The warehouse of the future – are we facing full automation?

Are warehouses doomed to automation? What trends currently dominate the logistics industry? Will labor shortages force changes in work organization?

Karol FrankowskiKarol Frankowski, Leasing Manager, Hines Polska Sp. z o.o.: The warehouse, production, and logistics real estate sector in Poland was developing very dynamically even before the pandemic. However, it was 2020 that initiated a unique period for the industry in many respects, partly due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Restrictions and lockdowns, accompanied by the suspension of sales in physical stores, fueled e-commerce, and it was then that record demand for space from tenants was recorded.

Last year, the demand for warehouse space among tenants amounted to approx. 5.2 million sq m. The first half of 2021, according to AXI IMMO data, ended with a result of 3.3 million sq m, which is a 40% year-on-year increase. Nearly 2.1 million sq m of new production and warehouse halls were completed, which is 23.5% less than in 2019, due to tightened bank lending rules. This makes the investment market in the warehouse and production sector currently much more attractive for investment funds with large capital, which are primarily interested in commercial real estate within the five largest national logistics regions.

Warehouse location and labor availability
Poland’s location remains key in terms of controlling strategic flows in Europe and, together with Romania, constitutes an important area between the Baltic and the Black Sea. Particularly important in this context is southwestern Poland, which offers competitive rental rates for warehouse and production halls and relatively cheap labor. Warehouses in this region often act as a buffer, serving neighboring countries or even supply chains between the Black Sea and Western Europe. As for domestic logistics, the most important region is Central Poland, providing services mainly for e-commerce companies or their branches that operate primarily on the domestic market.

Due to growing e-commerce sales and the increasing demand among tenants to locate production halls near sales markets, companies are facing an increasing challenge in finding employees near new investments. Previously, they operated according to the “just in time” principle and emphasized delivery at the right time. The pandemic has made the “just in case” work model dominant, which consists of preparing production and the supply chain so that they are properly secured and respond to current customer demand.

The right location is still the most important factor. However, the criteria for its selection are changing. Tenants are paying attention to plots further away from Poland’s western border, but with better access to employees and lower employment costs. The situation on the labor market partly increases the need for automation, which can not only speed up the operational activities of a warehouse or production hall but also ensure greater stability. Production and warehousing are then not so dependent on the human factor – employee migration and rising wages, which can be twice as high near the western border as in the central part of Poland. This is due to the much higher level of wages in Germany compared to earnings in our country. Furthermore, the need for automation is also increased by the seasonality of certain operational activities, e.g., in the logistics industry. With the right balance between human labor and automation, logisticians can maintain the efficiency of customer service without having to look for employees who are usually reluctant to take on seasonal work.

The labor market forces automation
The UK is currently struggling with a labor shortage that may force the implementation of full automation in the industry. After Brexit, there is a shortage of 100,000 heavy goods vehicle drivers, and forecasts suggest the problem will continue to worsen. Currently, 47% of active professional carriers in the United Kingdom are people over 50 years of age. In this case, the solution to the labor crisis may be the use of autonomous vehicles. However, the lack of appropriate road infrastructure for the exclusive use of autonomous vehicles creates a dilemma: if the traffic of autonomous and passenger cars were combined, it would be difficult to indicate who is responsible for a potential accident caused by an autonomous vehicle. On the other hand, studies conducted around the world prove that autonomous vehicles can affect road safety by ensuring smooth driving and reducing the risk of collisions through systems that recognize threats. To prevent road accidents involving autonomous cars and those driven by humans, new infrastructure solutions could be implemented, such as designating a lane only for autonomous vehicles. Despite the solutions considered by the expert community, I am convinced that “flesh and blood” employees will still be needed in the industry.

The shortage in the labor market can be reduced by modifying the driver’s role, such as a hybrid solution that provides for the inclusion of partially autonomous vehicles in traffic, driven by a human in some parts of the route – e.g., during loading and unloading and when entering or leaving a logistics park. Airplanes currently operate on a similar principle. During the flight, pilots use automatic steering most of the time, if weather conditions, among other things, allow them to do so. It is worth noting, however, that the machine is always supervised by one of them, and the distance between planes is greater than between vehicles moving on roads.

Despite ideas for automating many processes, the logistics industry should consider how to make the work of, for example, a tractor-trailer driver more attractive so that young people also want to take it up. If trucks were indeed driven mainly autonomously, then the driver would have more breaks between work, which would translate into greater interest in this career path. The profile of the employee would also likely change, from a driver to a programmer who, in the event of a failure, would perform software or hardware checks on the machine and restore it to full efficiency on their own.

Automated warehouses are becoming a trend
Warehouses, automated at least to some extent, are an increasingly frequent choice among companies in the e-commerce sector. We see this trend among our tenants and industry leaders, such as Amazon or Zalando. Consumers who expect delivery of ordered products on the same day have a significant impact on this situation. This increases the need to speed up the picking and shipping process so that goods reach customers as quickly as possible.

Robot suppliers are responding to the warehouse automation trend by not only selling machines but also leasing them, which reduces business operating costs. Renting a robot is in many cases more profitable than hiring another employee. Research conducted by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development shows that companies that effectively use digital technologies are ten times more productive than those that do not. It is a mistake to think that robots take jobs away from people, because using them often requires additional tasks from employees controlling the machines’ work and additional people needed to be hired among the contractors of a given automated warehouse. There are also various methods of cooperation between automation and humans, such as the “Pick by Light” system, which involves using illuminated screens and lights that turn on in the appropriate location in the warehouse to find goods or products needed to complete an order. Thanks to this, the operator can more efficiently find specific items and read their quantity.

Automation and robotization of warehouses will undoubtedly continue. The reason for this is primarily the situation on the labor market and the costs of hiring employees. Furthermore, the coronavirus pandemic has convinced the logistics industry that machines will contribute to minimizing costs and increasing the competitiveness of companies. However, it will take a long time before warehouses are fully automated, and even in such a case, excluding humans from warehouse work will be impossible. In my opinion, the most effective way for warehouses to function is the cooperation of “flesh and blood” employees with machines.