Has your data been exposed online? Check what you can do about it

Has your data been exposed online? Check what you can do about it

Each of us can become a victim of a data leak or theft. Situations where someone impersonates another person or unlawfully uses their image are being reported more and more frequently. Exposure to this type of threat results both from the deliberate actions of hackers and from a lack of sufficient care on the part of those responsible for data protection. Sometimes it is also the result of simple human malice. What should you do when such a situation occurs? What options does the law provide us with?

When do we talk about a personal data breach?
A personal data breach results in personal and, quite often, material damage. If our good name is tarnished, it can lead to, for example, the loss of clients and the image we have built. Therefore, one must be aware that if data is made public online, we can use specific legal tools.

According to Regulation 2016/679 of April 27, 2016, on the protection of natural persons with regard to the processing of personal data and on the free movement of such data (referred to as GDPR), a personal data breach constitutes a security breach leading to the accidental or unlawful destruction, modification, unauthorized disclosure, loss, or unauthorized access to personal data.

  • Data destruction is equivalent to its annihilation, as a result of which it ceases to exist and can no longer be used.
  • Data loss can be associated, for example, with losing access to it.
  • Modification is a violation of data integrity.
  • Unauthorized disclosure and unauthorized access to data mean, for example, disclosing or making data available to recipients who are not authorized to receive or access it.

A breach in this form does not have to be intentional. We understand personal data as any information that relates to an identified or identifiable living natural person. This will therefore include a name, surname, PESEL number, medical records, ID card number, etc., as well as a photo or image that allows for the identification of a given person.

When your data is disclosed, you can use one of two paths provided by the GDPR and the Personal Data Protection Act. One is administrative, the other is judicial. They differ in terms of the process and the goals that can be achieved through them.

Has your data been exposed online? Check what you can do about it

File a complaint with the President of the Personal Data Protection Office
The first option is to file a complaint with the President of the Personal Data Protection Office (UODO). As part of such proceedings, it can be determined whether there has been a violation of personal data protection regulations. If so, further actions are then determined that should be taken to remove the violations and restore compliance with the law.

The proceeding itself is administrative in nature, and its conclusion is the issuance of a decision. The advantage of such a solution is mainly the lack of fees for filing a complaint. The only expense may be a potential fee for a power of attorney. The complaint itself should contain elements appropriate for an application in administrative proceedings.

In the decision, the President of the UODO may order the restoration of a state compliant with the law. They will issue it if the violation still exists on the day the decision is issued. However, if the irregularities are removed during the proceedings, it will become moot and will be discontinued.

Nevertheless, even when the irregularities are removed, the President of the UODO may impose a financial penalty for violating personal data protection regulations. In addition, they have instruments that ensure the execution of the decision by the entity that committed the violation of data protection regulations. These are enforcement measures used to compel the fulfillment of an obligation, as indicated in the Act on Enforcement Proceedings in Administration.

Usually, a complaint is processed within one month, but when a large number of cases are received at the same time, it is possible that the issuance of a decision will be extended to several months. When the President of the UODO does not settle the case on time, they notify both parties and simultaneously provide them with information about the status of the case and the actions taken during its course.

Furthermore, proceedings before the President of the UODO are single-instance, and one cannot appeal the decision, but only challenge it before the Provincial Administrative Court.

Start proceedings for damages or compensation
Although a complaint to the President of the UODO is practically free and convenient, it only allows for repairing a state that is inconsistent with the law, i.e., removing the violation of personal data protection regulations. Therefore, it does not contribute to compensating for material or non-material damage.

A court can decide on the violation and compensation. Currently, there are two possible bases for obtaining compensation through the courts:

  • According to Article 82 of the GDPR, any person who has suffered material or non-material damage as a result of an infringement of this Regulation shall have the right to receive compensation from the controller or processor for the damage suffered. A controller is an authority, organizational unit, entity, or person deciding on the purposes and means of processing personal data. A processor is a person who processes data on behalf of the controller.
  • The second basis for obtaining compensation is Article 24 of the Civil Code: anyone whose personal rights are threatened by another person’s actions may demand that these actions cease, unless they are not unlawful. In the case of this provision, one can also speak of both material and non-material damage.

Each of these bases for filing a lawsuit is separate and they cannot be combined.

Of course, as a result of a lawsuit, we incur higher costs than in the case of a complaint to the President of the UODO. It is subject to a fixed fee of 600 PLN. The lawsuit itself can be filed before the court competent for the registered office of the controller or processor, or before the court competent for the place of permanent residence of the data subject. The case will be heard by a regional court.

Importantly, the burden of proof in the case of filing a complaint in connection with Article 82 of the GDPR shifts to the defendant. Therefore, the controller or data processor must prove that the violation of the regulations is not the result of their fault. As a result, this significantly strengthens the plaintiff’s procedural position.

As for the GDPR provisions, it is not entirely clear whether the compensation itself must take a monetary form. It is therefore not excluded that it will be possible to apply for other forms of reparation recognized by Polish civil law.

Has your data been exposed online? Check what you can do about itA complaint to the President of the UODO vs. court proceedings. Which solution is better?
The provisions of the Personal Data Protection Act specify the relationship between both procedures. By filing a lawsuit, you still have the option of filing a complaint with the President of the UODO and vice versa. If both proceedings are conducted in parallel, the court and the President of the UODO must exchange information regarding ongoing or completed proceedings related to the same violation.

However, Article 95 of the UODO Act states that the court is obliged to suspend proceedings if a case regarding the same violation has already been initiated before the President of the UODO (because they are the body specialized in handling such cases). This may result in a longer wait for a civil court verdict, as it is suspended not only for the duration of the administrative proceedings in the first instance but also for any potential administrative-court proceedings. The proceedings will be resumed only after a final judgment is issued.

More importantly, the civil court will be bound by the decision of the President of the UODO in which a violation of the regulations is found (Article 97 of the UODO Act). Therefore, obtaining such a decision can be beneficial for us – this way, it will be easier to obtain compensation (!).

At the same time, the court will not be bound by the decision of the President of the UODO if they do not find a violation of the regulations. In that case, the court may take a different position and conclude that the violation did, in fact, occur.

Conclusions. What to do when your data is exposed online?
You can demand only the removal of the data violation or additionally require compensation for the damage suffered. Everything depends on your individual decision. If you want to get rid of the problem as quickly as possible, choose only one form of removing the violation. Nevertheless, remember that even if your complaint or lawsuit is rejected, you can still stand up for your rights by sending a report to the President of the UODO.