
The pace of change resulting from technological development forces a re-evaluation of existing business models – this challenge is becoming increasingly obvious to managers today. On one hand, the existing experience of companies in the area of broadly defined process automation, and on the other, the increasingly uncertain future of the growth rate of many industries, open up a field for a broader discussion on the aspects of cooperation between people and devices performing work in increasingly automated factories and warehouses. How to reconcile the understandable and obvious desire to improve work methods and tools with the adaptation of employees to new working conditions? This is an increasingly common dilemma that managers, designers of IT and ergonomic solutions, as well as HR specialists must face.
The discussed issue fits into the concept of Social Networked Industry, which is still little known in Poland. According to experts from the Fraunhofer Institute for Material Flow and Logistics (IML) in Dortmund, the most important distinguishing feature of this concept is placing the human being increasingly at the center of activities related to logistics and production. Moreover, they emphasize that an important task of the Social Networked Industry is related to a kind of anticipation of specific human skills and needs, especially in the sphere of communication and interaction with autonomously operating cyber-physical systems, which are a key element of Industry 4.0.
From this seemingly important observation, it can be concluded that the issue of automation, and thus human-machine interaction, should be considered not only in economic terms, such as efficiency and return on investment. The key to success is increasing employee competence and ensuring a balance between the pursuit of economic benefits and concern for the safety and health of employees.
Controversial help? The example of exoskeletons
Undoubtedly, the idea of supporting physical work in warehouses through the use of exoskeletons (which we wrote about in the previous issue of Logistyka magazine – 2/2020) deserves more attention, if only – or perhaps primarily – because it speaks in favor of the employees. These devices were designed precisely to relieve them of work requiring great physical effort. This argument, justifying their use, is supported by specific data and analyses. According to 2012 Eurofound research, 30 percent of work (operations) performed in connection with moving loads consisted of manual labor. In turn, the European Agency for Health and Safety at Work defines this problem as one of the most significant challenges in the area of work ergonomics in Europe. This is indicated by studies showing that 63 percent of employees perform repetitive tasks, and as many as 46 percent perform them in a position that poses a health risk.
On the other hand, the use of exoskeletons in the workplace can raise doubts because, at the current stage of large-scale implementation, it is difficult to determine the consequences of their impact on the body in the long term. Due to the limited experience of companies related to the operation of these devices in industrial or warehouse realities, the authors of the aforementioned document emphasize the aspect of the little-studied impact on the human musculoskeletal system. A comprehensive assessment of the impact on the work environment is associated with the need for cross-sectional studies in many areas, including physiological and biomechanical factors. In the first case, it is about diagnosing any sense of discomfort felt by the employee resulting from wearing the device during a several-hour workday.
Who teaches whom? The example of cobots
In the case of using cobots, one can speak of a high degree of safety in the context of human-machine interaction. Research presented by Universal Robots indicates that these devices can contribute significantly to eliminating many workplace accidents. Another property that is positive from the point of view of ergonomics and work safety (resulting from the very design of these devices) is that they have been designed in a way that resembles human/employee behavior. Their work does not require special safety measures to protect employees. Another important functional feature of cobots deserves to be highlighted, as it were “derived” from the name itself (collaborative robots), namely their “innate” (programmed) ability to cooperate directly. A cobot does not only help the employee in a “passive” way, but also gives them the opportunity for actual interaction. In this case, the employee directly involved in a given process can easily reprogram the device themselves (the fact that they are programmed before “starting work” is an obvious issue). This is possible because the employee has a control panel (Human-Machine Interface – HMI) at their disposal. Of course, from the point of view of designers and programmers, the aforementioned interface is nothing new, but it is worth remembering its functionality also – or perhaps above all – from the point of view of work ergonomics. Another positive aspect is that thanks to the “proximity” of the device, the employees themselves quickly acquire new skills.
– Many positions and tasks in the production environment are characterized by low ergonomics. Collaborative robots can relieve employees from performing monotonous, dirty, or dangerous activities. While robots perform these tasks in an automated way, employees can engage in other tasks that require human creativity, bring higher satisfaction and profit from work, and are not burdensome to health. We are therefore improving both safety, work quality, and team morale. Collaborative robots have been designed to work with humans without additional safety measures, such as fencing or light curtains (always after a risk assessment of the entire workstation). Thanks to this, the operator can use cobots as a production tool, e.g., for pick and place operations, operating heavy machinery, or packing or palletizing bulky materials. Although the most frequently emphasized advantages of cobots and robotization seen more broadly are economic benefits – accelerating processes, increasing efficiency, reducing costs or material losses, improving safety in the workplace, and the ergonomics of tasks and workstations is a very important aspect pointed out by many clients. An example is the Unilever plant in Katowice, where 6 UR10 cobots took over work at the end of the lines – this was met with a positive reception from employees who, before the robotization of the workstations, stacked products on pallets from the lowest layers to the highest, working for many hours in an uncomfortable position. The complete automation of palletizing by cobots meant that operators were relieved of 30% of their tasks. Cobots perform the most arduous work and are extremely efficient at it – they place approx. 1100 cartons on pallets during an eight-hour shift – said Krzysztof Hajzyk, Channel Development Manager, Universal Robots.
How to present the cooperation of employees and devices and the effects of their cooperation in the era of Industry 4.0 in an interesting and unconventional way? For example, the Bosch company encourages an unusual journey to the factory of the future.









