
Since the outbreak of the war in Ukraine, the business climate index in the transport and construction sectors has fallen significantly. Employers in companies where staff shortages caused by the war have become very noticeable are thinking about the future with great anxiety. Janusz Mincewicz talks to Magda Dąbrowska, Vice President of the Progres Group.
Janusz Mincewicz: There are already over 2 million refugees from Ukraine in Poland, and there is also an aid act, a simplified procedure legalizing residence and work in Poland. How has such a number of Ukrainians affected the Polish labor market?
Magda Dąbrowska: A month after Russia’s attack on Ukraine, our labor market seems unrecognizable. The profile of candidates arriving in Poland has changed, as have their expectations regarding employment and non-wage benefits. Companies have started the process of recruiting Ukrainians fleeing the war and modernizing positions, and some are already “scheming” on how to make money from the special act, while in the industry, the general current business climate index fell by 6.7 points in March.
J.M.: Over 10 percent of Ukrainians have already received a PESEL number enabling them to start work in Poland. When will they appear on the labor market?
M.D.: People fleeing the war who are thinking about work after some time start looking for it after 3 weeks of staying in Poland. Ukrainians are looking for a job in a package with accommodation for them and their family – 1 job requires 4 sleeping places. According to data from the Progres Group, Ukrainians who fled to Poland before the war and are starting to think about work need about 3 weeks to acclimatize and start looking for employment. Dishonest employers are starting to use the special act to gain as much as possible. The war has worsened the mood of employers, many of whom are wondering what to do next.
J.M.: Why, since Ukrainians were readily employed in Poland?
M.D.: According to data from the Ministry of Labor and Social Policy, in 2021, work permits in Poland were granted to 504,172 foreigners. Almost 65 percent of this group (325,213) were Ukrainians. This year, the number of employees from Ukraine will increase significantly; many of them arrived in Poland after the outbreak of the war and are already looking for employment in our country. Currently, the willingness to take it up is declared mainly by women, who are increasingly asking not only about remuneration but also about non-wage issues. Before the outbreak of the war, foreigners expected the employer to provide them with accommodation or free transport to work. Currently, it is crucial not only to have free accommodation but also its standard, because many candidates are mothers with children who care about housing conditions that meet the needs of the youngest.
J.M.: How much has the number of Ukrainians willing to take up work in Poland increased since the outbreak of the war?
M.D.: Within a month, the number of job candidates from Ukraine has increased fivefold. Along with them, the demand for family accommodation has increased. Before the war, employers took such needs into account, primarily in the case of couples coming to our country. Currently, many of them, when planning employment and accommodation, also take into account children or grandparents who often accompany job candidates. Our data shows that at the beginning of the year, there were 10 sleeping places for every 10 employees hired. Currently, there are 40 such places because we must also provide accommodation for the families of Ukrainians. As a result, quarters where only employees used to live have changed their character into family places of stay. Many Ukrainians can count on the support of employers, but they must be vigilant because not everyone has good intentions, and a seemingly attractive job offer may bring them more harm than good.
J.M.: Ukrainians must have a PESEL number to take up work in Poland.
M.D.: From March 16 to 31, 2022, i.e., after the entry into force of the special act on assistance to citizens of Ukraine in connection with the armed conflict on the territory of that state, Ukrainians have already been granted almost 500,000 PESEL numbers. This means that over 20 percent of those fleeing the war can start legal work in accordance with applicable regulations. The act, which many employers were waiting for, makes it easier to employ our eastern neighbors. However, there are already signals that some of the provisions may be misinterpreted or constitute a loophole for abuse by dishonest intermediaries.
J.M.: Why?
M.D.: Because the current regulations, prepared three weeks after the outbreak of the war, were very necessary, but already a few days after they came into force, we can clearly see which issues need to be clarified. Currently, the employer has 14 days to notify the office that a Ukrainian citizen has started working for them, but they do not have to inform about its termination. This simplification, unfortunately, can lead to chaos and abuse, because considering the very large number of Ukrainians and the pace of flow of official information, it will be difficult to figure out where a given person actually works and whether they are still in Poland. In official statistics, there will be a “ghost” employee effect. This is a loophole for dishonest intermediaries who are already recruiting Ukrainians for work and will certainly take advantage of the current turmoil. I am also afraid that some employers hiring unskilled workers will be guided by the desire for apparent profit. For this reason, they will start firing current staff and hiring Ukrainians fleeing the war in their place, because according to the current act, the cost of employing them is lower than that of a person not covered by the special act. Expenses for, among other things, a declaration of entrusting work or other documents necessary for the legal employment of foreigners are eliminated.
J.M.: Where do these concerns come from?
M.D.: The Act of March 12, 2022, on assistance to citizens of Ukraine in connection with the armed conflict on the territory of that state, does not include Ukrainians who are looking for shelter in Poland but did not arrive in our country directly from their homeland. Such people who are fleeing the war or cannot return to their home country are not covered by the special act, even though the reason for their stay in Poland is the war ongoing in Ukraine. Unfortunately, not every employer is familiar with the meanders of the current law and does not take into account where a given person crossed the border.
J.M.: Is the subsidy for accommodation and food for those Poles who accept Ukrainians a good solution?
M.D.: Despite the possibility of obtaining a subsidy for accommodation and food provided to a refugee, Poles have not yet started to submit applications for covering these costs on a mass scale. Moreover, in many offices, this is not yet possible because organizational work is underway to enable the efficient receipt and processing of applications and the payment of benefits. Anyone who decides to take this step can apply for PLN 2,400. This is the maximum amount that can be received for providing accommodation and food to one refugee for 60 days. The regulations allow for the extension of this period, but the consent of the voivode will be needed. The municipality has a month to process the application. Whether the benefit is granted or paid may depend on the verification of food and accommodation conditions.
J.M.: What will happen next, after the 60 “statutory” days?
M.D.: The challenge today is to establish a plan for the coming months that will take into account many variables and the financial aspect. We do not know when the war will end. Even if this date is close, a large part of Ukrainians will not return to their homeland immediately. Therefore, it must be taken into account that they will have to receive salaries that will allow them, among other things, to rent an apartment and support their loved ones if the employer does not take into account long-term accommodation for entire families. Moreover, many companies that are currently helping have a specific budget for this help, and their resources may soon be exhausted. When, in addition, the help of the state and citizens ends or decreases, many Ukrainians may leave Poland very quickly because they will be looking for better living conditions or will return to their homeland because they are already declaring that they want to do so. Employers including this group in their staffing plans should take into account that some of these people will not stay with them for long. Organizations or institutions that adapt their profile only to Ukrainians fleeing the war and are not flexible enough to make a re-modification if necessary and if the number of Ukrainians in Poland decreases must also be vigilant.
J.M.: So a long-term action plan is needed.
M.D.: A long-term action plan is absolutely necessary and it is already necessary to work on it, because the mood among supervisors a month after the outbreak of the war is not the best. The business climate is deteriorating, among other things, in the industry that employs mainly men and is struggling with staff shortages. The general current business climate index – in this sector of the economy – was -16.7 points in March, which means a decrease of 6.7 points in a month. Employers from the transport and construction industries, whose staff shortages caused by the war are very noticeable, are also looking at the future critically. According to the Central Statistical Office (GUS), in transport, the business climate index fell in March from -12.7 points to -28.3 points, and in construction from -19.3 points to -26.5 points.








