
The digitalization of logistics processes is progressing every year. The use of TMS or WMS software or vehicle positioning is no longer surprising, and despite the widespread need to improve the way proof of carriage is provided, Europe is still struggling with the implementation of solutions enabling the use of electronic (digital) consignment notes. For several years, the forwarding industry has been using various provisions in transport orders aimed at enforcing the fastest possible delivery of documents confirming the delivery of cargo to the recipient. However, a problem arises when the driver is on the road for up to 3 weeks, and sending documents via public operators is often time-consuming. Hence the question: is the use of various types of penalties for failure to deliver consignment notes within a specified period legal?
Łukasz Chwalczuk – partner at the Iuridica Law Firm, President of the Management Board of OSPTN, ESTA Europe Board Member: Common courts have dealt with this issue many times, citing, among others, the content of the Act on Counteracting Excessive Delays in Commercial Transactions, which prevents the use of clauses in orders that contradict the principle of the contract of carriage. While judicial decisions are increasingly protecting the obligation to pay for the transport service performed (delivery of the shipment) even if transport documents are delivered later than provided for in the order, the solution to this problem would be the widespread use of electronic consignment notes. The availability and low costs of mobile internet fully enable the issuance of an electronic consignment note using electronic communication – in accordance with the Additional Protocol to the Convention on the Contract for the International Carriage of Goods by Road (CMR) concerning the electronic consignment note, drawn up in Geneva on February 20, 2008. However, as long as European countries do not take clear legislative action in this direction, the use of e-CMR will continue to be difficult. Polish transport law (see Art. 47 sec. 3) provides the possibility of using “electronic transmission”, but this is still a rarely encountered solution.
Work carried out by the European Commission on eFTI (Electronic Freight Transport Information) is at an advanced level, and the current problems caused by the SARS-Cov-2 epidemic should accelerate the implementation of changes in the European legal order. The benefits of the widespread use of e-CMR are undeniable. Confirmation of shipment delivery in real-time, availability of information for control authorities, or even the possibility of maintaining the confidentiality of certain data. It turns out, therefore, that the use of electronic consignment notes could be a solution for those companies that expect the so-called neutralization of consignment notes. The ability to automate the entry of data into the e-CMR will also be a solution to common problems related to the incorrect completion of consignment notes, which often cause insurers to refuse to pay compensation. Such popular refusals resulting from the lack of the full name and address of the carrier in the consignment note will cease to be a cause-excuse for avoiding the liability of insurance companies based on OCP policies.
It remains, therefore, to support actions on eFTI and encourage business partners (senders, loaders, recipients, logistics companies) to switch to the digital circulation of transport documents.








