The war in Ukraine through the eyes of experts

The war in Ukraine through the eyes of experts

The situation in Ukraine is becoming more dramatic by the day. The whole world is following the course of events with concern. Today, we are focusing our attention primarily on the humanitarian crisis and its unpredictable consequences, on finding ways to solve supply problems, and on organizing aid for those affected. Television stations and social media are broadcasting many valuable and substantive statements from military experts, politicians, economists, and financiers these days. Bearing in mind the mission of our portal, which is to convey reliable information about a small but very important slice of reality, which is logistics, we asked several experts who have been dealing directly with logistics issues for many years to comment.

Reading these comments should make us realize how important a role logistics has to play – not only in times of peace, prosperity, and the pursuit of well-being, but also – and perhaps above all – in situations where human life is at risk. Our interlocutors consider what alternative solutions can be planned to ensure the continuity of supplies to all places where people live who want to live and enjoy life.

The war in Ukraine through the eyes of expertsDr. Eng. Aleksander Niemczyk, Deputy Chairman of the Board of the Polish Logistics Association

I will draw attention to three aspects that Russia’s aggression against Ukraine will have a very large impact on – now or in the near future.
The massive growth of online sales is linked to the flow of goods along the New Silk Road from China to Poland or through Poland. The stream of goods will likely be redirected via the southern route through Turkey to bypass Russia and Ukraine. Sanctions related to the suspension of the delivery of many goods from the European Union to Russia will create a need to solve the problem of storing them until the sanctions are lifted or other buyers for these goods are found.
I am deeply convinced that the steadfast stance of the defenders in Ukraine will lead to a rapid withdrawal of the aggressor’s troops. However, I consider a return to the previous configuration of supply networks impossible. Both the pandemic and the current war point to the need to manufacture goods much closer to the end customers. But that is a separate topic and a challenge for the near future.

eksperci logistyki ukraina002Damian Kołata, Head of Industrial & Logistics PL/Head of E-Commerce CEE Cushman & Wakefield

The war conflict should not have a very negative impact on traditional global supply chains. The vast majority of goods are still transported by sea routes, and these run far from the arena of military operations.
However, we must remember that over time, the situation with subcontractors located in Ukraine and Russia will generate an increasing problem. These markets still do not constitute a hub of component suppliers, nevertheless, companies that have placed production plants in our eastern neighbor, or have outsourced certain processes there, will have to find alternative suppliers or increase production capacity in plants outside Ukraine. This situation also applies to several Polish companies (e.g., Cersanit, Śnieżka, Plast Box, Relpol, Wawel, Black Red White, Barlinek, or TZMO S.A.). Grain transport will also be strained – it is worth remembering that Ukraine accounts for 12% of global wheat exports, as well as 16% of corn production.
It is also worth keeping in mind potential problems with the flow of other raw materials, including gas and crude oil. We also do not know how the war will affect rail transport, for example, within the framework of the New Silk Road initiative. Theoretically, it does not run through the territory of Ukraine, however, the involvement of Russia and Belarus and the related sanctions may cause some turmoil with the final section of the route on the eastern side. Transport would have to be redirected through Tallinn and Riga. Once again, however, it is worth emphasizing that rail transport from China accounts for only a few percent of trade with Europe.
The war conflict will certainly also have an impact on the landscape of warehouse logistics. Cushman & Wakefield is already receiving inquiries about warehouse space related to the desire to mitigate risk and diversify storage, or even the direct necessity of launching operations outside Ukraine – due to the difficult-to-estimate duration of these cruel actions across our eastern border.

eksperci logistyki ukraina004Prof. Marek Grzybowski, President of the Baltic Maritime and Space Cluster

Russian aggression against Ukraine, the situation in the Black Sea, and the restrictions introduced by states have a direct and indirect impact on maritime business.
The Black Sea – all the way to the Bosphorus and the Dardanelles – has become a place of armed conflict and a zone of particular danger. Many shipowners are therefore resigning from entering Black Sea ports, and this significantly disrupts supply chains in this region. Disruptions in maritime logistics chains may also appear as a result of cyberattacks on communication networks in ports, on ship operators, and freight forwarders.
Shipowners who decide to direct a ship to this region or are forced to plan a voyage to one of the Black Sea ports must reckon with a significant increase in insurance rates. Freight rates and earnings of ships operating in the Black Sea have also jumped sharply. For example, the average earnings of smaller Aframax tankers trading in the Black Sea jumped to over 100,000 USD per day of sailing (on Thursday), while on Monday the daily earnings reached 8,000 USD – one operator reported. Due to restrictions on the purchase of Russian oil and gas, oil and gas prices on the spot market will also rise. Therefore, ship bunkering prices will rise, because the prices of Russian bunker were lower than the prices of bunker in the EU and Asia.
Many oil and gas suppliers have reported that they cannot increase supplies immediately. A barrel of West Texas Intermediate oil for April delivery costs 96.65 USD on NYMEX in New York, which is 5.52% more than 3 days ago and 30% more than December 1, 2021. Brent oil on the ICE in London for April delivery is valued at 102.50 USD per barrel, 4.67% more than 3 days ago and 35% more than December 1, 2021. Russian oil prices have also risen. Ural already costs over 100 USD per barrel, while on February 25 this year it cost 91.41 USD per barrel, and on December 1 last year 71.18 USD per barrel. Thus, the restrictions will not affect Russian oil and gas trade, the prices of which are also rising accordingly.

eksperci logistyki ukraina001Dr. Eng. Adam Koliński, Rector of the College of Logistics

The current state of war at our eastern neighbor’s can indeed affect the functioning of global supply chains in various ways. If, for example, we focus on the New Silk Road, then at the moment, two rail transport options – transport through Belarus and transport through Ukraine – have been blocked. However, supply chains do not tolerate a vacuum; we are perfectly aware that other transport corridors can be used that will bypass the territory threatened by war. Depending on which of the alternative options we choose, Poland’s role as a logistics operator for transport from Asia also changes; for corridors running through Hungary and Slovakia, our role is smaller, although still significant.
Complete elimination should be expected if Europe-Asia transport relies on the Turkish direction. Similarly, in the case where the emphasis on land/rail transport, which China currently cares about, loses its importance – a concentration on maritime transport, despite its drawbacks, also has serious advantages from the perspective of global supply chains.
Regardless of the alternatives that are being created for the current situation, one thing is certain: we can expect delays in deliveries, which the end customer may not notice at all in the near future, but only in the not-too-distant future. At the moment – despite disruptions in supplies – available stocks are being used, which, however, will quickly run out. I would not predict a break in supply chains, but disrupting their continuity is highly probable.

eksperci logistyki ukraina005Mateusz Boruta, Managing Director of ECR Poland

In the war in Ukraine, the fate of people is obviously in the foreground – both in free Ukraine and Ukrainians living in Poland – our neighbors, employees, associates, colleagues, or partners.
When considering the impact of the war on the functioning of supply chains, the human aspect is therefore crucial. Many people from Ukraine work directly in Polish logistics, trade, or production plants – and we appeal for their support, respect for their choices, and the need to take care of the safety of themselves and their loved ones.
Looking at other aspects – this perspective is broadening every day. I think that disruptions in the availability of liquid fuels will not have long-term effects, but the increase in raw material prices – primarily energy and agricultural – may be felt for much longer. I do not know how long the direct threat caused by military actions will last; we also do not yet have a full picture of the sanctions and their negative impact on European economies. The situation is developing, and as part of the ECR Poland crisis staff, we are monitoring it on an ongoing basis, while simultaneously exchanging experiences and knowledge to, as far as possible and in a spirit of responsibility, also take care of the continuity of supply chains in Poland.