
The main focus of this article is a comparison of two systems for the simulation of logistics processes. These are software packages from CLASS and FlexSim. The FlexSim software is already used by the authors of the article, while the CLASS software was indicated by a logistics operator with whom the authors collaborate. The operator is a global company. Simulation software should have the capability to model, simulate, predict, and visualize systems in areas including: production, material handling, healthcare, warehouses (including High-Bay Warehouses), processes in mines and power plants, logistics, etc.
Such systems should be simultaneously functional, flexible, and user-friendly. If the software meets these assumptions, it helps to optimize currently existing processes in these institutions or companies and to plan entirely new ones. Additionally, it is possible to reduce and identify losses, cut costs, and increase company revenue. Optimal use of organizational resources (people, equipment), improvement of organizational structure flexibility, and cost minimization are only selected goals set by companies participating in the market battle for the customer.
Unfortunately, choosing the right process simulation software is difficult. Very often, this is a problem due to the wide range of process simulation tools currently available. Knowledge on this subject can be drawn from professional literature (books, journals, conference materials, e.g., Winter Simulation Conference), internet sources dedicated to simulation tools, and one can also gain free access to the source codes of such software.
The structure of the article is as follows: section 2 describes the logistics processes carried out in High-Bay Warehouses (MWS), section 3 presents a brief analysis of literature regarding the simulation of logistics processes, and section 4 describes the criteria that, in the authors’ opinion, are worth considering when choosing software. The last section contains a comparison of two systems: CLASS and FlexSim. Final conclusions and the justification for choosing the best system are defined in point 6.
Logistics processes in High-Bay Warehouses (MWS)
A logistics process is an ordered and coordinated chain of operations related to the flow of materials. The result of a logistics process is a logistics service. A logistics service, in turn, is the transport or storage of a logistics product in quality, quantity, and time consistent with customer expectations. Processes carried out in MWS warehouses can be divided into internal processes and processes within the scope of receiving and issuing goods from the warehouse. There are, therefore, three groups of processes. Each of these processes can be appropriately optimized and redesigned to meet the requirements set by the company.
Below is an example list of internal processes of the studied warehouse:
– product freezing process after receipt,
– meat deboning process,
– process of selecting appropriate storage locations,
– configuration of picking locations with appropriate assortment (minimum as well as maximum quantity of goods, saturation level),
– arrangement of the picking path,
– continuous inventory in the picking process,
– appropriate labeling of storage locations and buffers for storage chambers,
– analysis of picker performance (reaction to poor efficiency),
– management (existence of EDI interfaces),
– when goods are entrusted – invoicing of services (for each logistics operation we generate a so-called service specification, and based on the price lists of each service, an invoice is generated for the client),
– change of states (statuses) of goods stored in the MWS warehouse, e.g., goods awaiting quality inspection, goods during microbiological quarantine, goods from returns – possible inter-warehouse movements, damaged goods, goods blocked by the client, blocked goods – possible releases to the manufacturer, etc.,
– any changes in the ownership of goods in the warehouse – already at the stage of storing products (e.g., entrusted), it becomes possible to change the ownership of products from one contractor and take over (e.g., purchase) by another contractor,
– possibilities of changing parameters (e.g., features – certificate) describing and configured for a given batch of goods,
– process of warehouse transfers (e.g., pallets) from one place to another (e.g., warehouse),
– management of the product de-picking process, e.g., from returns,
– inventory of variable-weight products.
All the above processes can be appropriately improved so that their work efficiency can be enhanced. Below are the processes that are intended to deliver (receive) products to the warehouse:
– delivery notification,
– cross-docking,
– receipt into the warehouse – generation of location transfers and searching for appropriate storage locations,
– own and manufacturer labeling,
– weighing of goods,
– checking the temperature of goods (shortening measurement time, 33 pallets per TIR) + manufacturer labeling,
– replenishment of picking locations for picking needs at the time of receipt,
– using the Shelf Life option for receiving goods.
The article contains 19,070 characters.
Source: Logistyka Magazine
L3-29_Mendlikowski_Pawlewski_Porownanie_oprogramowania_do_symulacji.pdf








