What is a contractual penalty and how to apply it correctly?

What is a contractual penalty and how to apply it correctly?

Regulating the rights and obligations of the parties is one of the most important issues in any civil law contract. It must be done in such a way as to leave no room for free interpretation between the parties. As long as the entities act in accordance with the adopted rules, the cooperation proceeds successfully. However, contracts are created “for times of war, not peace,” so it is better to remember to secure your interests. Among the most commonly used solutions in this regard are contractual penalties. What are they and how to use them effectively?

Contractual penalty – definition and functions

Regulations regarding contractual penalties can be found in Article 483, paragraph 1 of the Civil Code, according to which: It may be stipulated in a contract that the repair of damage resulting from non-performance or improper performance of a non-monetary obligation shall be effected by the payment of a specified sum (contractual penalty).

It is accepted that a contractual penalty is an additional stipulation in the content of a contract, which is classified as so-called accidentalia negotii (essential elements of the contract). This means that the general principles of this mechanism have been prepared by the legislator, but it is up to the parties to the contract to clarify its scope and amount. Furthermore, they can also precisely determine for which forms of non-performance or improper performance the contractual penalty will be applied.

What functions does a contractual penalty serve? First of all:

  • it constitutes a lump-sum compensation, the payment of which the creditor may demand in the event of non-performance or improper performance of a non-monetary obligation by the debtor,
  • it motivates the debtor to properly perform the obligations resulting from the contract,
  • it is a kind of penalty for failing to fulfill contractual obligations.

When is it worth stipulating a contractual penalty? Actually, in any case where it would be difficult to prove the amount of damage during the process, e.g., when we are trying to claim compensation for a breach of a non-compete clause or failure to deliver construction materials on time. In such cases, a precise calculation of the amount of damage would be practically impossible. And this, in turn, causes the process to drag on for many months and simultaneously increases the risk of losing.

However, a proper stipulation of a contractual penalty eliminates the need to prove the prerequisites for contractual liability. It is enough for the creditor to prove only the fact of the breach of the contractual stipulation. This also facilitates the calculation of the amount of compensation, as the contractual penalty is usually calculated in a pre-indicated amount or unit-based for each day of delay.

What must be remembered when formulating a contractual penalty? Mainly that you cannot calculate a penalty in this way indefinitely, i.e., without indicating an upper limit or the time for which it can be calculated. Such a provision constitutes a violation of the principles of social coexistence regarding the concept of a “specified sum of money” (Article 483 of the Civil Code) and may be considered absolutely void.

As an example, it is sufficient to point to the judgment of the Supreme Court of October 22, 2015, file ref. no. IV CSK 687/14, in which it was recognized that the lack of specifying the maximum amount of the contractual penalty or the period of its calculation results in the creation of a perpetual obligation, which contradicts the principle of freedom of contract and, as a result, is absolutely void.

Reduction of a contractual penalty

As a rule, the contractual penalty is due to the creditor in the stipulated amount. The circumstances accompanying the sending of a payment demand or the amount of damage incurred do not matter. Nevertheless, the law allows for the possibility of so-called reduction of a contractual penalty based on Article 484, paragraph 2 of the Civil Code, if:

  • the obligation has been performed in a significant part,
  • the contractual penalty is grossly excessive.

We will not find a precise answer in the regulations to the question of when a reduction is possible. For this reason, we refer to case law and the views of legal doctrine, e.g., a debtor may demand a reduction of a contractual penalty if the parties have settled the contract at 2/3 of its value (in accordance with the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Krakow of June 29, 2020, file ref. no. I Aca 451/20).

The case law of the Supreme Court accepts that a reduction of a contractual penalty is permissible when, within the framework of the contract’s implementation, the creditor’s interest has been satisfied to a significant extent. Therefore, such a reduction of the penalty will not be possible in the case of a debtor who has made only minimal efforts to perform the contract.

Regarding the disproportion of the penalty, the doctrine indicates that for a debtor to be able to demand a reduction, it must be so egregious that it would be noticeable to an objective observer. Depending on the lines of case law, courts assess the amount of the contractual penalty, taking into account:

  • the ratio of the contractual penalty to the value of the entire performance,
  • the ratio of the contractual penalty to the breached interest of the creditor,
  • the ratio of the contractual penalty to the damage incurred by the creditor.

It must be remembered that the court will consider the application of a reduction of the penalty only upon a plea raised by the debtor themselves (and not ex officio).

In the matter of reducing a contractual penalty, stipulations included in a non-compete agreement are also significant. The amount of such sanctions must have a real connection with the amount of the employee’s remuneration and the actual scope of their financial liability. Some court rulings even contain an indication of the maximum permissible amount of this type of contractual penalty (e.g., the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Poznan of January 1, 2006, file ref. no. III APa 37/06, set it at ten times the compensation).

What is a contractual penalty and how to apply it correctly?Contractual penalty vs. compensation

In principle, a contractual penalty should replace compensation. Unfortunately, it also acts as a “double-edged sword,” as one that is too high exposes the debtor to greater losses, while one that is too low may result in the creditor not obtaining full repair of the damage. The question therefore arises: how to balance the interests of both parties to the contract?

The answer is simple: by applying the solution included in Article 484, paragraph 1 of the Civil Code in fine. According to the provision: a claim for compensation exceeding the amount of the stipulated penalty is not permissible, unless the parties have decided otherwise. The use of this mechanism consists of including in the clause providing for a contractual penalty a stipulation according to which the parties – or one of them – will have the possibility of claiming compensation exceeding the amount of the stipulated contractual penalty. As a result, one can easily get rid of the barrier created by a penalty stipulated even as a single sum of money.

For many years, it was also a contentious issue whether, to demand payment of a contractual penalty by the debtor, one must prove damage to the creditor’s assets. Two trends have developed in case law:

  1. the first assumes that since a contractual penalty is a surrogate for compensation, the appearance of damage is necessary to justify the creditor’s claim for the contractual penalty (e.g., the judgment of the Court of Appeal in Katowice of March 20, 2013, file ref. no. I ACa 132/13),
  2. the second makes the payment of the contractual penalty independent of the occurrence of damage. Such a position was taken by the Supreme Court in a resolution of seven judges of November 6, 2003, file ref. no. III CZP 61/03. The resolution has the force of a legal principle.

When can a contractual penalty not be stipulated?

One of the more frequent problems that occur in the context of a construction works contract or a supply contract is withdrawal from the contract due to non-performance of a monetary obligation. What to do in a situation where the contract obliges the debtor to pay penalties after the creditor has exercised the right to withdraw from the contract for reasons occurring on the debtor’s side, when one of the prerequisites allowing for the exercise of the right to withdraw is a delay in the payment of remuneration by the debtor?

It might seem that in such a case, the parties have the right to stipulate a contractual penalty, as it concerns the right to withdraw from the contract for various reasons – including non-monetary ones. It turns out, however, that the case law of the courts is not unanimous here. It has been accepted that the concept of an obligation should be understood very broadly.

A monetary obligation cannot be even remotely linked to the stipulation of a contractual penalty. In another situation, we risk a declaration of invalidity of such a provision. Nevertheless, some courts allow the discussed construction, provided that the failure to perform the monetary obligation by one of the parties does not constitute the sole prerequisite for claiming the contractual penalty (e.g., the judgment of the Supreme Court of February 7, 2007, file ref. no. III CSK 288/06).

So how to effectively secure your interests? One of the methods used in construction works contracts is the stipulation of a payment guarantee consisting of the investor paying a designated sum of money in the event of non-performance or improper performance of contractual obligations (monetary or non-monetary). The guarantee can take the form of:

  • a bank guarantee,
  • an insurance guarantee,
  • a bank letter of credit,
  • a bank surety.

If we are not sure how to construct contractual safeguards to ensure full security, it is best to contact a law firm with experience in serving companies in the construction and investment sector.

In addition, it is accepted that one cannot simultaneously stipulate and accumulate contractual penalties for non-performance and improper performance of the same obligation. According to the position of the courts, one cannot simultaneously fail to perform an obligation and perform it in an incorrect manner. This is an internally contradictory stipulation, which is discussed, among others, in the resolution of the Supreme Court of July 18, 2012, file ref. no. III CZP 39/12.

Examples of contractual penalties

The wording of a contractual penalty clause should be adapted to the type of contract being concluded and the total value of the parties’ performances. The basis for properly formulating the provision is mainly the rights and obligations of the contractors, which must be precisely described to avoid inaccuracies and ambiguities when claiming lump-sum compensation. Below we present examples of stipulating a contractual penalty in a contract:

  1. The parties agree that in the event of a delay in handing over the Work, the Ordering Party may claim payment of a contractual penalty in the amount of 1% of the value of the work for each day of delay.
  2. The contractual penalty may not exceed a total of 10,000 PLN.
  3. The stipulated contractual penalty does not exclude the possibility of claiming compensation exceeding the amount of the stipulated contractual penalty.
  1. The Supplier shall pay the Ordering Party a contractual penalty in the amount of 2% of the order for each day of delay in delivering the goods.
  2. The contractual penalty may not exceed the equivalent of the value of the goods covered by the order.
  3. The Ordering Party may claim compensation exceeding the amount of the stipulated contractual penalty.

What is a contractual penalty and how to apply it correctly?Contractual penalty as a tax-deductible cost?

Many entrepreneurs forced to pay a contractual penalty wonder if they can include it in tax-deductible costs. Tax authorities most often answer that they cannot, but the problem is much more complicated.

The answers to these questions can be found in Articles 15(1) and 16(1)(22) of the Corporate Income Tax Act (CIT Act). According to Article 15(1) of the aforementioned Act, a tax-deductible cost is a cost incurred in order to achieve revenues from a source of revenue or in order to preserve or secure the source of revenue – excluding costs listed in Article 16(1) of the CIT Act.

In addition, Article 16(1)(22) states that contractual penalties and compensation for the following are not considered tax-deductible costs:

  • defects in delivered goods, performed works, and services,
  • delay in delivering goods free of defects,
  • delay in removing defects in goods or performed works and services.

Therefore, if there is a closed list in the Act, there is no basis to extend the interpretation of the discussed provision to other forms of non-performance or improper performance of an obligation. Such a position was found, among others, in the judgment of the Provincial Administrative Court in Gliwice of July 2, 2020, file ref. no. I SA/Gl 1348/19.

Conclusions – contractual penalty in a contract

Stipulating a contractual penalty is a very useful tool for claiming compensation. Properly formulated contractual provisions protect the interests of the creditor while simultaneously motivating the debtor to act in a timely manner and in accordance with the concluded contract. Although the provisions of the Civil Code introducing the contractual penalty are not complicated, their implementation into a contract requires knowledge of the specifics of the industry and current case law and the positions of legal doctrine. For this reason, it is best to commission the design of the contract content to experienced, trusted lawyers.