Transport is not profitable, or who rules the TSL industry?

Transport is not profitable, or who rules the TSL industry?

The average rating of a company’s financial situation given by representatives of the transport industry is 3.31. On a five-point scale, this three-plus is quite poor. Since Eurostat shows that in 2018 exports in European Union countries grew by 4.7 percent and imports by 5.4 percent, the demand for international road transport is high. It is worth noting that recently the number of registered trucks has increased by 8 percent to 29.9 thousand units, and the amount of goods transported in tons has increased by 18 percent2. The data indicate the good condition of Polish transport companies. It turns out, however, that despite their position, it is not the entrepreneurs who dictate the terms on the market. The TSL sector in Poland and Europe is ruled by the client.

Industrial production, the growth of trade exchange, or the development of the e-commerce industry – all this influences the growing demand for transport services. It is estimated that 80 percent of the world’s goods transport takes place by land. It would seem, therefore, that entrepreneurs could dictate the terms. Nothing could be further from the truth.

– Polish transporters are very fragmented. According to market data, 95 percent are small and medium-sized companies, often family-owned, operating on average from 4 to 8 trucks. Such businesses are particularly susceptible to any fluctuations, including, among others, changes in diesel prices, increases in wages, and administrative duties related to labor costs – says Kamil Wolański, an expert at the National Center for Driver Settlement (OCRK). – Furthermore, fragmentation does not serve competitiveness. Recently, OCRK asked its clients what they fear most when thinking about the future of the transport industry. In addition to the lack of qualified staff, which has been the number one problem for another year, keeping carriers awake at night, as many as 29 percent of respondents pointed to growing competition from Eastern European countries, and 26 percent to competitors in other countries of the EU Community – he adds.

Is transport profitable?
A carrier, when setting the price for freight, should take into account all the costs they must incur while executing an order. Therefore, the revenue for the transported cargo should not be lower than the expenses incurred. Transporters calculate the fee for the work performed in different ways. Some provide a price for the completed transport, while others count the number of kilometers traveled. The average rate for transported freight is about 3.23 PLN/km, assuming the driver has traveled 10,000 km. What do entrepreneurs do to gain a client? They compete with prices, lowering the offered amount for transporting the cargo.

– It is worth emphasizing that the issue does not only concern Poland, but also other European countries. For example, in Germany, a similar practice is used as in our country, which negatively affects the financial condition of carriers. Companies increasingly have a problem with payment backlogs and are balancing on the edge of profitability. According to data from the National Debt Register, transport companies – to leasing companies alone – have over 112 million PLN to pay back3. If entrepreneurs did not transport cargo below a certain rate, the client would have to pay more, and the contractor would not incur financial losses – explains Kamil Wolański, an OCRK expert.

Subcontractor exchange
The most commonly used practice is the so-called order from a freight forwarder. Contractors establish cooperation with a forwarder who is looking for an available carrier. In the negotiation process between the parties, a template of the contract is presented, which the carrier undertakes to sign if they accept the terms of cooperation. They have no possibility of introducing any modifications to the provisions and are obliged to fulfill all points of the contract. What is worth paying attention to in such a situation?

– The most frequently appearing provision is the obligation to pay a specific financial penalty for non-performance or improper performance of the order. In the event that, for example, there is a late arrival of the vehicle for loading/unloading or the monthly number of kilometers is not achieved, then carriers are obliged to pay a contractual penalty. The average fine that a carrier can be charged for breach of contract is from 5 to 7.5 thousand zlotys. Drivers are very afraid of high penalties resulting from the provisions of the SENT Act, which concerns the supervision of the transport of so-called sensitive goods, where they often do not have much influence on possible violations – explains Wolański.

Besides, contractors delay payment deadlines for services rendered. Due to the fact that there is a possibility of concluding contracts by entities based throughout the EU, the payment time is longer than 30 or even 60 days. This is due to the fact that the period for settling receivables is not counted from the moment the service is performed, but from the moment the documents are delivered to the principal, which significantly extends the deadline for obtaining overdue money. Small companies, therefore, struggle with payment backlogs.

– It is also worth noting that the contract that a carrier concludes with a forwarder often includes a clause regarding the possibility of its termination. However, as it turns out, it is not that simple. The termination of the contract is preceded by a several-month notice period. This means that the transport company is still obliged to work for a given client. The carrier-forwarder/principal relationship is not easy, and currently, with such high market fragmentation, it less and less often constitutes long-term cooperation based on mutual benefits and respect – adds the OCRK expert.

1 Transcash report, July 2019.
2 ZMPD and GUS data.
3 KRD data regarding debts to leasing companies: https://krd.pl/Centrum-prasowe/Informacje-prasowe/2019/Branza-leasingowa-rosnie-i-liczy-dluznikow