⚙️
🌟 Najlepsze dopasowanie
Wpisz szukaną frazę, aby zobaczyć propozycje AI.

The struggles of Polish SMEs with global internet giants

Photo: Pixabay

Many companies – mainly small and medium-sized ones – had to move online overnight to survive the pandemic and lockdown. E-commerce is a huge opportunity for them, but it also brings many challenges, such as competition from global sales giants that often use unfair practices to maintain low prices and high sales.

– The pandemic has changed the Polish e-commerce market in terms of value, which is now estimated at approx. PLN 100 billion, as well as size, because almost 11,000 new online stores were created by the end of the year – points out Patrycja Sass-Staniszewska, President of the Chamber of Electronic Economy.
Data from Gemius for the e-Chamber shows that 73% of Polish internet users are already shopping online, which means a record increase of 11 percentage points compared to last year. The Polish e-commerce market was growing dynamically even before the pandemic, which further accelerated this growth and the process of migrating customers from offline to online.

– In recent months, consumer activity online has been enormous – almost 2/3 of Poles shop systematically online and do so safely because their rights have been protected. On the other hand, we have suppliers, usually small and medium-sized enterprises, that often use e-commerce platforms. These companies were thrown in at the deep end. At the moment when their stores were closed, they had to move their business to the web very quickly, almost overnight. There was no time or funds to create their own platforms or websites – says Tomasz Janik, President of the Polish Economic Society.

A new Gemius report shows that in April last year alone, 137% more new online stores were established on the Shoper platform, which provides ready-made software for e-stores, than a year earlier. The most were in the grocery industry (26%), gifts (21%), and books and multimedia (20%).
– The pandemic influenced a change in thinking for both large and small entrepreneurs. Small and medium-sized entrepreneurs transformed digitally because for most of them it was the only lifeline to survive in such difficult times – says Patrycja Sass-Staniszewska, President of the Chamber of Electronic Economy.

Many SMEs were not ready for the accelerated migration to online. They lacked the tools or know-how related to, for example, positioning their company on the internet. This is also confirmed by the May edition of the KRD “SME Coronabalance” survey. However, small entrepreneurs adapted most quickly to the new reality, with 62.5% of them planning active online operations as early as May. Service and trade companies also proved to be best prepared for online sales, with more than half of them (54% and 52%, respectively) being able to conduct at least part of their business online.
The rapid development of e-commerce in recent years has led to a real arms race in this market. For customers, price is key, but so is the quality of service and delivery punctuality. Therefore, every entity operating in the industry must improve operations and increase competitiveness. This applies to all areas of activity – from investing in the appearance of the e-store to mobile applications, quality of service, and logistics, which translates into delivery speed and final consumer satisfaction. Small companies often cannot afford this, which is why they launch sales through large e-commerce platforms. These provide infrastructure and appropriate tools in a marketplace model, but on the other hand, they use their dominant position against small sellers.

– In Poland, this problem is not yet so pronounced today, but it will probably appear when foreign platforms begin to enter the Polish market more dynamically – says Tomasz Janik. – The experiences of other markets, including the American one, show that such platforms monopolize sales. For approx. 40% of companies selling in e-commerce, this is their only source of revenue. It is difficult to compete with a platform that has, among other things, a full database and information about which products sell how and how they are positioned.

As he points out, a pain point for smaller companies is, among other things, a mixed sales model, i.e., the ability for an e-commerce platform to sell its own-brand products right next to the products of entrepreneurs to whom it provides infrastructure for running their own business.
– Introducing competitive products under one’s own brand directly affects positioning. It creates a threat to the sales of small and medium-sized companies – explains the President of the Polish Economic Society. – Algorithms set in the systems prefer their own products. This is an element that must be regulated in some way so that we have access to distribution channels on equal terms. We know perfectly well that large platforms monopolize the market, and monopoly affects consumers.

The problem of the dominant position of e-commerce giants towards small sellers is clearly visible in the example of the American market and Amazon. This year’s report of the Judiciary Committee to the US Congress highlighted a number of monopolistic practices used by this platform. Amazon, among other things, constantly increases the margin charged to merchants (in 2015 it was 19%, now 30%) and uses the Buy Box algorithm, effectively deciding on its own which entrepreneur will sell their product and make a profit from the sale.
This platform faces problems not only in its home market. European regulators also notice that the giant uses practices that could potentially threaten local economies. For example, in October 2020, the French government intervened in a promotional program introduced by Amazon, which aimed to significantly lower product prices as part of the pre-Christmas “pre-Black Friday” campaign. The French authorities considered this practice harmful to small and medium-sized enterprises, against which it constituted price dumping. The EU Commissioner for Competition, Margrethe Vestager, also took a stand. She emphasized that Amazon is not only a sales platform but also a Big Data company that violates competition by weakening the market position of small and medium-sized enterprises, which is already significantly strained by the ongoing pandemic.

Another problem is unfair practices by sellers from China, i.e., sending goods in such a way as to avoid paying customs duties or VAT on them. According to the Community customs exemption system, low-value shipments (up to 150 euros) sent directly from a third country to a recipient in the EU are exempt from customs duties. In turn, VAT does not have to be paid on shipments worth up to 22 euros. Non-commercial shipments, i.e., gifts, worth less than 45 euros are also exempt from these fees.
– Chinese entrepreneurs sell products without tax, customs duty, understating the price and value of the shipment, and often also send these products as gifts. Therefore, right from the start, it is very difficult for a Polish entrepreneur to compete with Asian entrepreneurs – explains Patrycja Sass-Staniszewska.
As the NIK report shows, presented on the basis of inspections from 2017-2019, in cross-border electronic commerce, regulations are bypassed precisely by understating the value of purchased goods, lack of product descriptions or false information about them, splitting shipments into smaller ones, or declaring commercial shipments as gifts. The problem is an insufficient system of control and supervision. During the audited period, it was based on physical inspections of selected shipments, however, only 1% of postal shipments and 4% of courier shipments were verified.
– As the Chamber of Electronic Economy, we have been running the “Same Start” campaign for a year, the goal of which is equal legal frameworks for Polish and Asian entrepreneurs. We do not want Polish entrepreneurs to be treated better, but equally with Asian entrepreneurs. The point is for shipments from Asia to be checked and, if necessary, subject to customs duties and taxes. In conditions of fair competition, the number of Polish small and medium-sized enterprises in e-commerce will certainly grow even more dynamically and they will be able to boldly expand with foreign sales – says the President of the Chamber of Electronic Economy.

Source: Newseria

Read also about electronic commerce:
– Polish e-commerce 2020
– Frisbo enters Poland
– Home shopping with SPAR and Everli