
The Electric Vehicles Promotion Foundation (FPPE) is launching the #stopCNG campaign, aimed at debunking the myth that gas-powered buses are eco-friendly. The main goal of the campaign is to raise public awareness about the true costs of using CNG vehicles. Together with other pro-ecological organizations, the FPPE is calling on the government to stop supporting natural gas as a fuel and is educating local governments about the actual costs of investing in gas buses.
Gas buses exacerbate the air pollution problem
CNG gas buses are vehicles that use fossil fuel; each such vehicle generates exhaust fumes and contributes to the climate crisis by emitting large amounts of CO2. Despite this, one can encounter gas buses on city streets, e.g., in Warsaw, with an “I am eco-friendly” sticker. The FPPE does not agree with this description. Studies1 and reports2 confirm that CNG buses generate millions of microparticles that are particularly dangerous to health – causing respiratory diseases, cancer, and contributing to the development of Alzheimer’s disease. Microparticles, along with large amounts of ammonia, which is a byproduct of combustion, create a mixture that catalyzes smog. CNG buses also generate large amounts of greenhouse gases – studies confirm that even new diesels are more environmentally friendly in this respect.
– Every gas bus on city streets means deepening the air pollution problem. Local governments should invest in technologies that improve the situation. Gas buses are a socially and financially costly postponement of the necessary electrification of public transport. Meanwhile, the clock is ticking; every day we breathe polluted air and suffer the consequences – comments Rafał Bajczuk, a representative of Transport & Environment in Poland, a European non-governmental organization dealing with environmental protection in transport.
The real costs of CNG for local governments
Investing in gas buses, which enjoyed growing popularity in 2020 due to their low purchase price and subsidies, may tempt local governments looking for savings during the pandemic – which is why the FPPE, in parallel with pressure on the central administration, will be educating local officials. Materials on the true costs of purchasing a CNG bus will reach the 50 largest cities in Poland.
– We want to persuade and appeal to reason. Our campaign will reach the presidents and mayors of several dozen cities in Poland; we will also contact councilors and municipal public transport companies. Awareness of the harmfulness of CNG is too low; we will change that. Knowledge about the harmfulness and true costs of using CNG buses should be widespread among local officials – ultimately, they are the ones who make decisions about purchasing new buses in their localities – says Rafał Bajczuk.
The report “The CNG bus market in public transport in Poland”, prepared by Polityka Insight, clearly shows that the costs of using CNG buses are ultimately higher than using electric buses. This situation is influenced by the costs of building infrastructure, vehicle maintenance, and gas prices. However, this calculation does not take into account the difficult-to-estimate social costs caused by diseases of residents and premature deaths caused by polluted air.
Knowledge about the harmfulness of CNG buses is publicly available; in 2020, the FPPE, together with its partners, unsuccessfully appealed for an end to the priority treatment of gas vehicles. In 2020, the European Union committed to greater greenhouse gas emission reductions. The government talks about the need for Poland to achieve climate neutrality as quickly as possible. And yet, it continues to support and promote natural gas. The #stopCNG campaign aims to persuade the government to change its position.
Activists representing the FPPE, the Greenpeace Poland Foundation, the WWF Poland Foundation, the Institute of Civil Affairs, and the Polish Ecological Club Mazovian District are calling for:
1. Covering CNG and LNG gas fuel with excise tax;
2. Eliminating support instruments for the purchase of vehicles powered by CNG and LNG, both from EU funds and Polish funds (FNT and NFOŚ);
3. Excluding CNG vehicles from entering clean transport zones.
– Every fossil fuel is deadly to the climate, and natural gas is no exception. Climate change and air quality are among the greatest Polish challenges in the 21st century, which is why the government should abandon subsidizing CNG vehicles and focus on supporting zero-emission electric vehicles – this is a real action for improving air quality and climate neutrality. It is time to say stop to gas vehicles on our roads – concludes Marcin Korolec, President of the FPPE.
1 Report by the organization Transport & Environment “Compressed natural gas vehicles cannot be a clean solution for transport”, https://www.transportenvironment.org/sites/te/files/2020_06_CNG_particle_exec_summary_PL.pdf
2 Polityka Insight report “The CNG bus market in public transport in Poland”, https://www.politykainsight.pl/raporty/autobusycng








