequently, by registering your company’s name, you possess an effective weapon to fight against unfair competition.

How to register a product label? Industrial design vs. trademark

Trademarks and industrial designs are subject to legal protection under the provisions of the Act of June 30, 2000, on Industrial Property Law (PWP). According to the law, a product label falls under both categories.
According to the definition of an industrial design in Article 102:

“an industrial design is a new and individual character of a product or its part, given to it in particular by the features of lines, contours, shapes, colors, texture or material of the product and by its ornamentation.”

As you can see, an industrial design must have an individual character. This means that the overall impression it makes on the recipient must be different from the overall impression made by another publicly available design registered earlier.

In turn, a trademark is “any sign capable of distinguishing the goods of one undertaking from those of another and capable of being represented in the register of trademarks in a manner which allows the subject matter of the protection granted to be determined clearly and precisely.” According to the Act, a trademark is mainly considered to be:

  • A word, including a surname;
  • A drawing;
  • A letter;
  • A digit;
  • A color;
  • A spatial form, including the shape of the goods or packaging;
  • A sound.

As you can see, a product label can be considered both an industrial design and a trademark. It is a mixture of graphics, colors, and words. Much depends, however, on whether there is an element allowing for the recognition of the brand in the form of a word or graphic designation, or whether it is actually packaging or a graphic symbol with an individual character.

Checking the registers, one can notice that companies usually apply for label protection based on a trademark application. Nevertheless, there are exceptions that register them also as an industrial design. An example could be the Maspex sp. z o.o. group, which owns the Tymbark brand in its portfolio. Its labels appear in both the trademark and industrial design search engines. As a result, it has gained the most complete form of protection, which is particularly important for companies creating many different products and frequently changing their graphic design or packaging.

How to protect a product label? Brand protection methods

Can an unregistered trademark be protected?

According to Polish legislation, there are situations in which a trademark is protected nonetheless. The regulations providing such a form of protection for trademarks are primarily:

  • The Civil Code – especially Article 43(10) (premises for the protection of the right to a company name)
  • The Act on Combating Unfair Competition – provisions of Articles 5 and 10
  • The Copyright Act – only in the scope of graphic brand identification

Nevertheless, it is worth noting that these are not provisions that strongly emphasize the liability of a trademark infringer. In the Supreme Court judgment of August 11, 2004, case file II CK 487/03, it was explicitly stated that: “the purpose of the prohibition of unfair competition is to eliminate all actions that could in any way cause confusion regarding the entrepreneur or their product (…) It cannot replace the protection resulting from the provisions regulating absolute rights (patent, trademark, etc.) or cause protection resulting from these provisions.”

Therefore, without registration, the right to trademark protection arises only at the moment of starting commercial use of it in trade. Furthermore, this does not have to be synonymous with the moment of establishing a business activity. Moreover, this moment can occur before or after starting the business. And this creates another problem when an entrepreneur or a natural person wants to use a specific designation in the future. Without disclosing this fact in the register, one cannot reserve and protect a future name or logo. The protection of an unregistered trademark is not recorded in any register, so after an infringement of rights, one must seek justice in a court dispute. Then, the court will decide whether the right to the trademark actually belongs to a specific entity. Furthermore, such a procedure is time-consuming, and gathering evidence can be burdensome or even impossible.

It is also significant that this protection is limited only to the industry in which the enterprise operates and only to the market on which the company operates without a registered trademark.

Those entitled to trademark protection

The protection right belongs to every entitled person, which is both the applicant and another person who has acquired the right to the trademark. The group of entitled entities can be larger, because such a right does not belong to only one person. We distinguish therefore:

1. Individual trademark – the exclusive right to use the trademark by one entity;

2. Joint protection right – a right belonging to several people who have jointly registered a trademark. The rules for using the mark are defined in the regulations adopted by the entrepreneurs.

3. Collective trademark – another type of joint ownership, which belongs to members of an organization or legal persons operating under public law provisions;

4. Certification mark – a solution for associations and persons meeting the requirements included in the mark’s regulations.

How to prepare for the registration procedure?

One must remember that not every designation can be considered a trademark. The most important aspect is the distinctive function. However, a trademark does not have to be original. What counts is that it is distinctive enough to identify a specific product or brand based on it. At the same time, it must not be misleading.

Among the large number of absolute grounds that prevent registration, the following are indicated, among others (Article 129 p. 1 PWP):

  • A designation not capable of distinguishing the goods for which it has been registered;
  • Registration of a designation in bad faith or contrary to public order or good morals;
  • Descriptive or generic designations that function in trade to indicate the type of goods, quality, function, or method of production – an example could be the refusal to register the words “bread” or “tasty bread”;
  • Designations that result from colloquial language or are used in fair and established trade practices; Designations misleading as to the nature, quality, or origin of the goods;
  • Designations containing symbols of the Republic of Poland used without the consent of a state authority;

Moreover, Article 132 p. 1 also defines relative grounds that are a reason for refusal. The most frequently mentioned is the existence of an identical or similar trademark. Such a collision can be indicated in an opposition, which must be filed with the office within three months from the date of publication of the application.

So, before we submit a designation for registration, it should be properly prepared and we should ensure that there is no identical or similar registered mark. For this purpose, we can use the search engine available on the Patent Office website, e.g., Madrid Monitor.

Once we are sure that the mark can be registered, we then make the application. We fill out the application, indicate the goods and services according to the Nice classification, and pay the required fee. Depending on whether we register the mark electronically or not, the fee for a trademark for goods and services in one class of goods can be 400 and 450 PLN, respectively.

When we make the application, it will appear in the Patent Office search engine. If the office does not indicate obstacles, it will be published in the Patent Office Bulletin. Then a 3-month period will begin, during which another entity or person can file an opposition to the registered designation. If there are no grounds for opposition, the office will issue a decision on granting the protection right, and then publish information about it in the Patent Office News.

From this moment, an important issue will be trademark monitoring. This way, we will ensure that no one is infringing on our protection right.

In turn, the procedure for registering an industrial design is very similar to the one described above, although it requires even more attention when preparing for registration. The application fee is fixed and amounts to 300 PLN.

What does industrial design protection look like?

The main difference that distinguishes an industrial design from a trademark is that the design must be new and have an individual character. A design is considered new if its creator or legal successor makes it public no more than twelve months before the application date (!).

As a result, the best option after designing a pattern is to make an application to the Patent Office. Only after fulfilling this formality is it worth introducing it to the market. Then we practically eliminate the risk of the design being disclosed by a third party and the expiration of the applicable deadline.

It is also significant that in the matter of industrial designs, we will encounter numerous grounds that prevent its registration. Particularly helpful in this regard will be Art. 129 p. 1 of the Industrial Property Law Act, concerning trademarks.

Elements absolutely preventing the registration of an industrial design are:

  • Using the design contrary to public order or good morals;
  • Presence of elements of symbolic, religious, patriotic, cultural value, offending religious or patriotic feelings or national tradition;
  • Presence of symbols of the Republic of Poland, as well as other foreign countries, in particular the emblem, colors, or anthem;
  • A designation adopted for use in trade – for example, a quality mark, safety mark, or legalization mark.

Protection of a trademark and industrial design can extend beyond the borders of Poland. This is possible thanks to concluded international agreements.

How to protect a product label? Brand protection methods

International trademark protection

If we want to register a trademark within the European Union, we must carry out the procedure before the EU Intellectual Property Office. This is a great option for entrepreneurs who conduct business in other European Union countries, because thanks to this form of registration, they gain protection in each of the 28 member states.

The application can be made in person, traditionally, or electronically. In the case of a traditional application, the fee is 1000 euros, and for an electronic one – 850 euros. The duration of protection from registration is 10 years with the possibility of extending it indefinitely (of course, provided that subsequent fees are paid on time).

Two modes of application are available: Fast Track and the standard mode. The accelerated mode speeds up the case, thanks to which the publication time of the decision is halved. However, to use Fast Track, two conditions must be met:

1. The goods and services to which the mark refers must be selected from the database of terms that have been accepted by the European Union office – the harmonized database contains over 70,000 terms from which users can choose the goods and services they want to cover with protection. The list is very precise and you can find the most popular items there (wood, rods, glue, coffee drinks, marketing services, legal services, etc.), as well as check it before registering the mark in the list of services and goods creator made available on the EU Intellectual Property Office website.

2. The fee for the mark must be paid in advance.

In the standard mode, we gain more freedom regarding the submitted applications. We can indicate our own list of goods and services, register a collective trademark, or convert it into an international mark. Forms and applications necessary for the EU procedure can be found on the EU office website.

Apart from the EU process, thanks to the Madrid Agreement, Polish entrepreneurs can use international trademark registration. For this purpose, you must first register the mark in the country of origin. The fee for the international registration application is an additional 600 PLN.

Importantly, natural and legal persons from Poland must deliver the application to the International Bureau in Geneva. Therefore, the fee must be collected in Swiss francs, and the application should be prepared in English or French.

International industrial design protection

An industrial design can also be protected based on EU Regulation (EC) No 6/2002 of December 12, 2001. According to its content, only the following are protected:

  • The appearance of the product, i.e., its shape, form, motif, colors, or materials;
  • Architecture and arrangement of given spaces;
  • A design used to ensure the multiple folding or connecting of products in a modular system.

The application is made directly at the EU office or through the Polish Patent Office. The design in the territory of the community is protected for 5 years and can be extended four times (i.e., for a maximum of 25 years).

In the case of international protection, we act based on the Geneva Act of the Hague Agreement adopted on July 2, 1999. The application is made at the international bureau in Geneva or through the Polish Patent Office. In this variant, the maximum protection time is also 25 years, and the application itself must be created in English or French. The basic fee is 397 CHF.

Conclusions

Issues related to brand legal protection can be complicated. Nevertheless, there is no doubt that company identification – especially in today’s times – is extremely important. The protection right is a huge help and facilitation for entities operating on the market. For this reason, it is worth using the available tools and eliminating situations that can be easily avoided thanks to the registration of a trademark or industrial design.